Processing Value of Small-Diameter Sawtimber at Conventional Stud Sawmills and Modern High-Speed, Small-Log Sawmills in the Western United States—A Comparison
Abstract Past selective logging of early successional species [e.g., ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa)] and effective fire suppression have dramatically altered forest composition and health over millions of acres in the western United States. Implementation of ecological restoration treatments to address these conditions will produce large volumes of small-diameter sawtimber for processing. Since sawmills currently process a majority of sawtimber harvested in the West (more than 80% in some regions), this study concentrated on determining the value of small-diameter sawtimber delivered to sawmills. A conventional stud sawmill and a modern, high-speed, small-log sawmill were profiled. A simulator (MSUSP) was employed to describe these sawmills and to determine breakeven delivered-sawtimber values by dbh class for each sawmill. Data inputs included machinery type, mill layout, machine speeds, volume and grade recovery, product prices, and fixed and variable manufacturing costs. Results showed that sawtimber 9 in. dbh and under could not cover harvest and delivery costs and earn even a modest (10%) return on invested (ROI) capital at the conventional stud sawmill and that sawtimber 7.5 in. dbh and smaller had negative values. However with a 10% ROI capital, the value of all sizes of sawtimber at the modern, high-speed sawmill equaled or exceeded harvest and delivery costs. West. J. Appl. For. 15(4):208–212.