Control of Turbulent Transport: Less Friction and More Heat Transfer

2012 ◽  
Vol 134 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Nobuhide Kasagi ◽  
Yosuke Hasegawa ◽  
Koji Fukagata ◽  
Kaoru Iwamoto

Because of the importance of fundamental knowledge on turbulent heat transfer for further decreasing entropy production and improving efficiency in various thermofluid systems, we revisit a classical issue whether enhancing heat transfer is possible with skin friction reduced or at least not increased as much as heat transfer. The answer that numerous previous studies suggest is quite pessimistic because the analogy concept of momentum and heat transport holds well in a wide range of flows. Nevertheless, the recent progress in analyzing turbulence mechanics and designing turbulence control offers a chance to develop a scheme for dissimilar momentum and heat transport. By reexamining the governing equations and boundary conditions for convective heat transfer, the basic strategies for achieving dissimilar control in turbulent flow are generally classified into two groups, i.e., one for the averaged quantities and the other for the fluctuating turbulent components. As a result, two different approaches are discussed presently. First, under three typical heating conditions, the contribution of turbulent transport to wall friction and heat transfer is mathematically formulated, and it is shown that the difference in how the local turbulent transport of momentum and that of heat contribute to the friction and heat transfer coefficients is a key to answer whether the dissimilar control is feasible. Such control is likely to be achieved when the weight distributions for the stress and flux in the derived relationships are different. Second, we introduce a more general methodology, i.e., the optimal control theory. The Fréchet differentials obtained clearly show that the responses of velocity and scalar fields to a given control input are quite different due to the fact that the velocity is a divergence-free vector, while the temperature is a conservative scalar. By exploiting this inherent difference, the dissimilar control can be achieved even in flows where the averaged momentum and heat transport equations have the same form.

Author(s):  
Nobuhide Kasagi ◽  
Yosuke Hasegawa ◽  
Koji Fukagata ◽  
Kaoru Iwamoto

Because of the importance of fundamental knowledge on turbulent heat transfer for further decreasing entropy production and improving efficiency in various thermo-fluid systems, we revisit a classical issue whether enhancing heat transfer is possible with skin friction reduced or at least not increased as much as heat transfer. The answer that numerous previous studies suggest is quite pessimistic because the analogy concept of momentum and heat transport holds well in a wide range of flows. Nevertheless, the recent progress in analyzing turbulence mechanics and designing turbulence control offers a chance to develop a scheme for dissimilar momentum and heat transport. By reexamining the governing equations and boundary conditions for convective heat transfer, the basic strategies for achieving dissimilar control in turbulent flow is generally classified into two groups, i.e., one for the averaged quantities and the other for the turbulent fluctuating components. As a result, two different approaches are discussed presently. First, under three typical heating conditions, the contribution of turbulent transport to wall friction and heat transfer is mathematically formulated, and it is shown that the difference in how the local turbulent transport of momentum and that of heat contribute to the friction and heat transfer coefficients is a key to answer whether the dissimilar control is feasible. Such control is likely to be achieved when the weight distributions for the stress and flux in the derived relationships are different. Secondly, we introduce a more general methodology, i.e., the optimal control theory. The Fre´chet differentials obtained clearly show that the responses of velocity and scalar fields to a given control input are quite different due to the fact that the velocity is a divergence-free vector while the temperature is a conservative scalar. By exploiting this inherent difference, the dissimilar control can be achieved even in flows where the averaged momentum and heat transport equations have the same form.


1994 ◽  
Vol 116 (3) ◽  
pp. 577-587 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. H. Kim ◽  
N. K. Anand

Two-dimensional turbulent heat transfer between a series of parallel plates with surface mounted discrete block heat sources was studied numerically. The computational domain was subjected to periodic conditions in the streamwise direction and repeated conditions in the cross-stream direction (Double Cyclic). The second source term was included in the energy equation to facilitate the correct prediction of a periodically fully developed temperature field. These channels resemble cooling passages in electronic equipment. The k–ε model was used for turbulent closure and calculations were made for a wide range of independent parameters (Re, Ks/Kf, s/w, d/w, and h/w). The governing equations were solved by using a finite volume technique. The numerical procedure and implementation of the k–ε model was validated by comparing numerical predictions with published experimental data (Wirtz and Chen, 1991; Sparrow et al., 1982) for a single channel with several surface mounted blocks. Computations were performed for a wide range of Reynolds numbers (5 × 104–4 × 105) and geometric parameters and for Pr = 0.7. Substrate conduction was found to reduce the block temperature by redistributing the heat flux and to reduce the overall thermal resistance of the module. It was also found that the increase in the Reynolds number decreased the thermal resistance. The study showed that the substrate conduction can be an important parameter in the design and analysis of cooling channels of electronic equipment. Finally, correlations for the friction factor (f) and average thermal resistance (R) in terms of independent parameters were developed.


1995 ◽  
Vol 305 ◽  
pp. 127-157 ◽  
Author(s):  
Y. Nagano ◽  
M. Tagawa

In wall turbulence, it is widely accepted that the coherent motions determine the essential features of turbulent transport phenomena. In the present study, we have refined a trajectory-based detection algorithm for coherent motions and have investigated the relationship between coherent motions and scalar (heat) transfer from a structural point of view, i. e. trajectory analysis of the VITA heat transfer events, extraction of key flow modules and the relevant heat transport, and the prediction of passive scalar transfer by means of an autoregressive (AR) model. As a result, it is shown that the phase relationship of fluctuating velocity components dominates the essential characteristics of the transport processes of heat and momentum in wall turbulence and there exist distinct differences in individual correspondence between the coherent motions and heat transport processes, neither of which can be revealed by the widely used VITA technique. Also, the AR model is shown to provide good time-series predictions for turbulent heat transfer associated with coherent structures near the wall.


Author(s):  
V.V. Gorskiy ◽  
A.G. Loktionova

In order to compute the intensity of laminar-turbulent heat transfer, algebraic or differential models are commonly used, which are designed to compute the contribution of turbulent pulsations to the transfer properties of the gas. This, in turn, dictates the necessity of validating these semi-empirical models against experimental data obtained under conditions simulating the gas dynamics inherent to the phenomenon as observed in practice. The gas dynamic patterns observed during gradient flow around fragments of aircraft structure (such as a sphere or a cylinder) differs qualitatively from the patterns revealed by the flow around the lateral surfaces of these fragments, which necessitates using various semi-empirical approaches in this case, followed by mandatory validation against the results of respective experimental studies. In recent years, there appeared scientific publications dealing with modifying one of the algebraic models designed to compute the contribution of turbulent pulsations in the boundary layer to the transfer properties of the gas; this was accomplished by making use of experimental data obtained for a hemisphere at extremely high Reynolds numbers. The paper proposes a similar modification of the same turbulence model, based on fitting a wide range of experimental data obtained for lateral surfaces of spherically blunted cones. As a result of the investigations conducted, we stated a method for computing laminar-to-turbulent heat transfer over the entire surface of a blunted cone; the accuracy of the method is acceptable in terms of most practical applications. We show that the computational method presented is characterised by minimum error as compared to the most widely spread methods for solving this problem


Author(s):  
Michael J. Denninger ◽  
Ann M. Anderson

The work presented here is the first reported study to test the general correlation for turbulent heat transfer proposed by Maciejewski and Anderson (1996). A turbulent pipe flow apparatus was built for heat transfer and fluid studies. Tests were performed for a range of Reynolds numbers from 27,000 to 90,000. The heated wall temperature, adiabatic temperature, the wall heat flux and the maximum velocity fluctuations were measured at each Reynolds number. The non-dimensional groups recommended by Maciejewski and Anderson were formed and compared to the correlation. The results verify the correlation with agreement to within ±7% (as per figure 11). This study has important implications for the study of heat transfer in a wide range of fields, including the gas turbine industry. The development of a geometry independent correlation will lead to faster turn around times and improved engine design.


Author(s):  
Roberto Da Vià ◽  
Sandro Manservisi ◽  
Valentina Giovacchini

The study of turbulent heat transfer in liquid metal flows has gained interest because of applications in several industrial fields. The common assumption of similarity between the dynamical and thermal turbulence, namely the Reynolds analogy, has been proven to be not valid for these fluids. Many methods have been proposed in order to overcome the difficulties encountered in a proper definition of the turbulent heat flux, such as global or local correlations for the turbulent Prandtl number or four parameter turbulence models. In this work we assess a four parameter logarithmic turbulence model for liquid metals based on RANS approach. Several simulation results considering fluids with Pr = 0.01 and Pr = 0.025 are reported in order to show the validity of this approach. The Kays turbulence model is also assessed and compared with integral heat transfer correlations for a wide range of Peclet numbers.


1969 ◽  
Vol 91 (1) ◽  
pp. 135-139 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. N. Cannon ◽  
W. M. Kays

In this paper the effects of tube rotation on heat transfer to a fluid flowing inside a tube are examined. The most pronounced influence is noted to be on the transition from laminar to turbulent flow region with lesser effects in the laminar region, and no measurable effects once the flow has become fully turbulent. Heat transfer data are presented for a wide range of through-flow and rotational Reynolds numbers. A brief examination of the flow by visual means revealed that tube rotation tends to stabilise laminar flow, and in fact can cause an already turbulent flow to revert back to a laminar flow. When the tube is rotating, the transition from laminar to turbulent flow as through-flow Reynolds number is sufficiently increased is characterized by a very distinct “burst of turbulence” phenomenon, photographs of which are presented in this paper.


2003 ◽  
Vol 125 (1) ◽  
pp. 194-200 ◽  
Author(s):  
Masoud Rokni and ◽  
Bengt Sunde´n

This investigation concerns numerical calculation of fully developed turbulent forced convective heat transfer and fluid flow in ducts over a wide range of Reynolds numbers. The low Reynolds number version of a non-linear eddy viscosity model is combined with a two-equation heat flux model with the eddy diffusivity concept. The model can theoretically be used for a range of Prandtl numbers or a range of different fluids. The computed results compare satisfactory with the available experiment. Based on existing DNS data and calculations in this work the ratio between the time-scales (temperature to velocity) is found to be approximately 0.7. In light of this assumption an algebraic scalar flux model with variable diffusivity is presented.


2011 ◽  
Vol 683 ◽  
pp. 57-93 ◽  
Author(s):  
Y. Hasegawa ◽  
N. Kasagi

AbstractA wide range of applicability of the Reynolds analogy between turbulent momentum and heat transport implies inherent difficulty in diminishing or enhancing skin friction and heat transfer independently. In the present study, we introduce suboptimal control theory for achieving a dissimilar control of enhancing heat transfer, while keeping the skin friction not increased considerably in a fully developed channel flow. The Fréchet differentials clearly show that the responses of velocity and temperature fields to wall blowing/suction are quite different, due to the fact that the velocity is a divergence-free vector field while the temperature is a conservative scalar field. This essential difference allows us to achieve dissimilar control even in flows where the averaged momentum and energy transport equations have an identical form. It is also found that the resultant optimized mode of control input exhibits a streamwise travelling-wave-like property. By exploring the phase relationship between the travelling-wave-like control input and the velocity and thermal fields, we reveal that such control input contributes to dissimilar heat transfer enhancement via two different mechanisms, i.e. direct modification of the coherent components of the Reynolds shear stress and the turbulent heat flux, and indirect effects on the incoherent components, through modification of the mean velocity and temperature profiles. Based on these results, a simple open-loop strategy for dissimilar control is proposed and assessed.


1999 ◽  
Vol 121 (2) ◽  
pp. 288-294 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. J. Denninger ◽  
A. M. Anderson

The work presented here is the first reported study to test the general correlation for turbulent heat transfer proposed by Maciejewski and Anderson (1996). A turbulent pipe flow apparatus was built for heat transfer and fluid studies. Tests were performed for a range of Reynolds numbers from 27,000 to 90,000. The heated wall temperature, adiabatic temperature, the wall heat flux, and the maximum velocity fluctuations were measured at each Reynolds number. The nondimensional groups recommended by Maciejewski and Anderson were formed and compared to the correlation. The results verify the correlation with agreement to within ±7 percent (as per Fig. 11). This study has important implications for the study of heat transfer in a wide range of fields, including the gas turbine industry. The development of a geometry independent correlation will lead to faster turn-around times and improved engine design.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document