Analysis of Tooth Surface Distress Using AGMA 925 and Numerical Load Distribution Methods
The AGMA document 925 is an important step toward the standardisation of the present knowledge of the surface distress mechanisms; specifically it provides a careful look onto two important phenomena as scuffing and wear on gears employing a wide set of experimental data provided by literature and AGMA members; but since the load distribution is calculated using simplified methods the obtained results may be limited to gear designs whose load distribution is similar to the one(s) of the test gearset(s) where the above data was collected, i.e. spur gears, mostly accurately designed to scuff and to test lubricants. The work summarizes the different effects of applying the cited document methodology using simplified load distribution and most sophisticated one(s) on classical test gears for lubricants and on helical designs. It is shown that using more sophisticated load distribution methods the results on helical gears may be strongly different with respect of simplified methods and may suggest, in some cases, a design review.