Manure management and composting methods may greatly affect compost characteristics. An experiment was conducted to characterize 23 on-farm and 6 industrial composts in Québec (Canada). Cluster analysis identified two major groups characterized by their chemical composition, source materials, management intensity and degree of decomposition. Electrical conductivity, total N and K, water-soluble NH4+, PO4, K, Al and organic C, and a cress test were the best chemical and biological parameters for grouping composts. These groups were strongly associated with bedding rate, turning frequency, composting duration, profile windrow appearance, material aggregation and odor. When restricted to dairy manure composts, no clear relationship could be established by cluster analysis between material grouping and their farm management. Statistical analysis on single chemical parameters of dairy manure composts, however, identified five farm management factors: type and amount of bedding, system of manure handling and storage, compost windrow turning, composting length and milk production intensity. These factors affected one or several major parameters: pH, dry matter, electrical conductivity, total and water-soluble C, N, P and K, and humic components characteristics. This study demonstrated the importance of leaching losses in the on-farm composting operations in humid cold regions and the need for more environmentally sustainable composting methods. Key words: Farm manure management, composting, chemical composition