The better bisphosphonate in patients with bone metastasis: Zoledronic acid or ibandronic acid? A study from Eastern India
e20524 Background: Ibandronic acid is a third generation bisphosphonate which acts by inhibition of osteoclasts. Zoledronic acid also has a similar mechanism of action. This study was designed to study superiority or inferiority of either agent over other in terms of efficacy in reducing bone pain and complications in patients with bone metastases. Methods: From Jan 2005 to Dec 2008, 240 patients of various malignancies with bone metatstasis were enrolled and were randomized on a 1:1 basis to receive monthly IV infusions of ibandronate or zoledronate and were analysed for pain relief, skeletal related events and adverse events. Results: Patients in both the arms were well matched for their diagnosis, stage of disease, burden of skeletal disease and performance status. Different diagnoses were, carcinoma breast (n=99), carcinoma prostate (n=54), myeloma (n=48), carcinoma lung (n=23), others (n=20). Median follow up was 18 months. At 18 months, mean increases in British Pain Inventory pain scores were lower with zoledronate compared to ibandronate (0.43 vs 0.88 [p=0.02]). Analgesic use as defined by 4 point analgesic scale was less with zoledronate as compared to ibandronate. Incidence of skeletal related events was not significantly different between two arms (33% for zoledronate vs 39% for ibandronate [p=0.2]). Median time to first skeletal related event was not reached in either arm. At 18 months of median follow up, percentage of patients with skeletal related events were 39% in zoledronate arm vs 43% in ibandronate arm (p=0.06). Zoledronate caused fever in 30 (12.5%) patients and hypocalcemia in 10 patients. Ibandronte caused hypocalcemia in 3 patients. No cases of osteonecrosis of jaw were observed. Conclusions: Zoledronate is the preferred bisphosphonate in developing countries for its shorter infusion time and availability of cheaper generic brands. This study also indicates that it may be slightly better than ibandronate in reducing bone pain and preventing skeletal related events. No significant financial relationships to disclose.