The Myth of the Universal Haitian Republic, or Deux Nations dans la Nation
This chapter focuses on unity, or laconcorde—a crucial republican concept linked to fraternité—and its function in Boyer’s unified republican island state (over which he served as president for life from 1822 to 1843) and the realities of disunity and division within it. The chapter begins by unearthing the tension between territorial concorde and internal strife to reveal the limits and possibilities of Boyer’s unified island state, which it argues are based in the myth of the universal Haitian republic. Central to Boyer’s attempts to create territorial concorde is Beaubrun Ardouin’s little-studied Géographie de l’Ile d’Haïti (1832), which is analyzed in a second section. A final section contrasts Ardouin’s social scientific, imperial island strategy with the attempt to represent and create internal concorde among the island’s diverse populations in the liberal newspapers Le Républicain and L’Union. These newspapers focused on addressing and even ameliorating internal divisions within Haiti by attempting to narrate a more capacious and inclusive Haitian republic through an early example of the cultural nationalist movement known as indigénisme.