scholarly journals Seven Primary Data Types in Citizen Science Determine Data Quality Requirements and Methods

2021 ◽  
Vol 3 ◽  
Author(s):  
Robert D. Stevenson ◽  
Todd Suomela ◽  
Heejun Kim ◽  
Yurong He

Data quality (DQ) is a major concern in citizen science (CS) programs and is often raised as an issue among critics of the CS approach. We examined CS programs and reviewed the kinds of data they produce to inform CS communities of strategies of DQ control. From our review of the literature and our experiences with CS, we identified seven primary types of data contributions. Citizens can carry instrument packages, invent or modify algorithms, sort and classify physical objects, sort and classify digital objects, collect physical objects, collect digital objects, and report observations. We found that data types were not constrained by subject domains, a CS program may use multiple types, and DQ requirements and evaluation strategies vary according to the data types. These types are useful for identifying structural similarities among programs across subject domains. We conclude that blanket criticism of the CS data quality is no longer appropriate. In addition to the details of specific programs and variability among individuals, discussions can fruitfully focus on the data types in a program and the specific methods being used for DQ control as dictated or appropriate for the type. Programs can reduce doubts about their DQ by becoming more explicit in communicating their data management practices.

Author(s):  
Abraham Nieva de la Hidalga ◽  
Alex Hardisty

The definition of a digital specimen is proposed to encompass the digital representation(s) of physical specimens from natural science collections. The digital specimen concept is intended to define a representation (digital object) that brings together an array of heterogeneous data types, which are themselves alternative physical specimen representations. In this case, the digital specimen (DS) holds references to specimen data from a collection management system, images, 3D models, research articles, DNA sequences, collector information, among many other data types. The proposal is to create persistent relationships between the DS and other categories of digital objects (e.g. resource types mentioned above, collections, storage platforms, organisations, databases, and provenance data). Complying with FAIR data principles (findability, accessibility, interoperability, and reuse), i.e., achieving data ‘FAIRness’, eases data integration, which is needed for cross-disciplinary linking and combination of data from different domains, making the DS as a comprehensive package of information about a specimen. Implementation and access to a digital specimen repository (DSR) as a Digital Object Architecture (Sharp 2016) component demonstrates the alignment of the DS concept and FAIR data principles (Wilkinson et al. 2016, Kahn and Wilensky 2006). The DSR fulfills four roles: data producer, resource manager, data publisher, and collaboration space. As data producer, the DSR allows acquisition and curation (indexing, storage) of DSs linking primary data, models, analyses, and other digital object types. As resource manager, the DSR manages access to distributed platforms, ranging from acquisition networks (digitisation stations, museums, herbariums) to processing services, advanced computational resources, data asset storage systems, and specialised servers. As data publisher, the DSR provides access to data assets from national and transnational data archives. As collaboration space, the DSR supports users’ accessing, sharing and (re)using data assets, and derived data products and services. Adopting the collaboration space and data publisher roles, the DSR implements interfaces that expose the DSs to the research community, fulfilling the FAIR findability, accessibility, and reuse principles. Adopting the data producer and resource manager roles, the DSR creates meaningful and persistent relationships required to link DSs and other types of digital objects, fulfilling the FAIR interoperability principle. A prototype DSR based on the Cordra digital object repository has been deployed (Corporation for National Research Initiatives (CNRI) 2018, Reilly and Tupelo-Schneck 2010). The advantages of Cordra are: rapid deployment, customisable object model, creation of relations between digital objects, and application program interfaces for programmatic access. Rapid deployment of the DSR provides a tangible target for discussing the implementation of the DS concept. The customisable object model enables the refinement and enhancing of the definition of DS in response to feedback from colleagues who have accessed the DSR and used its contents. Creating relations between digital objects enables flexible linking to digital objects stored in different repositories. Accessing the DSR programmatically through APIs enables extending the use of the repository in different platforms (e.g. mobile devices) as well as integration with other repositories and services. As well as supporting a HTTP-oriented API, Cordra implements Digital Object Interface Protocol (DONA Foundation 2018), allowing the definition of operations to act directly on selected DSs in the repository. The DSR prototype has been demonstrated by providing access to the repository administrative interface and with a custom interface designed to facilitate access by different user groups, such as collection curators, researchers, teachers, and students. The client interface has been designed to demonstrate a subset of the functionalities derived from user stories, which describe software features from the end-user perspective. Demonstrating the DSR capabilities as proposed, will inform the refinement of the design of the DS model and provide early feedback about the needed software features.


2018 ◽  
Vol 15 (2) ◽  
pp. 1-20
Author(s):  
Sabri Embi ◽  
Zurina Shafii

The purpose of this study is to examine the impact of Shariah governance and corporate governance (CG) on the risk management practices (RMPs) of local Islamic banks and foreign Islamic banks operating in Malaysia. The Shariah governance comprises the Shariah review (SR) and Shariah audit (SA) variables. The study also evaluates the level of RMPs, CG, SR, and SA between these two type of banks. With the aid of SPSS version 20, the items for RMPs, CG, SR, and SA were subjected to principal component analysis (PCA). From the PCA, one component or factor was extracted each for the CG, SR, and RMPs while another two factors were extracted for the SA. Primary data was collected using a self-administered survey questionnaire. The questionnaire covers four aspects ; CG, SR, SA, and RMPs. The data received from the 300 usable questionnaires were subjected to correlation and regression analyses as well as an independent t-test. The result of correlation analysis shows that all the four variables have large positive correlations with each other indicating a strong and significant relationship between them. From the regression analysis undertaken, CG, SR, and SA together explained 52.3 percent of the RMPs and CG emerged as the most influential variable that impacts the RMPs. The independent t-test carried out shows that there were significant differences in the CG and SA between the local and foreign Islamic banks. However, there were no significant differences between the two types of the bank in relation to SR and RMPs. The study has contributed to the body of knowledge and is beneficial to academicians, industry players, regulators, and other stakeholders.


Mathematics ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 9 (8) ◽  
pp. 875
Author(s):  
Jesus Cerquides ◽  
Mehmet Oğuz Mülâyim ◽  
Jerónimo Hernández-González ◽  
Amudha Ravi Shankar ◽  
Jose Luis Fernandez-Marquez

Over the last decade, hundreds of thousands of volunteers have contributed to science by collecting or analyzing data. This public participation in science, also known as citizen science, has contributed to significant discoveries and led to publications in major scientific journals. However, little attention has been paid to data quality issues. In this work we argue that being able to determine the accuracy of data obtained by crowdsourcing is a fundamental question and we point out that, for many real-life scenarios, mathematical tools and processes for the evaluation of data quality are missing. We propose a probabilistic methodology for the evaluation of the accuracy of labeling data obtained by crowdsourcing in citizen science. The methodology builds on an abstract probabilistic graphical model formalism, which is shown to generalize some already existing label aggregation models. We show how to make practical use of the methodology through a comparison of data obtained from different citizen science communities analyzing the earthquake that took place in Albania in 2019.


2021 ◽  
Vol 444 ◽  
pp. 109453
Author(s):  
Camille Van Eupen ◽  
Dirk Maes ◽  
Marc Herremans ◽  
Kristijn R.R. Swinnen ◽  
Ben Somers ◽  
...  

2021 ◽  
Vol 10 (4) ◽  
pp. 207
Author(s):  
Annie Gray ◽  
Colin Robertson ◽  
Rob Feick

Citizen science initiatives span a wide range of topics, designs, and research needs. Despite this heterogeneity, there are several common barriers to the uptake and sustainability of citizen science projects and the information they generate. One key barrier often cited in the citizen science literature is data quality. Open-source tools for the analysis, visualization, and reporting of citizen science data hold promise for addressing the challenge of data quality, while providing other benefits such as technical capacity-building, increased user engagement, and reinforcing data sovereignty. We developed an operational citizen science tool called the Community Water Data Analysis Tool (CWDAT)—a R/Shiny-based web application designed for community-based water quality monitoring. Surveys and facilitated user-engagement were conducted among stakeholders during the development of CWDAT. Targeted recruitment was used to gather feedback on the initial CWDAT prototype’s interface, features, and potential to support capacity building in the context of community-based water quality monitoring. Fourteen of thirty-two invited individuals (response rate 44%) contributed feedback via a survey or through facilitated interaction with CWDAT, with eight individuals interacting directly with CWDAT. Overall, CWDAT was received favourably. Participants requested updates and modifications such as water quality thresholds and indices that reflected well-known barriers to citizen science initiatives related to data quality assurance and the generation of actionable information. Our findings support calls to engage end-users directly in citizen science tool design and highlight how design can contribute to users’ understanding of data quality. Enhanced citizen participation in water resource stewardship facilitated by tools such as CWDAT may provide greater community engagement and acceptance of water resource management and policy-making.


2016 ◽  
Vol 30 (3) ◽  
pp. 447-449 ◽  
Author(s):  
Roman Lukyanenko ◽  
Jeffrey Parsons ◽  
Yolanda F. Wiersma
Keyword(s):  

Author(s):  
Abu Hanifa Md. Noman ◽  
Md. Amzad Hossain ◽  
Sajeda Pervin

Objective - The study aims to investigate credit risk management practices and credit risk management strategies of the local private commercial banks in Bangladesh. Methodology -The investigation is conducted based on primary data collected from a set of both closed end and open end questionnaire from 23 out of 39 local private commercial banks in Bangladesh. Descriptive statistics has been used in processing the data and interpreting the results. Findings - The results reveal that credit risk management practice of the sample banks is sound which is attributed to the appropriate implementation of Basel II and credit risk management guidelines the country's central bank. The findings further show that use of Credit risk grading is most popular and effective criteria for measuring the borrowing capacity of the borrowers. In order to control credit risk and preventing losses from credit exposure banks give more focus on collateralization, accurate loan pricing and third party guarantee. Loan is monitored properly and credit reminder is given to the client if principal and interest remain outstanding for three months. The study further reveals that lack of experienced and trained credit officers, lack of genuine market information and Lack of awareness regarding non-genuine borrower are the most important problems of current credit risk management practices in Bangladesh. Novelty - To the best of the knowledge of the authors the study is the first that investigates credit risk management strategies of private commercial banks, especially on Bangladesh. Type of Paper - Empirical Keyword : Bangladesh; Commercial Bank; Credit risk; Credit risk management; Credit risk management strategies.


Author(s):  
Lemarimpe N Parsumpat ◽  
Shadrack Bett

The purpose of change management is to implement strategies for effecting change, controlling change and helping people to adapt to change. Change management is a systematic approach to dealing with the transition or transformation of an organization's goals, processes or technologies. The National government Constituency development fund to counties has made a great impact, with numerous projects coming up throughout the country. The initiation of the development projects at grassroots level have led to significant rise in wellbeing of citizens in the constituency and county at large. The general objective of this study was to assess change management practices and how it relates to performance of national government CDF funded projects in Bomet County in Kenya. The specific objectives of the study were; to determine the influence of leadership on performance of the national development funded projects in Bomet County, to establish how stakeholder’s involvement influences the performance of the national development funded projects in Bomet County, to assess the influence of resources allocation on performance of the national development funded projects in County and to find out the extent to which monitoring and evaluation influences the performance of the national development funded projects in Bomet County. The study was anchored on Kotter’s 8 step model and the theory of planned change. The study adopted a Census research design targeting all CDFC members and officials managing CDF projects in each of the five wards in Bomet County. The study utilized primary data. Primary data was collected using semi structured questionnaires. Data was analyzed using SPSS. Descriptive and inferential statistics were employed in the study. Analyzed data was presented in percentages, frequencies, mean and standard deviation. From the findings, the researcher can conclude that, change management practices through leadership, stakeholders’ involvement, resources, and monitoring and evaluation has a significant and positive composite effect on performance of NG-CDF in County. Leadership aspects that contribute to this performance includes leaders’ role model and championship capacity towards change management, ability to develop strategy, create mission, motivate people to achieve objectives, employees’ empowerment, and organizational culture change. The researcher therefore recommends that, NG-CDF leadership should observe change management practices by ensuring there is frequent stakeholders’ engagement, role model and championship capacity towards change management, ability to develop strategy, create mission, motivate people to achieve objectives, employees’ empowerment, and sound organizational culture change. https://www.ijcab.org/ ,[email protected] https://journals.ijcab.org/journals/index.php


2017 ◽  
Vol 16 (02) ◽  
pp. C05
Author(s):  
Stuart Allan ◽  
Joanna Redden

This article examines certain guiding tenets of science journalism in the era of big data by focusing on its engagement with citizen science. Having placed citizen science in historical context, it highlights early interventions intended to help establish the basis for an alternative epistemological ethos recognising the scientist as citizen and the citizen as scientist. Next, the article assesses further implications for science journalism by examining the challenges posed by big data in the realm of citizen science. Pertinent issues include potential risks associated with data quality, access dynamics, the difficulty investigating algorithms, and concerns about certain constraints impacting on transparency and accountability.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document