scholarly journals Reply to Comment by Jie Qin and Teng Wu on “A Modified Particle Filter‐Based Data Assimilation Method for a High‐Precision 2‐D Hydrodynamic Model Considering Spatial‐Temporal Variability of Roughness: Simulation of Dam‐Break Flood Inundation”

2020 ◽  
Vol 56 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Yin Cao ◽  
Yuntao Ye ◽  
Lili Liang ◽  
Hongli Zhao ◽  
Yunzhong Jiang ◽  
...  
Agriculture ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 10 (12) ◽  
pp. 606
Author(s):  
Alaa Jamal ◽  
Raphael Linker

Particle filter has received increasing attention in data assimilation for estimating model states and parameters in cases of non-linear and non-Gaussian dynamic processes. Various modifications of the original particle filter have been suggested in the literature, including integrating particle filter with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (PF-MCMC) and, later, using genetic algorithm evolutionary operators as part of the state updating process. In this work, a modified genetic-based PF-MCMC approach for estimating the states and parameters simultaneously and without assuming Gaussian distribution for priors is presented. The method was tested on two simulation examples on the basis of the crop model AquaCrop-OS. In the first example, the method was compared to a PF-MCMC method in which states and parameters are updated sequentially and genetic operators are used only for state adjustments. The influence of ensemble size, measurement noise, and mutation and crossover parameters were also investigated. Accurate and stable estimations of the model states were obtained in all cases. Parameter estimation was more challenging than state estimation and not all parameters converged to their true value, especially when the parameter value had little influence on the measured variables. Overall, the proposed method showed more accurate and consistent parameter estimation than the PF-MCMC with sequential estimation, which showed highly conservative behavior. The superiority of the proposed method was more pronounced when the ensemble included a large number of particles and the measurement noise was low.


2020 ◽  
Vol 8 (5) ◽  
pp. 1989-1992
Author(s):  
Vinay Khalkho ◽  
Dr. Alex Thomas ◽  
Manmohan Singh ◽  
Shilpi Dadel

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Bertrand Cluzet ◽  
Matthieu Lafaysse ◽  
Emmanuel Cosme ◽  
Clément Albergel ◽  
Louis-François Meunier ◽  
...  

Abstract. Monitoring the evolution of the snowpack properties in mountainous areas is crucial for avalanche hazard forecasting and water resources management. In-situ and remotely sensed observations provide precious information on the snowpack but usually offer a limited spatio-temporal coverage of bulk or surface variables only. In particular, visible-near infrared (VIS-NIR) reflectance observations can inform on the snowpack surface properties but are limited by terrain shading and clouds. Snowpack modelling enables to estimate any physical variable, virtually anywhere, but is affected by large errors and uncertainties. Data assimilation offers a way to combine both sources of information, and to propagate information from observed areas to non observed areas. Here, we present CrocO, (Crocus-Observations) an ensemble data assimilation system able to ingest any snowpack observation (applied as a first step to the height of snow (HS) and VIS-NIR reflectances) in a spatialised geometry. CrocO uses an ensemble of snowpack simulations to represent modelling uncertainties, and a Particle Filter (PF) to reduce them. The PF is known to collapse when assimilating a too large number of observations. Two variants of the PF were specifically implemented to ensure that observations information is propagated in space while tackling this issue. The global algorithm ingests all available observations with an iterative inflation of observation errors, while the klocal algorithm is a localised approach performing a selection of the observations to assimilate based on background correlation patterns. Experiments are carried out in a twin experiment setup, with synthetic observations of HS and VIS-NIR reflectances available in only a 1/6th of the simulation domain. Results show that compared against runs without assimilation, analyses exhibit an average improvement of snow water equivalent Continuous Rank Probability Score (CRPS) of 60 % when assimilating HS with a 40-member ensemble, and an average 20 % CRPS improvement when assimilating reflectance with a 160-member ensemble. Significant improvements are also obtained outside the observation domain. These promising results open a way for the assimilation of real observations of reflectance, or of any snowpack observations in a spatialised context.


2013 ◽  
Vol 10 (3) ◽  
pp. 2879-2925 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. C. D. Paiva ◽  
W. Collischonn ◽  
M.-P. Bonnet ◽  
L. G. G. de Gonçalves ◽  
S. Calmant ◽  
...  

Abstract. In this work we introduce and evaluate a data assimilation framework for gauged and radar altimetry-based discharge and water levels applied to a large scale hydrologic-hydrodynamic model for stream flow forecasts over the Amazon River basin. We used the process-based hydrological model called MGB-IPH coupled with a river hydrodynamic module using a storage model for floodplains. The Ensemble Kalman Filter technique was used to assimilate information from hundreds of gauging and altimetry stations based on ENVISAT satellite data. Model state variables errors were generated by corrupting precipitation forcing, considering log-normally distributed, time and spatially correlated errors. The EnKF performed well when assimilating in situ discharge, by improving model estimates at the assimilation sites and also transferring information to ungauged rivers reaches. Altimetry data assimilation improves results at a daily basis in terms of water levels and discharges with minor degree, even though radar altimetry data has a low temporal resolution. Sensitivity tests highlighted the importance of the magnitude of the precipitation errors and that of their spatial correlation, while temporal correlation showed to be dispensable. The deterioration of model performance at some unmonitored reaches indicates the need for proper characterization of model errors and spatial localization techniques for hydrological applications. Finally, we evaluated stream flow forecasts for the Amazon basin based on initial conditions produced by the data assimilation scheme and using the ensemble stream flow prediction approach where the model is forced by past meteorological forcings. The resulting forecasts agreed well with the observations and maintained meaningful skill at large rivers even for long lead times, e.g. > 90 days at the Solimões/Amazon main stem. Results encourage the potential of hydrological forecasts at large rivers and/or poorly monitored regions by combining models and remote sensing information.


2019 ◽  
Vol 147 (4) ◽  
pp. 1107-1126 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jonathan Poterjoy ◽  
Louis Wicker ◽  
Mark Buehner

Abstract A series of papers published recently by the first author introduce a nonlinear filter that operates effectively as a data assimilation method for large-scale geophysical applications. The method uses sequential Monte Carlo techniques adopted by particle filters, which make no parametric assumptions for the underlying prior and posterior error distributions. The filter also treats the underlying dynamical system as a set of loosely coupled systems to effectively localize the effect observations have on posterior state estimates. This property greatly reduces the number of particles—or ensemble members—required for its implementation. For these reasons, the method is called the local particle filter. The current manuscript summarizes algorithmic advances made to the local particle filter following recent tests performed over a hierarchy of dynamical systems. The revised filter uses modified vector weight calculations and probability mapping techniques from earlier studies, and new strategies for improving filter stability in situations where state variables are observed infrequently with very accurate measurements. Numerical experiments performed on low-dimensional data assimilation problems provide evidence that supports the theoretical benefits of the new improvements. As a proof of concept, the revised particle filter is also tested on a high-dimensional application from a real-time weather forecasting system at the NOAA/National Severe Storms Laboratory (NSSL). The proposed changes have large implications for researchers applying the local particle filter for real applications, such as data assimilation in numerical weather prediction models.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Concetta Di Mauro ◽  
Renaud Hostache ◽  
Patrick Matgen ◽  
Peter Jan van Leeuwen ◽  
Nancy Nichols ◽  
...  

<p>Data assimilation uses observation for updating model variables and improving model output accuracy. In this study, flood extent information derived from Earth Observation data (namely Synthetic Aperture Radar images) are assimilated into a loosely coupled flood inundation forecasting system via a Particle Filter (PF). A previous study based on a synthetic experiment has shown the validity and efficiency of a recently developed PF-based assimilation framework allowing to effectively integrate remote sensing-derived probabilistic flood inundation maps into a coupled hydrologic-hydraulic model. One of the main limitations of this recent framework based on sequential importance sampling is the sample degeneracy and impoverishment, as particles loose diversity and only few of them keep a substantial importance weight in the posterior distribution. In order to circumvent this limitation, a new methodology is adopted and evaluated: a tempered particle filter. The main idea is to update a set of state variables, namely through a smooth transition (iterative and adaptative process). To do so, the likelihood is factorized using small tempering factors. Each iteration includes subsequent resampling and mutation steps using a Monte Carlo Metropolis Hasting algorithm. The mutation step is required to regain diversity between the particles after the resampling. The new methodology is tested using synthetic twin experiments and the results are compared to the one obtained with the previous approach. The new proposed method enables to substantially improve the predictions of streamflow and water levels within the hydraulic domain at the assimilation time step. Moreover, the preliminary results show that these improvements are longer lasting. The proposed tempered particle filter also helps in keeping more diversity within the ensemble.</p>


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
sejal chandel ◽  
suvarna shah

<p>In recent study, Gujarat has become one of the India’s most urbanized state, causing severe flash flooding. The Sabarmati river is one of the major west-flowing rivers in India and biggest river of north Gujarat.Urbanization should meet the population’s need by enlargement of paved areas, which has unusually changed the catchment’s hydrological and hydraulic characteristic. Therefor, the frequency of flash flooding in Sabarmati river has been increased. The Sabarmati river basin experienced eight times devastating flooding coendition between 1972 to 2020.Among which July 2017 flooding event breakdown a 112 years old record of 1905. The Dharoi dam and Wasna barrage on Sabarmati river and surrounding district Kheda, Mehsana, Gandhinagar, Ahmedabad received a huge rainfall caused anomalous inflow to tributary which forced the dam authorities to release huge discharge in short duration which leads to flooding. The Sabarmati riverfront of Ahmedabad had been going under water for five days due incessant rainfall in the city that leads to swelling of the Sabarmati river in 2017. In order to determine extent of Inundation, Hydrodynamic Model HEC-RAS(5.0.6) with Arc GIS was used. Various scenarios were run with HEC-RAS to study the impact of flow simulation on flood inundation(with & without riverfront project). The simulated flood depths have been compared with actual depths obtained at gauging station, which were collected from Government authorities. Ultimately, the analysis was used to create maps for different return periods with RAS Mapper and ArcMap that visually show the reach of the floodplains, illustrating the affected areas. Results demonstrate the usefulness of  modelling system to predict the extent of flood inundation and thus support analyses of management strategies to deal with risk associated with infrastructure in an urban setting.</p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document