Palliative whole brain radiation therapy (WBRT) for brain metastases (BM) revisited: The patient population in the modern era is different from the original patient cohort of the RTOG WBRT clinical trials
1544 Background: RTOG trials in the 1970’s established WBRT (3000 cGy/10 fractions) as an effective palliative tool for symptomatic BM. This was in the era before CT/ MRI and effective systemic therapy. Inclusion criteria was based on clinical symptoms, and studies such as EEG and arteriography though not required. This study was undertaken to determine if pts. in the modern era are similar to those aforementioned, since it may not be appropriate to use accelerated WBRT (aWBRT) in these pts. based on the RTOG guidelines if the cohorts are different. (Other issues such as delayed cognitive dysfunction, alopecia and the impact of and integration with systemic therapy are pertinent to the application and prescription of aWBRT, but not the focus of this study). Methods: A retrospective chart review of 414 consecutive pts. with BM treated with radiation therapy in a single practice from 1990 through 2004 form the basis of this study. There were 256 females and 158 males. Lung cancer was the most common primary site (249/60%) and breast cancer next (75/18%). 121 pts (29%) had a single brain metastsis. 66 symptomatic patients underwent surgical resection of a brain metastasis prior to WBRT. The use of CT or MRI was determined. Results: Of the 414 pts, 105 were asymptomatic (25%). An additonal 66 pts. were rendered asymptomatic with surgical resection. Therefore, a total of 171 (40%) pts. were asymptomatic. All pts underwent imaging with CT (132) or MRI (282). Conclusions: Many pts. with BM seen in a modern radiation oncology practice are different from those in the RTOG series’ in which pts. were designated to receive aWBRT. 1. A notable proportion (40%) of a large number of pts. treated since 1990 for BM was asymptomatic vs. none of the pts. in the RTOG trials. 2. All pts. in this series underwent direct imaging vs. none in the RTOG series’. The systematic prescription of aWBRT for all pts. with BM as dictated by RTOG studies in the 1970’s may not be appropriate and alternative strategies and clinical trials are warranted. No significant financial relationships to disclose.