Beyond Mendelian Inheritance: Genetic Buffering and Phenotype Variability

Understanding the way genes work amongst individuals and across generations to shape form and function is a common theme for many genetic studies. The recent advances in genetics, genome engineering and DNA sequencing reinforced the notion that genes are not the only players that determine a phenotype. Due to physiological or pathological fluctuations in gene expression, even genetically identical cells can behave and manifest different phenotypes under the same conditions. Here, we discuss mechanisms that can influence or even disrupt the axis between genotype and phenotype; the role of modifier genes, the general concept of genetic redundancy, genetic compensation, the recently described transcriptional adaptation, environmental stressors, and phenotypic plasticity. We furthermore highlight the usage of induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), the generation of isogenic lines through genome engineering, and sequencing technologies can help extract new genetic and epigenetic mechanisms from what is hitherto considered ‘noise’.

Functional characterization of hydroxyproline-O-galactosyltransferases for Arabidopsis arabinogalactan-protein synthesis

Background Arabinogalactan-proteins (AGPs) are structurally complex hydroxyproline-rich cell wall glycoproteins ubiquitous in the plant kingdom. AGPs biosynthesis involves a series of post-translational modifications including the addition of type II arabinogalactans to non-contiguous Hyp residues. To date, eight Hyp-galactosyltransferases (Hyp-GALTs; GALT2-GALT9) belonging to CAZy GT31, are known to catalyze the addition of the first galactose residues to AGP protein backbones and enable subsequent AGP glycosylation. The extent of genetic redundancy, however, remains to be elucidated for the Hyp-GALT gene family. Results To examine their gene redundancy and functions, we generated various multiple gene knock-outs, including a triple mutant (galt5 galt8 galt9), two quadruple mutants (galt2 galt5 galt7 galt8, galt2 galt5 galt7 galt9), and one quintuple mutant (galt2 galt5 galt7 galt8 galt9), and comprehensively examined their biochemical and physiological phenotypes. The key findings include: AGP precipitations with β-Yariv reagent showed that GALT2, GALT5, GALT7, GALT8 and GALT9 act redundantly with respect to AGP glycosylation in cauline and rosette leaves, while the activity of GALT7, GALT8 and GALT9 dominate in the stem, silique and flowers. Monosaccharide composition analysis showed that galactose was decreased in the silique and root AGPs of the Hyp-GALT mutants. TEM analysis of 25789 quintuple mutant stems indicated cell wall defects coincident with the observed developmental and growth impairment in these Hyp-GALT mutants. Correlated with expression patterns, galt2, galt5, galt7, galt8, and galt9 display equal additive effects on insensitivity to β-Yariv-induced growth inhibition, silique length, plant height, and pollen viability. Interestingly, galt7, galt8, and galt9 contributed more to primary root growth and root tip swelling under salt stress, whereas galt2 and galt5 played more important roles in seed morphology, germination defects and seed set. Pollen defects likely contributed to the reduced seed set in these mutants. Conclusion Additive and pleiotropic effects of GALT2, GALT5, GALT7, GALT8 and GALT9 on vegetative and reproductive growth phenotypes were teased apart via generation of different combinations of Hyp-GALT knock-out mutants. Taken together, the generation of higher order Hyp-GALT mutants demonstrate the functional importance of AG polysaccharides decorating the AGPs with respect to various aspects of plant growth and development.

Participation of Acyl-Coenzyme A Synthetase FadD4 of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 in Acyclic Terpene/Fatty Acid Assimilation and Virulence by Lipid A Modification

The pathogenic bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa possesses high metabolic versatility, with its effectiveness to cause infections likely due to its well-regulated genetic content. P. aeruginosa PAO1 has at least six fadD paralogous genes, which have been implicated in fatty acid (FA) degradation and pathogenicity. In this study, we used mutagenesis and a functional approach in P. aeruginosa PAO1 to determine the roles of the fadD4 gene in acyclic terpene (AT) and FA assimilation and on pathogenicity. The results indicate that fadD4 encodes a terpenoyl-CoA synthetase utilized for AT and FA assimilation. Additionally, mutations in fadD paralogs led to the modification of the quorum-sensing las/rhl systems, as well as the content of virulence factors pyocyanin, biofilm, rhamnolipids, lipopolysaccharides (LPS), and polyhydroxyalkanoates. In a Caenorhabditis elegans in vivo pathogenicity model, culture supernatants from the 24-h-grown fadD4 single mutant increased lethality compared to the PAO1 wild-type (WT) strain; however, the double mutants fadD1/fadD2, fadD1/fadD4, and fadD2/fadD4 and single mutant fadD2 increased worm survival. A correlation analysis indicated an interaction between worm death by the PAO1 strain, the fadD4 mutation, and the virulence factor LPS. Fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) analysis of LPS revealed that a proportion of the LPS and FA on lipid A were modified by the fadD4 mutation, suggesting that FadD4 is also involved in the synthesis/degradation and modification of the lipid A component of LPS. LPS isolated from the fadD4 mutant and double mutants fadD1/fadD4 and fadD2/fadD4 showed a differential behavior to induce an increase in body temperature in rats injected with LPS compared to the WT strain or from the fadD1 and fadD2 mutants. In agreement, LPS isolated from the fadD4 mutant and double mutants fadD1/fadD2 and fadD2/fadD4 increased the induction of IL-8 in rat sera, but IL1-β cytokine levels decreased in the double mutants fadD1/fadD2 and fadD1/fadD4. The results indicate that the fadD genes are implicated in the degree of pathogenicity of P. aeruginosa PAO1 induced by LPS-lipid A, suggesting that FadD4 contributes to the removal of acyl-linked FA from LPS, rendering modification in its immunogenic response associated to Toll-like receptor TLR4. The genetic redundancy of fadD is important for bacterial adaptability and pathogenicity over the host.

In Vitro and in Vivo Characterisation of P. Aeruginosa Oxidoreductase Enzymes in Pathogenesis and Therapy

<p>Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an increasingly multi-drug resistant human pathogen, is now one of the top three causes of opportunistic infection and there is much interest in identifying novel therapeutic targets for treatment. As a bacterial pathogen, P. aeruginosa encounters innate immune system defences and must continue to adapt to its defence strategies to accommodate the ever-changing environment. Though P. aeruginosa virulence determinants have been heavily characterised over the last several decades, most recent work acknowledges the complex interaction between the human host and the pathogen as an on-going dialogue of virulence factors adapting to the continuum that is the immune response. A major challenge that P. aeruginosa must overcome are reactive oxygen species (ROS) that are released at all stages of infection. Based on previous work which demonstrated a role for soluble nitro- and quinone oxidoreductase (NQOR) enzymes in protecting a related bacterium (Pseudomonas putida) from oxidative stress, we hypothesized that P. aeruginosa would similarly utilize NQORs to withstand ROS. This thesis seeks to understand the role of ROS-protecting enzymes in pathogenesis as well as their potential applications in a therapeutic context. Several NQORs of P. aeruginosa were identified to possess biochemical characteristics consistent with the enzymatic capacity to indirectly reduce reactive species like H₂O₂. However, when individual genes encoding NQORs were deleted from P. aeruginosa, no apparent H₂O₂ sensitivity was seen. In contrast, when candidate genes were over-expressed, certain NQOR enzymes conferred the ability to tolerate H₂O₂ challenge at low concentrations; indicating that these NQORs may play a protective role whose effects are masked in vitro by genetic redundancy as well as a highly active endogenous catalase. By developing a novel in vivo cell culture infection model, the survival of P. aeruginosa post exposure to immunocompetent murine macrophages was also assessed. This not only demonstrated that several putative NQORs were activated in the presence of macrophages but also that an in vivo modelling system is likely to be more appropriate for discovering virulence determinants. In a different aspect of this study it was investigated whether the reductive capacity of the P. aeruginosa-derived NQORs might hold potential for gene-directed enzyme-prodrug therapy (GDEPT). Prodrugs, such as 5-(aziridin-1-yl)-2,4-dinitrobenzamide (CB1954) or the nitro-chloromethyl benzindoline SN 26438, are nontoxic in their native form, but become highly toxic upon reduction of their nitro functional groups. The P. aeruginosa NQORs, were tested to identify enzymes capable of efficient activation of CB1954 or SN 26438. Although none of these enzymes exhibited greater activity with CB1954 than the “best in class” Eschericha coli enzymes NfsA or NfsB, the P. aeruginosa NfsB orthologue (PA5190) demonstrated greater than 20-fold improved activity over NfsB from Escherichia coli in its ability to sensitise human cells to SN 26438. This finding offers promise for development of PA5190 and SN 26438 as a novel enzyme-prodrug paradigm for GDEPT.</p>

In Vitro and in Vivo Characterisation of P. Aeruginosa Oxidoreductase Enzymes in Pathogenesis and Therapy

<p>Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an increasingly multi-drug resistant human pathogen, is now one of the top three causes of opportunistic infection and there is much interest in identifying novel therapeutic targets for treatment. As a bacterial pathogen, P. aeruginosa encounters innate immune system defences and must continue to adapt to its defence strategies to accommodate the ever-changing environment. Though P. aeruginosa virulence determinants have been heavily characterised over the last several decades, most recent work acknowledges the complex interaction between the human host and the pathogen as an on-going dialogue of virulence factors adapting to the continuum that is the immune response. A major challenge that P. aeruginosa must overcome are reactive oxygen species (ROS) that are released at all stages of infection. Based on previous work which demonstrated a role for soluble nitro- and quinone oxidoreductase (NQOR) enzymes in protecting a related bacterium (Pseudomonas putida) from oxidative stress, we hypothesized that P. aeruginosa would similarly utilize NQORs to withstand ROS. This thesis seeks to understand the role of ROS-protecting enzymes in pathogenesis as well as their potential applications in a therapeutic context. Several NQORs of P. aeruginosa were identified to possess biochemical characteristics consistent with the enzymatic capacity to indirectly reduce reactive species like H₂O₂. However, when individual genes encoding NQORs were deleted from P. aeruginosa, no apparent H₂O₂ sensitivity was seen. In contrast, when candidate genes were over-expressed, certain NQOR enzymes conferred the ability to tolerate H₂O₂ challenge at low concentrations; indicating that these NQORs may play a protective role whose effects are masked in vitro by genetic redundancy as well as a highly active endogenous catalase. By developing a novel in vivo cell culture infection model, the survival of P. aeruginosa post exposure to immunocompetent murine macrophages was also assessed. This not only demonstrated that several putative NQORs were activated in the presence of macrophages but also that an in vivo modelling system is likely to be more appropriate for discovering virulence determinants. In a different aspect of this study it was investigated whether the reductive capacity of the P. aeruginosa-derived NQORs might hold potential for gene-directed enzyme-prodrug therapy (GDEPT). Prodrugs, such as 5-(aziridin-1-yl)-2,4-dinitrobenzamide (CB1954) or the nitro-chloromethyl benzindoline SN 26438, are nontoxic in their native form, but become highly toxic upon reduction of their nitro functional groups. The P. aeruginosa NQORs, were tested to identify enzymes capable of efficient activation of CB1954 or SN 26438. Although none of these enzymes exhibited greater activity with CB1954 than the “best in class” Eschericha coli enzymes NfsA or NfsB, the P. aeruginosa NfsB orthologue (PA5190) demonstrated greater than 20-fold improved activity over NfsB from Escherichia coli in its ability to sensitise human cells to SN 26438. This finding offers promise for development of PA5190 and SN 26438 as a novel enzyme-prodrug paradigm for GDEPT.</p>

Genetic redundancy resolves invasion paradox in Colorado potato beetle

The paradox of how invasive species cope with novel selective pressures with limited genetic variation is a fundamental question in molecular ecology. Several mechanisms have been proposed, but they can lack generality and predictive power. Here, we introduce an alternative mechanism, genetic redundancy, wherein changes in multiple combinations of loci can achieve a fitness optimum for polygenic traits, and thus the variations left after the founder effect may be sufficient for adaptation. We tested the potential importance of genetic redundancy in environmental adaptation of Colorado potato beetle (CPB) in introduced Eurasia. Population genomic analyses showed substantial genetic depletion following a single introduction event, which supports invasive CPB as a classic system for the paradox study. Genome-environment association analyses revealed a suite of loci and gene functions plausibly related to cold stress. Notably, a substantial portion of loci showed different contributions to similar or identical environments. Such non-parallel evolution indicates their potential redundancy to overall fitness. Furthermore, one important adaptive gene function, “phospholipid production”, was represented by more than one independent linkage cluster, suggesting some gene functional redundancy in cold resistance. Taken together, these results support the hypothesis that genetic redundancy can promote the adaptability of polygenic traits despite strong genetic depletion, thus providing a general mechanism for resolving the genetic paradox of invasion. More broadly, genetic redundancy, as an inherent feature of the genome, may have contributed to the evolutionary success of invasive species in many aspects.

Combined fluorescent seed selection and multiplex CRISPR/Cas9 assembly for fast generation of multiple Arabidopsis mutants

Background Multiplex CRISPR-Cas9-based genome editing is an efficient method for targeted disruption of gene function in plants. Use of CRISPR-Cas9 has increased rapidly in recent years and is becoming a routine method for generating single and higher order Arabidopsis thaliana mutants. Low entry, reliable assembly of CRISPR/Cas9 vectors and efficient mutagenesis is necessary to enable a maximum of researchers to break through the genetic redundancy within plant multi-gene families and allow for a plethora of gene function studies that have been previously unachievable. It will also allow routine de novo generation of mutations in ever more complex genetic backgrounds that make introgression of pre-existing alleles highly cumbersome. Results To facilitate rapid and efficient use of CRISPR/Cas9 for Arabidopsis research, we developed a CRISPR/Cas9-based toolbox for generating mutations at multiple genomic loci, using two-color fluorescent seed selection. In our system, up-to eight gRNAs can be routinely introduced into a binary vector carrying either a FastRed, FastGreen or FastCyan fluorescent seed selection cassette. FastRed and FastGreen binary vectors can be co-transformed as a cocktail via floral dip to introduce sixteen gRNAs at the same time. The seeds can be screened either for red or green fluorescence, or for the presence of both colors. Importantly, in the second generation after transformation, Cas9 free plants are identified simply by screening the non-fluorescent seeds. Our collection of binary vectors allows to choose between two widely-used promoters to drive Cas enzymes, either the egg cell-specific (pEC1.2) from A. thaliana or the constitutive promoter from Petroselinum crispum (PcUBi4-2). Available enzymes are “classical” Cas9 codon-optimized for A. thaliana and a recently reported, intron-containing version of Cas9 codon-optimized for Zea mays, zCas9i. We observed the highest efficiency in producing knockout phenotypes by using intron-containing zCas9i driven under egg-cell specific pEC1.2 promoter. Finally, we introduced convenient restriction sites flanking promoter, Cas9 and fluorescent selection cassette in some of the T-DNA vectors, thus allowing straightforward swapping of all three elements for further adaptation and improvement of the system. Conclusion A rapid, simple and flexible CISPR/Cas9 cloning system was established that allows assembly of multi-guide RNA constructs in a robust and reproducible fashion, by avoiding generation of very big constructs. The system enables a flexible, fast and efficient screening of single or higher order A. thaliana mutants.

In-Depth Analysis of the Role of the Acinetobactin Cluster in the Virulence of Acinetobacter baumannii

Acinetobacter baumannii is a multidrug-resistant pathogen that represents a serious threat to global health. A. baumannii possesses a wide range of virulence factors that contribute to the bacterial pathogenicity. Among them, the siderophore acinetobactin is one of the most important, being essential for the development of the infection. In this study we performed an in-depth analysis of the acinetobactin cluster in the strain A. baumannii ATCC 17978. For this purpose, nineteen individual isogenic mutant strains were generated, and further phenotypical analysis were performed. Individual mutants lacking the biosynthetic genes entA, basG, basC, basD, and basB showed a significant loss in virulence, due to the disruption in the acinetobactin production. Similarly, the gene bauA, coding for the acinetobactin receptor, was also found to be crucial for the bacterial pathogenesis. In addition, the analysis of the ΔbasJ/ΔfbsB double mutant strain demonstrated the high level of genetic redundancy between siderophores where the role of specific genes of the acinetobactin cluster can be fulfilled by their fimsbactin redundant genes. Overall, this study highlights the essential role of entA, basG, basC, basD, basB and bauA in the pathogenicity of A. baumannii and provides potential therapeutic targets for the design of new antivirulence agents against this microorganism.

Local conjugation of auxin by the GH3 amido synthetases is required for normal development of roots and flowers in Arabidopsis

Gretchen Hagen 3 (GH3) amido synthetases conjugate amino acids to a carboxyl group of small molecules including hormones auxin, jasmonate, and salicylic acid. The Arabidopsis genome harbors 19 GH3 genes, whose exact roles in plant development have been difficult to define because of genetic redundancy among the GH3 genes. Here we use CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing technology to delete the Arabidopsis group II GH3 genes, which are able to conjugate indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) to amino acids. We show that plants lacking the eight group II GH3 genes (gh3 octuple mutants) accumulate free IAA and fail to produce IAA-Asp and IAA-Glu conjugates. Consequently, gh3 octuple mutants have extremely short roots, long and dense root hairs, and long hypocotyls and petioles. Our characterization of gh3 septuple mutants, which provide sensitized backgrounds, reveals that GH3.17 and GH3.9 play prominent roles in root elongation and seed production, respectively. We show that GH3 functions correlate with their expression patterns, suggesting that local deactivation of auxin also contributes to maintaining auxin homeostasis and is important for plant development. Moreover, this work provides a method for elucidating functions of individual members of a gene family, whose members have overlapping functions.