scholarly journals Static and Impact Response of a Single-Span Stone Masonry Arch

2021 ◽  
Vol 6 (12) ◽  
pp. 178
Author(s):  
Bora Pulatsu ◽  
Semih Gonen ◽  
Paulo B. Lourenço

Unreinforced masonry structures are susceptible to man-made hazards such as impact and blast loading. However, the literature on this subject mainly focuses on masonry wall behavior, and there is a knowledge gap about the behavior of masonry arches under high-strain loading. In this context, this research aims to investigate both quasistatic and impact response of a dry-joint stone masonry arch using the discrete element method. Rigid blocks with noncohesive joint models are adopted to simulate dry-joint assemblages. First, the employed modeling strategy is validated utilizing the available experimental findings, and then sensitivity analyses are performed for both static and impact loading, considering the effect of joint friction angle, contact stiffness, and damping parameters. The outcomes of this research strengthen the existing knowledge in the literature regarding the computational modeling of masonry structures that are subjected to usual and extreme loading conditions. The results highlight that applied discontinuum-based numerical models are more sensitive to stiffness parameters in high-strain loading than static analysis.

2021 ◽  
Vol 300 ◽  
pp. 01022
Author(s):  
Jiang Hu ◽  
Fuheng Ma

As commonly used canal system structures, masonry arch aqueducts constitute a significant proportion of Chinese old irrigation infrastructures. Most of these existing aqueducts are well over 50 years old, the deterioration of their constituent materials over time, as well as the development of other defects, significantly affects the mechanical responses of these structures. A deep understanding on the dominant factors that influence the structural safety behaviour of masonry arch aqueducts is essential for determining maintenance and strengthening strategies. Taken the Zhaimen masonry aqueduct in the famous Red Flag Canal as a case study, sensitivity analyses of the influences of mortar aging and loss on the structural performance were carried out. The aqueduct, with unknown geometric dimensions and uncertain physical and mechanical parameters, has defects such as the arch ring detaching from the upper structure and the continuous loss and falling of mortar. The discrete element method (DEM) was employed to analyse the structural behaviour. The results show that the upper structure and the supporting structure are stable under the no bond strength condition. When the mortar is lost locally, the vault position is the most dangerous, followed by the arch shoulder, and then the arch foot part. The mortar loss, manifested as denseness reduction, greatly affects the aqueduct stability. Conversely, the deterioration of the mechanical properties of the mortar, caused by weathering and Calcium ion dissolution due to ambient environment and aqueduct leakage, has relatively little impact on the structural safety. Supplementary grouting of the mortar between the stone masonry should be timely carried out to maintain the structural integrity to ensure the overall stability of the structure. The proposed approach can provide a reference to structural diagnosis and performance assessment for similar structures.


Meccanica ◽  
2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Marialaura Malena ◽  
Maurizio Angelillo ◽  
Antonio Fortunato ◽  
Gianmarco de Felice ◽  
Ida Mascolo

AbstractSettlements severely affect historic masonry arch bridges worldwide. There are countless examples of structural dislocations and ruins in recent years due to severe settlements at the base of pier foundations, often caused by shipworm infestation of wooden foundations or scouring and riverbed erosion phenomena. The present paper proposes an original way to approach the failure analysis of settled masonry arch bridges. The proposed method combines two different 2D numerical models for the prediction of masonry arch bridge capacity against settlements and for safety assessment. The first one is the Piecewise Rigid Displacement method, i.e. a block-based limit analysis approach using the well known Heyman's hypotheses; the second one is a continuous Finite Element approach. The case study of the four-span Deba Bridge (Spain, 2018) failure is presented with the aim to illustrate how the methods work. The failure analysis produced satisfactory results by applying both methods separately, in confirmation of their reliability. Their combination also allowed to obtain a significantly reduction in computational cost and an improvement of prediction accuracy. A sensitivity and a path-following analysis were also performed with the aim to demonstrate the robustness of the presented method. The obtained simulations highlighted that the results do not depend on the friction angle and that a proper prediction of the evolution of the structural behavior can be obtained only taking into account geometric nonlinearities. Such results demonstrate once again that in settled masonry arches geometry prevails over the mechanical parameters. The current study paves the way for the fruitful use of the proposed approaches for a wider range of applications, as, for example, the mechanism identification or the displacement capacity assessment of masonry structures under overloading as seismic loads.


2012 ◽  
Vol 6 (1) ◽  
pp. 119-120 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gabriele Milani

The Special Issue of The Open Civil Engineering Journal entitled “New trends in the numerical analysis of masonry structures” provides an insight into the most up-to-date nu-merical techniques used at academic and professional level to perform advanced structuralanalyses on masonry struc-tures. Masonry is a building material that has been used for more than ten thousand years. In many countries, masonry structures still amount to 30–50%of the new housing devel-opments. Also, most structures built before the 19th century and still surviving are built with masonry. Masonry is usu-ally described as a heterogeneous material formed by units and joints, with or without mortar, and different bond ar-rangements. Units are such as bricks, blocks, ashlars, adobes, irregular stones and others. Mortar can be clay, bitumen, chalk, lime/cement based mortar, glue or other. The almost infinite possible combinations generated by the geometry, nature and arrangement of units as well as the characteristics of mortars raise doubts about the accuracy of the term “ma-sonry”. Still, much information can be gained from the study of regular masonry structures, in which a periodic repetition of the microstructure occurs due to a constant arrangement of the units (or constant bond). The difficulties in performing advanced testing and pro-viding sufficiently general numerical models for this kind of structures are basically due to the innumerable variations of masonry typologies, the large scatter of in situ material prop-erties and the impossibility of reproducing all in a specimen. Therefore, most of the advanced numerical research carried out in the last decades concentrated in brick / block masonry and its relevance for design. Accurate modelling requires a comprehensive experimental description of the material, which seems mostly available at the present state of knowl-edge. From a numerical point of view, masonry behaviour is quite complex to model, exhibiting non-linearity very early during the loading process, with softening in both tension and compression, low ductility and differed deformations under sustained loads. In addition, masonry is the result of the assemblage of bricks or stones, where mortar is laid, with common geometric irregularities adding further complexity to the problem. The special issue collects ninepapers from experts in the field, including contributions of researchers from six differ-ent countries (Czech Republic, Iran, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Switzerland), either devoted to the utilization of non-standard numerical models for case-studies or presenting new approaches for the interpretation of masonry behaviour in presence of different kinds ofnon-linearity. The effort is always to put the knowledge beyond the existing state-of-the art. Karbassi and Lestuzzi [1]present a fragility analysis per-formed on unreinforced masonry buildings, conducted by means of the so called Applied Element Method (AEM), to define fragility curves of typical masonry buildings which may be regarded as representative of building classes. A se-ries of nonlinear dynamic analyses using AEM are per-formed for a 6-storey stone masonry and a 4-storey brick masonry building using more than 50 ground motion re-cords. The distribution of the structural responses and inter-storey drifts are finally used to develop spectral-based fragil-ity curves for the five European Macro-seismic Scale dam-age grades. In the second paper, Milani et al. [2]perform a detailed non-linear analysis (both pushover and limit analysis) on the San Pietro di Coppito bell tower in L’Aquila, Italy, trying to have an insight into the causes of the collapse occurred dur-ing the devastating 2009 earthquake. Sykora et al. [2]review several topics related to the ho-mogenization of transport processes occurring in historical masonry structures. Particular attention is paid to variations of temperature and moisture fields, whose contribution to structural damage usually far exceeds the effects of me-chanical loadings. The concept of Statistically Equivalent Periodic Unit Cell (SEPUC) is reviewed and utilized to deal with historic masonry and random patterns. Accepting SEPUC as a reliable representative volume element, a Fast Fourier Transform to both the SEPUC and large binary sam-ples of real masonry is used to tackle effective thermal con-ductivities problems. Fully coupled non-stationary heat and moisture transport problems are addressed next in the framework of a two-scale first-order homogenization, with emphases on the application of boundary and initial condi-tions at the meso-scale.


Heritage ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 4 (1) ◽  
pp. 401-421
Author(s):  
Semih Gonen ◽  
Bora Pulatsu ◽  
Ece Erdogmus ◽  
Engin Karaesmen ◽  
Erhan Karaesmen

The majority of architectural heritage consists of load-bearing masonry components made up of stone units and relatively weak mortar joints, yielding potential weak planes for masonry structures where tension and shear failures are expected to occur. Advanced nonlinear analyses are required to simulate these phenomena and predict the corresponding nonlinear structural behavior of historic masonry constructions. In this context, this paper presents a model of a stone masonry Roman aqueduct (the Valens Aqueduct), constructed in the fourth century A.D. in Istanbul, Turkey, to explore the seismic capacity and behavior using the discrete element method (DEM). The employed modeling approach comprises distinct rigid blocks interacting along their boundaries based on the point-contact hypothesis. Thus, the discontinuous stone skeleton of the masonry aqueduct is represented explicitly in the computational model. First, a validation study was conducted on the laboratory experiment to demonstrate the capabilities of the adopted modeling approach. Then, a discontinuum model representing the Valens Aqueduct was used to assess the seismic capacity of the structure under gradually increasing lateral forces. The numerical simulations gave insight into the structural response of the aqueduct from the elastic range to total collapse. Additionally, parametric research was performed considering joint properties, namely the joint tensile strength, contact stiffness, joint friction angle, and compressive strength of the masonry, to quantify the effects of contact parameters on the displacement response of the DEM model. Further inferences were made regarding the modeling parameters, and practical conclusions were derived.


Author(s):  
Antonio Maria D’Altri ◽  
Francesco Cannizzaro ◽  
Massimo Petracca ◽  
Diego Alejandro Talledo

AbstractIn this paper, a simple and practitioners-friendly calibration strategy to consistently link target panel-scale mechanical properties (that can be found in national standards) to model material-scale mechanical properties is presented. Simple masonry panel geometries, with various boundary conditions, are utilized to test numerical models and calibrate their mechanical properties. The calibration is successfully conducted through five different numerical models (most of them available in commercial software packages) suitable for nonlinear modelling of masonry structures, using nonlinear static analyses. Firstly, the panel stiffness calibration is performed, focusing the attention to the shear stiffness. Secondly, the panel strength calibration is conducted for several axial load ratios by attempts using as reference the target panel strength deduced by well-known analytical strength criteria. The results in terms of panel strength for the five different models show that this calibration strategy appears effective in obtaining model properties coherent with Italian National Standard and Eurocode. Open issues remain for the calibration of the post-peak response of masonry panels, which still appears highly conventional in the standards.


Author(s):  
José D. Henao Casas ◽  
Fritz Kalwa ◽  
Marc Walther ◽  
Randolf Rausch

AbstractTo cope with water scarcity in drylands, stormwater is often collected in surface basins and subsequently stored in shallow aquifers via infiltration. These stormwater harvesting systems are often accompanied by high evaporation rates and hygiene problems. This is commonly a consequence of low infiltration rates, which are caused by clogging layers that form on top of the soil profile and the presence of a thick vadose zone. The present study aims to develop a conceptual solution to increase groundwater recharge rates in stormwater harvesting systems. The efficiency of vadose-zone wells and infiltration trenches is tested using analytical equations, numerical models, and sensitivity analyses. Dams built in the channel of ephemeral streams (wadis) are selected as a study case to construct the numerical simulations. The modelling demonstrated that vadose-zone wells and infiltration trenches contribute to effective bypassing of the clogging layer. By implementing these solutions, recharge begins 2250–8100% faster than via infiltration from the bed surface of the wadi reservoir. The sensitivity analysis showed that the recharge rates are especially responsive to well length and trench depth. In terms of recharge quantity, the well had the best performance; it can infiltrate up to 1642% more water than the reservoir, and between 336 and 825% more than the trench. Moreover, the well can yield the highest cumulative recharge per dollar and high recharge rates when there are limitations to the available area. The methods investigated here significantly increased recharge rates, providing practical solutions to enhance aquifer water storage in drylands.


Author(s):  
Mustafa Hrasnica ◽  
Amir Čaušević ◽  
Nerman Rustempašić

Traditional art of building in Bosnia and Herzegovina comprises brick or stone masonry structures. Most historical buildings belonging to national cultural heritage were made of stone-masonry. The country is situated in seismic active region of South-East Europe. In the case of strong earthquake motion such buildings could suffer heavy damages. Some structural elements of historical buildings, as domes and arches, cracked already by moderate earthquake but without the loss of stability. Substantial damages were caused by recent war disaster. Damages could be accumulated through the history as well. Generally, stone-masonry buildings in Bosnia and Herzegovina can be classified in vulnerability classes between A and C according to European Macroseismic Scale. Design and construction procedures for rehabilitation are presented here with examples of repair and strengthening of mosques, which present historical stone masonry structures dating from the Ottoman period in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Traditional and contemporary materials were used for their rehabilitation. It is important to preserve original forms, especially those of damaged elements. The challenge for structural engineers and architects was to find equilibrium between aesthetical and structural demands.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document