Weak GDP growth makes case for more easing in Japan

Significance The previous quarter's output was revised upward to 2.0% from the original 1.7%. For the first six months, Japan has grown at a bit more than 1.1% (annualised) -- above its predicted growth trajectory, given the decline of population and workforce. The Bank of Japan (BoJ) recently estimated Japan's potential growth rate at 0.21%, and the Cabinet Office put it at 0.3%. Given such low expectations, any negative factors such as weak exports can easily cause a contraction. Impacts Higher consumption depends on higher labour income, which is undermined by the increased use of non-regular workers. Negative interest rates stimulate residential investment and a front-loaded stimulus appears to have raised public investment. Falling numbers of hours worked, while jobs increased, demonstrates structural problems in the labour market.

Subject Monetary policy in Japan. Significance After reviewing a comprehensive assessment of the Japanese economy, the Bank of Japan (BoJ) ended its meeting on September 21 with decisions to fine-tune monetary policy, disappointing observers who expected a deeper dive into negative interest rates or amplification of the current course of government bond purchases. Impacts Major changes to interest rates or exchange rates are unlikely. Shares of banks and other financial institutions will benefit. Backward-looking inflation expectations should turn positive as months of fairly stable import prices work their way through overall prices.


2018 ◽  
Vol 10 (2) ◽  
pp. 310-320
Author(s):  
Benjamin S. Kay

Purpose While central bankers have widely discussed the trade-offs of negative interest rates on monetary policy, the consequences of negative rates on financial stability are less well understood. The purpose of this paper is to examine the likely and possible financial stability consequences of a negative rates policy with particular focus on banks, short-term funding markets, foreign exchange markets, asset managers, pension funds and insurers. Design/methodology/approach It draws from international experience with negative interest rates to identify financial stability threats posed to any economy by negative interest rates, and it also highlights where the US experience is likely to differ. Findings In time, financial market threats and other logistical issues of a negative interest rate policy can be managed or overcome. Even cumulatively, these threats are likely to be small as long as the rates remain only modestly negative. However, if the rates remain negative for long periods or they become more sharply negative, the rewards of avoiding negative rates increase. Originality/value Does the negative interest rate policy directly or through these challenges of implementation present a substantial obstacle to achieving financial stability objectives? As policy rates go negative in a greater share of the global economy, the financial stability consequences remain poorly understood and under discussed.


Subject Monetary policy in Japan. Significance The monetary policy board of the Bank of Japan (BoJ) at its last meeting abandoned its prediction of when the nation will reach its 2% inflation target, the first time it has omitted a target date since Governor Haruhiko Kuroda introduced his policy of radical monetary easing five years ago. Impacts Japan’s interest rates will remain at historically low levels for at least two more years. The yen will remain relatively weak as other countries’ central banks end their quantitative easing programmes. A weak currency plus widespread global economic growth will create strong demand for Japanese exports.


Significance Despite aggressive easing by both the Bank of Japan (BoJ) and the ECB, including negative interest rates, the lowering of expectations over the scale and pace of rate hikes by the US Federal Reserve (Fed) has negated their attempts to weaken their currencies and thus boost export-driven growth. This is heightening concern that ultra-loose monetary policies have passed the point where they can revive growth and inflation. Impacts Despite the recent improvement due to the oil price rebound since mid-February, sentiment towards EM currencies will remain fragile. The still strong demand for 'safe-haven' assets, such as German government bonds and gold, implies investors will remain cautious. Negative deposit rates will further undermine banks' earnings, amid persistent concerns about capital levels. Central banks will reach the limits of their capacity to promote growth without fiscal support from governments.


Significance Forecasts of modest GDP growth next year assume a recovery in domestic investment, driven primarily by government spending to deliver a six-year growth and development strategy. Impacts Rising yields on government debt next year may disrupt plans for new issuance. Higher bond yields will add to pressure to raise interest rates. Restricted public borrowing will reduce funds available for public investment. The government is promising more rigorous methods for quantifying strategic goals, but only by end-2019.


Significance The fall highlights the economic impact of the second lockdown; the third, from mid-December, will cause GDP to fall in the first quarter of 2021. The accommodation and food services sector, and some parts of the retail sector, will be hardest hit. Impacts The regionally disjointed recovery and fiscal pressures will make it harder for the government to pursue its ‘levelling up’ agenda. Post-COVID-19 behaviour will help adjust the balance between towns and cities but the pandemic will also weaken the sectors towns rely on. The central bank's review of negative interest-rates confirms that it is reluctant to cut rates but will do so if the downturn deepens.


Subject The second phase of the government's reform agenda. Significance The closing months of 2016 promise to be busy as the government pushes several pieces of legislation through parliament, in line with election promises. These include the long-awaited bill on converting foreign-currency mortgages denominated in Swiss francs and a revised budget for 2017. Impacts The fiscal deficit is likely to be contained within the EU's 3% limit in 2016-17 but rise beyond that threshold in 2018. Until infrastructure-led investment takes effect, low interest rates and a strong labour market may help private consumption support growth. As more state-owned companies look to invest in ageing infrastructure, public investment will become a key growth driver after 2018.


Subject The economic outlook for Japan. Significance Japan’s GDP rose 1.0% for the calendar year 2016 and the fourth quarter (annualised). Although the latest quarter decelerated from the pace of the earlier part of the year, the economy has now experienced four straight quarters of growth, the longest stretch since 2013. Impacts Higher wages arising from tighter labour markets will eventually push up prices, the four-year goal of the Bank of Japan. Low interest rates, rising investment and historically low levels of business failure support bank lending and demand for loans. The apparent end of a raw materials glut is bringing foreign demand back to Japan’s exporters; this should continue.


Subject Financial markets turmoil and negative interest rates. Significance Global stocks are down 11.7% year-to-date in dollar terms and the yield on benchmark ten-year US Treasury bonds has hit a low of 1.66%. The turmoil in financial markets since the beginning of this year is partly attributable to investors' waning confidence in the effectiveness of central bank policy, and, in particular, that negative interest rate policies are exacerbating weaknesses in the banking sector. This is reducing the scope for a rally in equity markets, which have been overly reliant on the flow of cheap money from central banks. Impacts The strong yen will pose a severe challenge to the Japanese government's reflationary programme. While stock markets will remain sensitive to monetary policy, investors will perceive central banks as sources of volatility. The European financials sell-off stems from concerns about their earnings and business models, as opposed to a full-blown liquidity crisis.


2019 ◽  
Vol 20 (4) ◽  
pp. 370-387 ◽  
Author(s):  
Giuseppe Orlando ◽  
Rosa Maria Mininni ◽  
Michele Bufalo

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to model interest rates from observed financial market data through a new approach to the Cox–Ingersoll–Ross (CIR) model. This model is popular among financial institutions mainly because it is a rather simple (uni-factorial) and better model than the former Vasicek framework. However, there are a number of issues in describing interest rate dynamics within the CIR framework on which focus should be placed. Therefore, a new methodology has been proposed that allows forecasting future expected interest rates from observed financial market data by preserving the structure of the original CIR model, even with negative interest rates. The performance of the new approach, tested on monthly-recorded interest rates data, provides a good fit to current data for different term structures. Design/methodology/approach To ensure a fitting close to current interest rates, the innovative step in the proposed procedure consists in partitioning the entire available market data sample, usually showing a mixture of probability distributions of the same type, in a suitable number of sub-sample having a normal/gamma distribution. An appropriate translation of market interest rates to positive values has been introduced to overcome the issue of negative/near-to-zero values. Then, the CIR model parameters have been calibrated to the shifted market interest rates and simulated the expected values of interest rates by a Monte Carlo discretization scheme. We have analysed the empirical performance of the proposed methodology for two different monthly-recorded EUR data samples in a money market and a long-term data set, respectively. Findings Better results are shown in terms of the root mean square error when a segmentation of the data sample in normally distributed sub-samples is considered. After assessing the accuracy of the proposed procedure, the implemented algorithm was applied to forecast next-month expected interest rates over a historical period of 12 months (fixed window). Through an error analysis, it was observed that our algorithm provides a better fitting of the predicted expected interest rates to market data than the exponentially weighted moving average model. A further confirmation of the efficiency of the proposed algorithm and of the quality of the calibration of the CIR parameters to the observed market interest rates is given by applying the proposed forecasting technique. Originality/value This paper has the objective of modelling interest rates from observed financial market data through a new approach to the CIR model. This model is popular among financial institutions mainly because it is a rather simple (uni-factorial) and better model than the former Vasicek model (Section 2). However, there are a number of issues in describing short-term interest rate dynamics within the CIR framework on which focus should be placed. A new methodology has been proposed that allows us to forecast future expected short-term interest rates from observed financial market data by preserving the structure of the original CIR model. The performance of the new approach, tested on monthly data, provides a good fit for different term structures. It is shown how the proposed methodology overcomes both the usual challenges (e.g. simulating regime switching, clustered volatility and skewed tails), as well as the new ones added by the current market environment (particularly the need to model a downward trend to negative interest rates).


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document