Reconsideration of the Fan Scaling Laws: Part II — Applications

Author(s):  
Asad M. Sardar ◽  
William K. George

The entire approach to the scaling of fan performance was reconsidered in Part I from first principles using the Navier-Stokes equations appropriate to rotating and swirling (incompressible) flows. Generalized fan scaling laws (GFSL) were derived, consistent with the fact that both Strouhal and Reynolds number must be maintained constant for full dynamical similarity to be possible. As a consequence, dynamic similarity is only possible if ΩD2/ν = const. (in addition to U/ΩD = constant, or equivalently, Q/ΩD3 = constant). This can be contrasted with the classical fan laws (CFSL) which for the same flow rate coefficient would imply that Q/ΩD3 = const. The differences in fan scaling laws between GFSL and CFSL lead to very different fan pressure and fan power scaling criteria. For example, using the GFSL, the pressure coefficient (or Euler number), similarity between the model and prototype fan results in ΔPm/ΔPp = 1/(Lm/Lp)2 (for constant kinematic viscosity), whereas the CFSL pressure scaling criteria lead to ΔPm/ΔPp = (Ωm/Ωp)2 (Lm/Lp)2. Clearly these are very different scaling results and affect the scaling of all the relevant fan performance parameters. In this paper, several applications will be described of experimental programs which utilized these GFSL to design dynamically similar scale models of automotive fans, and these designs are contrasted with what might have been done had the classical laws been used. Three of the facilities were built, and each allowed detailed flow measurements, which would not otherwise have been possible. In addition, the implications and advantages of making tests in a high-pressure facility are explored. Some suggestions will also be made as to how the generalized scaling laws can be applied in design practice.

Author(s):  
Asad M. Sardar ◽  
William K. George

Generalized Fan Scaling Laws (GSFL) are derived for the scaling of fan performance. These follow from first principles using the Navier-Stokes equations appropriate to rotating and swirling flows. Not surprisingly, both Strouhal and Reynolds number similarity must be maintained. Thus for a geometrically similar family of fans, dynamic similarity is only possible if ΩD/U = constandUD/ν = const. If the second relation is solved for U and substituted into the first, it follows that full dynamic similarity is possible only if ΩD2/ν = const. This can be contrasted with the classical fan laws (CFSL) which for the same flow rate coefficient would imply that Q/ΩD3 (or U/ΩD) = const, implying that both fan size ratio and fan speed ratio are independent fan scaling parameters. Clearly for dynamic similarity to be maintained, the velocity and fan speed can not be varied independently (i.e. fan size and fan speed are not independent scaling parameters), contrary to the implications of the classical fan scaling laws. Further implications of the differences between the classical and generalized scaling laws for fan performance testing and design will be explored. Also several examples will be given in Part II as to how the generalized scaling laws can be applied in design practice.


AIAA Journal ◽  
2000 ◽  
Vol 38 ◽  
pp. 1603-1614
Author(s):  
Martin Scholtysik ◽  
Bernhard Mueller ◽  
Torstein K. Fannelop

2009 ◽  
Vol 76 (2) ◽  
Author(s):  
Murat Manguoglu ◽  
Ahmed H. Sameh ◽  
Faisal Saied ◽  
Tayfun E. Tezduyar ◽  
Sunil Sathe

In this paper we present effective preconditioning techniques for solving the nonsymmetric systems that arise from the discretization of the Navier–Stokes equations. These linear systems are solved using either Krylov subspace methods or the Richardson scheme. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our techniques in handling time-accurate as well as steady-state solutions. We also compare our solvers with those published previously.


2014 ◽  
Author(s):  
P. Bigay ◽  
A. Bardin ◽  
G. Oger ◽  
D. Le Touzé

In order to efficiently address complex problems in hydrodynamics, the advances in the development of a new method are presented here. This method aims at finding a good compromise between computational efficiency, accuracy, and easy handling of complex geometries. The chosen method is an Explicit Cartesian Finite Volume method for Hydrodynamics (ECFVH) based on a compressible (hyperbolic) solver, with a ghost-cell method for geometry handling and a Level-set method for the treatment of biphase-flows. The explicit nature of the solver is obtained through a weakly-compressible approach chosen to simulate nearly-incompressible flows. The explicit cell-centered resolution allows for an efficient solving of very large simulations together with a straightforward handling of multi-physics. A characteristic flux method for solving the hyperbolic part of the Navier-Stokes equations is used. The treatment of arbitrary geometries is addressed in the hyperbolic and viscous framework. Viscous effects are computed via a finite difference computation of viscous fluxes and turbulent effects are addressed via a Large-Eddy Simulation method (LES). The Level-Set solver used to handle biphase flows is also presented. The solver is validated on 2-D test cases (flow past a cylinder, 2-D dam break) and future improvements are discussed.


1987 ◽  
Vol 109 (4) ◽  
pp. 345-352 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Reggio ◽  
R. Camarero

A numerical procedure to solve three-dimensional incompressible flows in arbitrary shapes is presented. The conservative form of the primitive-variable formulation of the time-dependent Navier-Stokes equations written for a general curvilinear coordiante system is adopted. The numerical scheme is based on an overlapping grid combined with opposed differencing for mass and pressure gradients. The pressure and the velocity components are stored at the same location: the center of the computational cell which is used for both mass and the momentum balance. The resulting scheme is stable and no oscillations in the velocity or pressure fields are detected. The method is applied to test cases of ducting and the results are compared with experimental and numerical data.


1969 ◽  
Vol 37 (4) ◽  
pp. 727-750 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gareth P. Williams

A method of numerically integrating the Navier-Stokes equations for certain three-dimensional incompressible flows is described. The technique is presented through application to the particular problem of describing thermal convection in a rotating annulus. The equations, in cylindrical polar co-ordinate form, are integrated with respect to time by a marching process, together with the solving of a Poisson equation for the pressure. A suitable form of the finite difference equations gives a computationally-stable long-term integration with reasonably faithful representation of the spatial and temporal characteristics of the flow.Trigonometric interpolation techniques provide accurate (discretely exact) solutions to the Poisson equation. By using an auxiliary algorithm for rapid evaluation of trigonometric transforms, the proportion of computation needed to solve the Poisson equation can be reduced to less than 25% of the total time needed to’ advance one time step. Computing on a UNIVAC 1108 machine, the flow can be advanced one time-step in 2 sec for a 14 × 14 × 14 grid upward to 96 sec for a 60 × 34 × 34 grid.As an example of the method, some features of a solution for steady wave flow in annulus convection are presented. The resemblance of this flow to the classical Eady wave is noted.


Author(s):  
Y Wang ◽  
S Komori

A pressure-based finite volume procedure developed previously for incompressible flows is extended to predict the three-dimensional compressible flow within a centrifugal impeller. In this procedure, the general curvilinear coordinate system is used and the collocated grid arrangement is adopted. Mass-averaging is used to close the instantaneous Navier-Stokes equations. The covariant velocity components are used as the main variables for the momentum equations, making the pressure-velocity coupling easier. The procedure is successfully applied to predict various compressible flows from subsonic to supersonic. With the aid of the k-ɛ turbulence model, the flow details within a centrifugal impeller are obtained using the present procedure. Predicted distributions of the meridional velocity and the static pressure are reasonable. Calculated radial velocities and flow angles are favourably compared with the measurements at the exit of the impeller.


2014 ◽  
Vol 740 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mohamed Ali ◽  
Malek Abid

AbstractWe report a self-similar behaviour of solutions (obtained numerically) of the Navier–Stokes equations behind a single-blade rotor. That is, the helical vortex core in the wake of a rotating blade is self-similar as a function of its age. Profiles of vorticity and azimuthal velocity in the vortex core are characterized, their similarity variables are identified and scaling laws of these variables are given. Solutions of incompressible three-dimensional Navier–Stokes equations for Reynolds numbers up to $Re= 2000$ are considered.


1997 ◽  
Vol 119 (4) ◽  
pp. 900-905 ◽  
Author(s):  
X. Zheng ◽  
C. Liao ◽  
C. Liu ◽  
C. H. Sung ◽  
T. T. Huang

In this paper, computational results are presented for three-dimensional high-Reynolds number turbulent flows over a simplified submarine model. The simulation is based on the solution of Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes equations and two-equation turbulence models by using a preconditioned time-stepping approach. A multiblock method, in which the block loop is placed in the inner cycle of a multi-grid algorithm, is used to obtain versatility and efficiency. It was found that the calculated body drag, lift, side force coefficients and moments at various angles of attack or angles of drift are in excellent agreement with experimental data. Fast convergence has been achieved for all the cases with large angles of attack and with modest drift angles.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document