425 Background: Primary lesion in mRCC often shows necrotic change or only density changes to targeted therapy. As most clinical trials for mRCC have enrolled nephrectomized patients (pts), there is no consensus on including primary lesion in target lesion when evaluating response. We investigated whether best overall response (OR) changes when designate target lesions with or without primary lesion, and such discordance lead to difference in predictive value in terms of time to progression (TTP) and overall survival (OS). Methods: We enrolled mRCC pts with intact primary lesion, at least one measurable metastatic lesion, and proper image data who had received sunitinib in our institution between 2003 and 2011. We documented the variation of the sum of the largest diameters (ΔSLD) with all target lesions and with metastasis-only target lesions separately. Response evaluation was calculated with RECIST v1.1. Results: Of 41 pts, 38 received sunitinib as 1st line treatment and 3 did as 2nd line. The most frequent metastatic site was lung (63.4%) followed by lymph node (46.3%) and bone (42.5%). Median ΔSLD of primary lesion and metastatic target lesion were -6.02% (range: -34.00 to 17.60%), and -18.03% (-100.00 to 120.00%). On response evaluation with metastasis-only target lesions, best OR of 2 pts (4.87%) changed from stable disease to partial response. When categorize pts into responders and non-responders, metastasis-only target lesions resulted in significantly better discrimination of TTP (14.949 vs 4.271 mo, p=0.01) and OS (18.497 vs 9.561 mo, p=0.036) between two groups. Using all target lesions, both TTP (14.949 vs 5.355 mo, p=0.056) and OS (17.971 vs 10.579 mo, p=0.155) were statistically insignificant. Conclusions: Our study showed discordance in OR between using all target lesions and using metastasis-only target lesions, and metastasis-only target lesion could have more accurate predictive value. As response rate is often used as an end point in clinical research of mRCC, further discussion is needed whether primary lesion should be included or not in target lesion. [Table: see text]