Comparison and predesign cost assessment of ozonation, membrane filtration and activated carbon for the treatment of recalcitrant organics, a conceptual study
Abstract The presence of micropollutants in the environment is today of major concern. These pollutants could have long-term impacts on the environment and on population health. Biological treatment of wastewater is generally insufficient to allow their complete elimination. The establishment of efficient treatments is then needed to degrade the refractory organic matter. Activated carbon adsorption, membrane filtration and oxidation processes are common suitable solutions. All of them have advantages and are effective to treat wastewaters but drawbacks are well known such as waste production, energy consumption or by-products formation. This study aims at defining a strategy to choose the best option according to the nature of the wastewater and the treatment objectives. A methodology was designed for the rating of theses processes to choose the best strategy regarding environmental, technical and economic criteria. A simulation of three wastewater treatment scenarios was carried out to compare the costs of ozonation, adsorption and reverse osmosis. According to the result obtained, a decision tree is proposed to define the best option for a tertiary treatment to reach reuse or discharge objectives.