Persistence of ground-layer bryophytes in a structural retention experiment: initial effects of level and pattern of overstory retention
We examined first-year responses of forest-floor bryophytes to structural retention harvests at four locations in western Washington. Treatments represented a range of retention levels (100%, 75%, 40%, and 15% of original basal area) and spatial patterns (dispersed vs. aggregated in 1 ha patches). Declines in bryophyte cover and species' frequencies were comparably large at 40% and 15% retention. Retention pattern had little effect on the magnitude of decline, although declines in richness tended to be greater in aggregated treatments. Changes in cover were small within forest aggregates (comparable to controls). However, richness declined relative to controls within aggregates at 15% retention; rarer taxa in these exposed patches may be susceptible to edge effects. Declines in species' frequencies and richness were consistently greater in "clear-cut" areas of aggregated treatments than in dispersed retention; liverworts were particularly sensitive to harvest. In cut areas, bryophytes responded positively to cover of understory vegetation and negatively to logging slash. The positive correlation of richness (but not cover) to tree basal area may reflect the contribution of tree boles to persistence of rarer corticolous species. Our results suggest that conservation of bryophytes in forests managed with structural retention will require large retention patches and dispersed trees at levels considerably higher than current retention standards.