The objective of this review was to determine what information is available on the incidence, pathophysiology, late complications, and treatment paradigms for occipital plagiocephaly based on a critical review of the literature obtained from recognized databases in peer-reviewed scientific publications.
The content of this article is based on a critical review of the literature, and when discussing treatment options, classification of those articles with respect to the strength of the recommendations they contain.
Using standard computerized search techniques, databases containing medical literature were queried for key words related to occipital plagiocephaly beginning in 1966. Key words used for this search were: lambdoid, craniosynostosis, cranial sutures, facial asymmetry, torticollis, and plagiocephaly. Titles of all articles were scanned for relevance. Copies of all potentially relevant articles published in the English language were obtained and received at least a cursory review. Several articles not captured by these methods were found to be important when referenced in the articles obtained. Articles discussing treatment were divided into Class I, Class II, and Class III data for the purpose of deciding on their applicability to the development of a potential consensus for the treatment of this controversial condition.
Using the aforementioned key words, there were 4308 articles identified with potential relevance: scanning by title excluded all but 89. Of the 89, those with on-line abstracts were scanned, the remainder were obtained via interlibrary loan when needed for scanning of the article itself. The actual incidence of occipital plagiocephaly is unknown and there are no population-based studies of its incidence or prevalence. The reported incidence of lambdoid craniosynostosis ranges from 3 to 20% with the differences primarily due to differences in diagnostic criteria. With the possible exception of a lambdoid suture, which is replaced throughout its entire course by a dense ridge of bone, there are no other diagnostic criteria upon which there is agreement. There are no Class I and only one Class II studies in which a group of patients treated with one form of therapy is compared with another form of therapy or an untreated group. Treatment options that are recommended include observation only, mechanical treatments such as exercises, positioning, remodeling helmets, and a wide variety of surgical techniques. Very few reports accessed through the aforestated methodology report patients suffering any significant late effects of occipital plagiocephaly, although it may be morphometrically evident in as many as 14% of adults.
Controlled clinical trials will be needed before any form of intervention can be generally recommended. If surgery, which is expensive and potentially dangerous, is to continue to play a role in the management of this condition, efforts should be made to ascertain from the general population which patients who have not been treated have suffered from this lack of treatment.