Thermal and Flow Phenomena Associated With the Behavior of Brush Seals in Aero Engine Bearing Chambers

Author(s):  
Michael Flouros ◽  
Patrick Hendrick ◽  
Bilal Outirba ◽  
Francois Cottier ◽  
Stephan Proestler

Due to the increasing fuel cost and environmental targets, the demand for more efficient gas turbines has risen considerably in the last decade. One of the most important systems in a gas turbine is the secondary air system, which provides cooling air to the disks and to the blades. It also provides air for sealing of the bearing chambers. The amount of secondary air that is extracted from the compressor is a performance penalty for the engine. In aero engines, bearing chambers are in most cases sealed by the most traditional type of seal, the labyrinth seal. Bearing chambers contain the oil lubricated components like bearings and gears. In order to avoid oil migration from the bearing chamber into the turbomachinery, the seals are pressurized by secondary air; thus, a pressure difference is setup across the seal, which retains the lubricant into the bearing chamber. Oil loss can lead to a number of problems like oil fire or coking with the probability of an uncontained destruction of the aero engine. Oil fumes can also cause contamination of the air conditioning system of the aircraft thus cause discomfort to the passengers. Beside labyrinth seals, other types of seals such as brush seals and carbon seals are used. Both the latter are contact type seals, that is, they may be installed with zero gap and lift during operation when they get pressurized. Brush seals particularly may be installed having an overlap with the rotating part. An original aero engine bearing chamber was modified by MTU Aero Engines to run with brush seals in a simulating rig in Munich. Two types of brush seals were used for testing: (a) a brush seal with bristles made of Kevlar fibers and (b) a brush seal with bristles made of steel. Both types were installed with an overlap to the rotor. The targets set were twofold: (a) to measure the transient temperatures in the rotor and particularly in the contact zone between the bristles and the rotor and (b) to calculate the heat generation by the seals which could enable predictions of the heat generation in future applications (i.e., scaling to bigger rotor diameters). For the heat transfer calculations, numerical models using ansys cfx were created. Additionally, a coupled computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and finite element analysis (FEA) approach was applied to simulate flow and bristle's behavior. In order to obtain the transient temperature measurements with high fidelity, a new pyrometric technique was developed and was applied for the first time in brush seals as reported by Flouros et al. (2013, “Transient Temperature Measurements in the Contact Zone Between Brush Seals of Kevlar and Metallic Type for Bearing Chamber Sealing Using a Pyrometric Technique,” ASME J. Gas Turbines Power, 135(8), p. 081603) and Flouros et al. (2012, “Transient Temperature Measurements in the Contact Zone Between Brush Seals of Kevlar and Metallic Type for Bearing Chamber Sealing Using a Pyrometric Technique,” ASME Turbo Expo 2012, Copenhagen, Paper No. GT2012-68354). This technique has enabled positioning of the pyrometer (SensorthermGmbH, www.sensortherm.com) into the bristles pack of the seal adjacent to the rotating surface. The pyrometer could record the frictional temperature evolution in the bristles/rotor contact zone during accelerations or decelerations of the rotor. The sealing air demand can be reduced up to 97% with brush seals compared to traditional three fin labyrinth. It has been estimated that this can result in a reduction in fuel burned up to 1%. Further, the reduction in air flow has additional potential benefits such as a possible simplification of the bearing chamber architecture (vent less chamber). Even though the rotor was accelerated up to 19,500 rpm, the temperature induced overshoots in the seal/rotor contact zone have caused no deterioration in either the materials or the oil.

Author(s):  
Michael Flouros ◽  
Patrick Hendrick ◽  
Bilal Outirba ◽  
Francois Cottier ◽  
Stephan Proestler

Due to the increasing fuel cost and environmental targets, the demand for more efficient gas turbines has risen considerably in the last decade. One of the most important systems in a gas turbine is the secondary air system which provides cooling air to the disks and to the blades. It also provides air for sealing of the bearing chambers. The amount of secondary air that is extracted from the compressor is a performance penalty for the engine. In aero engines, bearing chambers are in most cases sealed by the most traditional type of seal, the labyrinth seal. Bearing chambers contain the oil lubricated components like bearings and gears. In order to avoid oil migration from the bearing chamber into the turbo machinery the seals are pressurized by air thus a pressure difference is set up across the seal which retains the lubricant into the bearing chamber. Oil loss can lead to a number of problems like oil fire or coking with the probability of an uncontained destruction of the aero engine. Oil fumes can also cause contamination of the air conditioning system of the aircraft thus cause discomfort to the passengers. Beside labyrinth seals other types of seals such as brush seals and carbon seals are used. Both the latter are contact type seals, that is, they may be installed with zero gap and lift during operation when they get pressurized. Brush seals particularly may even have an overlap with the rotating part. An original aero engine bearing chamber was modified by MTU Aero Engines to run with brush seals in a simulating rig in Munich. Two types of brush seals were used for testing: a) brush seal with bristles made of Kevlar fibers and b) with bristles made of steel. Both types were installed having an overlap to the rotor. The targets set were twofold: a) to measure the transient temperatures in the rotor and particularly in the contact zone between the bristles and the rotor and b) to calculate the heat generation by the seals which could enable predictions of the heat generation in future applications (i.e. scaling to bigger rotor diameters). To that effect numerical models using ANSYS CFX were created. Additionally, a coupled CFD and Finite Element Analysis (FEA) approach was applied to simulate flow and bristle’s behavior. In order to obtain the transient temperature measurements with high fidelity, a new pyrometric technique was developed and was applied for the first time in brush seals as reported in [5]. This technique has enabled positioning of the pyrometer [15] into the bristles pack of the seal adjacent to the rotating surface. The pyrometer can record the frictional temperature evolution in the bristles/rotor contact zone during accelerations or decelerations of the rotor. The sealing air demand can be reduced up to 97% with brush seals compared to traditional three fin labyrinth. It has been estimated that this can result in a reduction in fuel burned by up to 1%. Further, the reduction in air flow has additional potential benefits such as a possible simplification of the bearing chamber architecture (vent less chamber). Even though the rotor was accelerated up to 19500rpm, the temperature induced overshoots in the seal/rotor contact zone have caused no deterioration in either the materials or the oil. This work is part of the European Union funded research programme ELUBSYS (Engine LUBrication System TechnologieS) within the 7th EU Frame Programme for Aeronautics and Transport (AAT.2008.4.2.3).


Author(s):  
Michael Flouros ◽  
Martin Stadlbauer ◽  
Francois Cottier ◽  
Stephan Proestler ◽  
Stefan Beichl

For the past 25 years brush seal technologies have evolved into the aero engine designs and, more generally, into the gas turbine world, not only for sealing gas areas at different pressure levels but also for sealing gas/liquid environments. This is the case in an aero engine where the bearing chambers are sealed. Aero engine bearing chambers enclose oil lubricated components such bearings and gears. In order to avoid contamination of the turbo machinery through oil loss, air blown seals are used to retain the oil into the bearing chamber. Oil loss may cause coking or ignition with the probability of an uncontained destruction of rotating parts such as disks or blades. It may also cause contamination of the air conditioning system with oil fumes thus causing health problems to the passengers and crew from such exposure. The most widely known seals for bearing chamber sealing are the labyrinth seals, however, in recent years brush seals and carbon seals have also been used. The latter are contact seals; that is, they may be installed having zero clearance to the rotating part and lift during operation when their air side is pressurized. During this survey an actual aero engine bearing chamber was modified to run with brush seals in a simulating rig. Two types of brush seals were used: (a) with bristles made of Kevlar, and (b) bristles made of a metallic material. Both types were installed with an overlap to the rotor. The targets set were twofold: (a) to measure the transient temperatures in the rotor and particularly in the contact zone between the bristles and the rotor, and (b) to measure the air leakage through the seals at different operating conditions. In order to obtain the transient temperature measurements with high fidelity, a new pyrometric technique was developed and was applied for the first time in brush seals. This technique has enabled placement of the pyrometer into the bristle's pack of the seal adjacent to the rotating surface and it could record the frictional temperature evolution in the bristles/rotor contact zone during acceleration or deceleration of the rotor. Additionally, the air consumption of the seals was measured and was compared to the air consumption through the labyrinth seals. For the metallic brush seal, up to 80% of the required sealing air can be saved, which can result, in turn, into a reduction in fuel burned by up to 1%. Furthermore, a design simplification of the bearing chamber architecture can be achieved by taking into account the reduced air flow. Even though the rotor was accelerated to high speeds up to 19,500 rpm, the produced temperature overshoots in the seal/rotor contact zone have caused no deterioration in either the materials or the oil.


Author(s):  
Michael Flouros ◽  
Martin Stadlbauer ◽  
Francois Cottier ◽  
Stephan Proestler ◽  
Stefan Beichl

For the past 25 years brush seal technologies evolved into the aero engine designs and more general into the gas turbine world not only for sealing gas areas at different pressure levels but also for sealing gas/liquid environments. This is the case in an aero engine where the bearing chambers are sealed. Aero engine bearing chambers enclose oil lubricated components such bearings and gears. In order to avoid contamination of the turbo machinery through oil loss, air blown seals are used to retain the oil into the bearing chamber. Oil loss may cause coking or ignition with the probability of an uncontained destruction of rotating parts like disks or blades. It may also cause contamination of the air conditioning system with oil fumes thus cause health problems to the passengers and crew from such exposure. The most widely known seals for bearing chamber sealing are the labyrinth seals but in the recent years also brush seals and carbon seals are used. The latter are contact seals, that is, they may be installed having zero clearance to the rotating part and lift during operation when their air side is pressurized. During this survey an actual aero engine bearing chamber was modified to run with brush seals in a simulating rig. Two types of brush seals were used: a) with bristles made of Kevlar and b) bristles made of metallic material. Both types were installed with an overlap to the rotor. The targets set were twofold: a) to measure the transient temperatures in the rotor and particularly in the contact zone between the bristles and the rotor and b) to measure the air leakage through the seals at different operating conditions. In order to obtain the transient temperature measurements with high fidelity, a new pyrometric technique was developed and was applied for the first time in brush seals. This technique has enabled placing the pyrometer into the bristle’s pack of the seal adjacent to the rotating surface and could record the frictional temperature evolution in the bristles/rotor contact zone during acceleration or deceleration of the rotor. Additionally, the air consumption of the seals was measured and was compared to the air consumption through the labyrinth seals. For the metallic brush seal, up to 80% of the required sealing air can be saved which can result in return into a reduction in fuel burned by up to 1%. Further, a design simplification of the bearing chamber architecture can be achieved by taking into account the reduced air flow. Even though the rotor was accelerated to high speeds up to 19500rpm, the produced temperature overshoots in the seal/rotor contact zone have caused no deterioration in either the materials or the oil. This work is part of the European Union funded research programme ELUBSYS (Engine LUBrication System TechnologieS) within the 7th EU Frame Programme for Aeronautics and Transport (AAT.2008.4.2.3).


Author(s):  
Marco Mantero ◽  
Alessandro Vinci ◽  
Luca Bozzi ◽  
Enrico D’Angelo

In order to achieve significant secondary air savings in heavy duty gas turbines, a remarkable item of improvement is the reduction of seal flows for turbine stator-rotor cavities. The optimization of such flows allows to avoid waste of air, obligatory with standard labyrinth seals, to ensure the minimum sealing flow rate in all operating conditions. Based on the experience gained in the design of sealing system of stator-rotor cavities with standard seals, the project of installation of inter-stage brush-seals was undertaken incorporating such devices into the vane seal rings of 2nd and 3rd turbine stages of a AE94.3A Gas Turbine (GT). The paper offers a detailed description of the installation project. The following describes in detail the design flow process and the calculation methodologies used, step by step, to define the geometry of brush-seals in order to ensure mechanical integrity and durability, needed in the commercial operation, without thereby affecting the performance. The first prototype of brush-seal devices has been installed on a AE94.3A4 unit of the Ansaldo fleet. In order to verify the behavior of stator-rotor sealing system, in particular in terms of temperature and pressure variations, vane seal rings have been equipped with special instrumentation. A series of tests to optimize the set points of bleed control valves was carried out.


Author(s):  
Shouqing Huang ◽  
Shuangfu Suo ◽  
Yongjian Li ◽  
Jun Ding ◽  
Yuming Wang

A type of fiber thermocouple is applied to a brush seal in order to obtain the temperature of the bristle-rotor friction zone. Using a brush seal test rig, the temperature measurements utilizing a fiber thermocouple, infrared thermometer, and common thermocouple are compared and studied. The fiber thermocouple is studied under various operational conditions consisting of different pressure and speed variations, rotor-bristle interferences, and eccentricities. Some interesting phenomena and characteristics of brush seals are revealed during these experiments. Some preliminary wear results of a fiber thermocouple are also presented. The results demonstrate the superiority of fiber thermocouples when used in narrow spaces, high temperature, and pressure environments within the heart of an aero-engine.


Author(s):  
Patrick Nau ◽  
Zhiyao Yin ◽  
Oliver Lammel ◽  
Wolfgang Meier

Phosphor thermometry has been developed for wall temperature measurements in gas turbines and gas turbine model combustors. An array of phosphors has been examined in detail for spatially and temporally resolved surface temperature measurements. Two examples are provided, one at high pressure (8 bar) and high temperature and one at atmospheric pressure with high time resolution. To study the feasibility of this technique for full-scale gas turbine applications, a high momentum confined jet combustor at 8 bar was used. Successful measurements up to 1700 K on a ceramic surface are shown with good accuracy. In the same combustor, temperatures on the combustor quartz walls were measured, which can be used as boundary conditions for numerical simulations. An atmospheric swirl-stabilized flame was used to study transient temperature changes on the bluff body. For this purpose, a high-speed setup (1 kHz) was used to measure the wall temperatures at an operating condition where the flame switches between being attached (M-flame) and being lifted (V-flame) (bistable). The influence of a precessing vortex core (PVC) present during M-flame periods is identified on the bluff body tip, but not at positions further inside the nozzle.


Author(s):  
A. Glahn ◽  
M. Kurreck ◽  
M. Willmann ◽  
S. Wittig

The present paper deals with oil droplet now phenomena in aero engine bearing chambers. An experimental investigation of droplet sizes and velocities utilizing a Phase Doppler Particle Analyzer (PDPA) has been performed for the first time in bearing chamber atmospheres under real engine conditions. Influences of high rotational speeds are discussed for individual droplet size classes. Although this is an important contribution to a better understanding of the droplet flow impact on secondary air/oil system performance, an analysis of the droplet flow behaviour requires an incorporation of numerical methods because detailed measurements as performed here suffer from both strong spatial limitations with respect to the optical accessibility in real engine applications and constraints due to the extremely time consuming nature of an experimental flow field analysis. Therefore, further analysis is based on numerical methods. Droplets characterized within the experiments are exposed to the flow field of the gaseous phase predicted by use of our well-known CFD code EPOS. The droplet trajectories and velocities are calculated within a Lagrangian frame of reference by forward numerical integration of the particle momentum equation. This paper has been initiated rather to show a successful method of bearing chamber droplet flow analysis by a combination of droplet sizing techniques and numerical approaches than to present field values as a function of all operating parameters. However, a first insight into the complex droplet flow phenomena is given and specific problems in bearing chamber heat transfer are related to the droplet flow.


Author(s):  
Bilal Outirba ◽  
Patrick Hendrick

Abstract Carbon fibre brush seals are an alternative to labyrinth seals in aero-engines lubrication systems due to better sealing ability with low power loss. However, the use of brush seals still raises concerns about coking issues. In addition, the influence of oil on the brush seal behaviour needs to be fully assessed. This paper provides an experimental investigation of the effect of lubrication oil on the performance of carbon fibre brush seals under static and dynamic conditions. Eight brush seal samples of various geometrical designs were submitted to an environment recreating the working conditions of a modern aero-engine bearing chamber in terms of rotational speed, air pressure, and oil type of injection and temperature. The test results indicated that the performance of carbon fibre brush seals was deeply influenced by the presence of oil within fibres. Oil deeply influences leakage performance, depending on geometrical parameters (density, fibre length and interference) and operating conditions (oil temperature, rotational speed). Brush seal fibre pack is mainly prone to hydrodynamic lift and oil soaking, which is defined by the ability of lubrication oil to fill in properly the interstices between fibres. Viscosity and surface tension may be the key properties influencing oil soaking. Seal torque data corroborates the presence of a hydrodynamic lift. In addition, in absence of differential pressure, seal torque decrease with when oil temperature increases indicates the existence of a critical viscosity. Finally, oil lubrication within the bristles allows reduction of the inter-bristle friction, thus limiting hysteresis.


Author(s):  
E. D. Kay ◽  
H. Power ◽  
S. Hibberd

Droplet-cooled oil films develop on the internal surfaces of an aero-engine bearing chamber and are a primary mechanism in removing heat from the chamber as oil is continuously collected and externally cooled and recycled. Predicting the internal oil temperature and oil temperature history is an important thermal problem which becomes more apparent with potential increases in operating temperatures of gas turbines. Studying interacting oil flow and thermal processes within a simplified bearing chamber geometry provides useful information on the trends and characteristics which can arise under different applied flow conditions (e.g. mass flow rate of oil through the system) and insight to the effect chamber design parameters may have on oil degradation and cooling of chamber walls. Thin oil films develop on the walls of a bearing chamber as oil is injected or shed from bearings and impinges on the walls under a strong airflow set in motion by rotating components. Typically the film is also subject to a heat flux from the hot chamber walls and the droplets provide an important cooling effect through “heat-to-oil” mechanisms. We present a mathematical model for the depth-averaged flow and associated heat transfer by thin oil films on the walls of a simplified aero-engine bearing chamber. Cases corresponding to generic flow conditions relevant to an aero-engine bearing chamber are presented. Characteristics of the film and the efficacy of the flow regime to transfer heat from the chamber is explored through calculating residence times and time histories of oil particles as they make a transit of the internal system.


Author(s):  
Luis San Andre´s ◽  
Jose´ Baker ◽  
Adolfo Delgado

Simplicity, low cost and easy replacement make labyrinth seals the primary seal type in gas turbines. However, excessive leakage and potential for rotordynamic instability are well known issues. Brush seals effectively control leakage in air breathing engines, albeit only applied for relatively low-pressure differentials. Hybrid brush seals (HBS) are an alternative to resolve poor reliability resulting from bristle tip wear while also allowing for reverse rotation operation. The novel configuration incorporates pads contacting the shaft; which under rotor spinning; lift-off due to the generation of a hydrodynamic pressure. The ensuing gas film prevents intermittent contact; thus lowering the operating temperature and thermal distortions, and even eliminating bristle wear. The hybrid brush seal improves sealing, is more durable and reliable than conventional brush seals, and allows reverse shaft rotation without seal damage. The paper presents measurements of power loss and leakage in a hybrid brush seal (HBS) for increasing pressure differentials over a range of rotor speeds. The test HBS, Haynes-25 bristle pack [∼850 bristles/cm] and 45° lay angle, is 166.4 mm in diameter and integrates 20-arcuate pads connected with thin EDM-webs to the seal casing. The webs are designed with low radial stiffness to allow for rotor excursions and high axial stiffness to avoid pad pitching motions resulting from high pressure differentials across the seal. Measured drag power at low rotor speeds (< 11 m/s at 1,300 rpm) decreases as the pressure differential across the seal increases. At a fixed rotor speed, a significant drop in drag torque (and drag power) ensues as the supply pressure increases, thus demonstrating that a gas film separates the rotor from the seal pads. Additionally, the operating temperature measured at the rotor/seal interface remains approximately constant (∼24°C) during tests with shaft rotation (power loss and drag torque measurements) under pressurized conditions; indicating that the rotor and seal pads are not in contact. Flow rate measurements at room temperature (25°C) show an improved sealing ability with a leakage reduction of about 36%, when compared to a first generation shoed-brush seal (SBS). The HBS calculated effective clearance (∼50 μm) is approximately 70% smaller than the radial clearance (∼180 μm) of an ideal non contacting seal with similar rotor diameter. Improved brush seal technology will increase the efficiency of gas turbines while also aiding to improve the engine stability and to reduce vibrations.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document