Abstract
DNMT3A mutations (DNMT3AMUT) are recurrent in AML. They predominate in patients with intermediate-risk (IR) cytogenetics and are often co-incident with FLT3ITD and NPM1MUT. Their prognostic impact is unclear. Most reports suggest they are associated with a worse outcome, but a large study including 1060 younger adult IR patients found that DNMT3AMUT had no significant impact on survival endpoints. Variable results have also been reported for different FLT3/NPM1 subgroups. Missense mutations at R882 in exon 23 occur in ≈65% of patients, but other missense and truncation mutations occur throughout the gene, mainly in exons 13-23. There is limited information on the prognostic impact of the different mutations, although they may have differing functional consequences. We therefore screened exons 13-23 in DNA samples from 914 younger adult AML patients (median age 43 years) with IR cytogenetics treated on UK MRC trials and evaluated outcome according to type of DNMT3Amutation.
Overall, 278 mutations were detected in 272 (30%) patients; 175 (64%) had R882 missense mutations, 59 (22%) other missense mutations, 35 (13%) truncations or in-frame deletions; 3 (1%) had 2 mutations of differing types. Median R882 mutant level in 172 mutated cases was 47% (range 15-85%), consistent with a heterozygous mutation in most cells. Patients with DNMT3AMUT were significantly older than those with DNMT3A wild-type (DNMT3AWT) (P<.0001), more likely to be female (P=.004), have a higher presenting WBC (P<.0001), and a normal rather than abnormal karyotype (P<.0001). The presence of DNMT3AMUT positively correlated with FLT3ITD (P=.0003) and NPM1MUT (P<.0001) and negatively correlated with CEBPAMUT (P<.0001). Patients with R882 mutations had significantly higher WBC (P=.005) and correlation with NPM1MUT (P=.01) than non-R882 mutated patients; non-R882 missense mutated patients had higher WBC (P=.05) and non-significant higher co-incidence with FLT3ITD than those with truncations.
Presence of DNMT3AMUT was associated with a poorer prognosis, but this difference was only seen if the results were analyzed separately according to NPM1 genotype, where DNMT3AMUT was associated with higher cumulative incidence of relapse (CIR) than DNMT3AWT in cases with NPM1MUT (49% vs 40%, P=.01) and NPM1WT (61% vs 58%, P=.5) genotype. Similarly, DNMT3AMUT patients had worse overall survival (OS) than DNMT3AWT patients with NPM1MUT (38% vs 50%, P=.008) and NPM1WT (15% vs 25%, P=.09) genotype. This statistical anomaly is an example of Simpson’s paradox. It results from the strong co-incidence of DNMT3A and NPM1 mutations with opposing prognostic associations that mask the effect seen separately when the groups are combined. Although the differences were smaller for NPM1WT cases, tests for heterogeneity showed that the impact of a DNMT3A mutation did not differ between NPM1MUT and NPM1WT for either CIR or OS, nor between the 4 genotypes defined by the combination of NPM1 and FLT3ITD genotypes. In multivariable analysis including age, WBC, NPM1 and FLT3ITD, DNMT3AMUT was a significant adverse risk factor for CIR (HR=1.27, CI=1.01-1.61; P=.04), and showed a trend for being adverse for OS (HR=1.19, CI=.98-1.45; P=.08).
When outcome was considered according to the type of mutation (R882, other missense or truncations), for the NPM1MUT genotype cases CIR was highest in R882 and other missense cases (51%, 50%) and truncation cases were similar to DNMT3AWT (35%, 40%). For NPM1WT, CIR was highest in R882 cases (76%), similar in other missense and DNMT3AWT cases (55%, 58%) and lowest in truncation cases (40%). Consistent with this data, for NPM1MUT genotype, OS was lowest in R882 and other missense cases (35%, 38%), better in DNMT3AWT (50%) and highest in truncation cases (57%). For NPM1WT, OS was lowest in R882 cases (11%), and similar in DNMT3AWT, other missense and truncation cases (25%, 21%, 18% respectively).
These data suggest that screening cannot be limited to the hotspot R882 mutations and that cases with missense mutations should be treated as poor risk, including those patients currently considered as favorable risk such as NPM1MUTFLT3WT. Conversely, truncation mutations have a different functional impact from missense mutations, more likely to result in haploinsufficiency than a dominant-negative effect, and these cases should be considered as equivalent to DNMT3AWT for prognostication and selection of therapy in 1st remission.
Disclosures
No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.
Essential Nonredundant Function of the Catalytic Activity of Histone Deacetylase 2 in Mouse Development
