scholarly journals Comparative Study of Dynamic Stall between an Aircraft Airfoil and a Wind Turbine Airfoil in an Air–Particle Flow

2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (22) ◽  
pp. 10920
Author(s):  
Junjun Jin ◽  
Zhiliang Lu ◽  
Tongqing Guo ◽  
Di Zhou ◽  
Qiaozhong Li

Dynamic stall in clean air flow has been well studied, but its exploration in air–particle (air–raindrop or air–sand) flow is still lacking. The aerodynamic performance loss of aircraft (NACA0012) and wind turbine (S809) airfoils and their differences during the hysteresis loop at different pitching parameters are also poorly understood. As shown in this paper, the reduced frequency has little effect on the value of the maximum lift coefficient increment caused by particles, but a larger one can enhance the hysteresis effect and drag the angle of attack, at which the maximum increment is obtained, from the up stroke to the down stroke. The large lift coefficient increments of two airfoils and their difference also have a similar change trend with the reduced frequency. Compared to that of NACA0012 airfoil, the increments of S809 airfoil are obviously greater at three mean angles of attack, especially at 8°, which is the commonly used operating angle. In addition, the angle of attack, at which the maximum lift coefficient is obtained, can be significantly changed by particles in two regions: one is under the effect of deep stall, the other is under the effect of light stall at a low, reduced frequency.

Author(s):  
Venkata Ravishankar Kasibhotla ◽  
Danesh Tafti

The paper is concerned with the prediction and analysis of dynamic stall of flow past a pitching NACA0012 airfoil at 1 million Reynolds number based on the chord length of the airfoil and at reduced frequency of 0.25 in a three dimensional flow field. The turbulence in the flow field is resolved using large eddy simulations with the dynamic Smagorinsky model at the sub grid scale. The development of dynamic stall vortex, shedding and reattachment as predicted by the present study are discussed in detail. This study has shown that the downstroke phase of the pitching motion is strongly three dimensional and is highly complex, whereas the flow is practically two dimensional during the upstroke. The lift coefficient agrees well with the measurements during the upstroke. However, there are differences during the downstroke. The computed lift coefficient undergoes a sharp drop during the start of the downstroke as the convected leading edge vortex moves away from the airfoil surface. This is followed by a recovery of the lift coefficient with the formation of a secondary trailing edge vortex. While these dynamics are clearly reflected in the predicted lift coefficient, the experimental evolution of lift during the downstroke maintains a fairly smooth and monotonic decrease in the lift coefficient with no lift recovery. The simulations also show that the reattachment process of the stalled airfoil is completed before the start of the upstroke in the subsequent cycle due to the high reduced frequency of the pitching cycle.


2019 ◽  
Vol 9 (18) ◽  
pp. 3909 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tongqing Guo ◽  
Junjun Jin ◽  
Zhiliang Lu ◽  
Di Zhou ◽  
Tongguang Wang

In this paper, the Navier-Stokes equations coupled with a Lagrangian discrete phase model are described to simulate the air-particle flows over the S809 airfoil of the Phase VI blade, the NH6MW25 airfoil of a 6 MW wind turbine blade and the NACA0012 airfoil. The simulation results demonstrate that, in an attached flow, the slight performance degradation is caused by the boundary layer momentum loss. After flow separation, the performance degradation becomes significant and is dominated by a more extensive separation due to particles, since the aerodynamic coefficient increments and the moving distance of separation point present similar variation trends with increasing angle of attack. Unlike the NACA0012 airfoil, a most particle-sensitive angle of attack is found in the light stall region for a wind turbine airfoil, at which the lift decrement and the drag increment reach their peak values. For the S809 airfoil, the most sensitive angle of attack is about 3° higher than that for the maximum lift-to-drag ratio. Hence, the aerodynamic performance of a wind turbine is very susceptible to particles. Based on the most sensitive angles of attack, the more sensitive scope of angles of attack of a blade airfoil and the more sensitive range of rotor tip speed ratios are predicted sequentially. The present study clarifies the principles for the performance degradation of a wind turbine airfoil due to particles and the conclusions are useful for the wind turbine design reducing the particle influences.


2015 ◽  
Vol 798 ◽  
pp. 8-14
Author(s):  
Kun Ye ◽  
Zheng Yin Ye ◽  
Zhan Qu

Wind energy has been attracting more and more attentions due to its clean and renewable source. The aerodynamic characteristic of wind turbine airfoil directly affects the turbine efficiency. In order to improve the airfoil aerodynamic characteristic, a new concept airfoil configuration for wind turbine is presented. A cave on the upper surface near the trailing edge is designed to generate a trapped vortex in the cave. The trapped vortex is used to stabilize the separated flow when the airfoil at high angle of attack. Combining with the Gurney flap, the airfoil with the cave behaves very good aerodynamic characteristics at wide range of incidences, especially at high angles of attack. The method is used on the well-known FFA-W3-301 turbine airfoil. By using numerical simulation, it is shown that the new airfoil has a higher lift than the original airfoil at the same angle of attack, the stall angle of attack increases from 12 degree to 17 degree, and the maximum lift coefficient increases approximately 64 percents. In addition, the effects of the chord-wise location of starting point of the designed cave are discussed. Therefore, it is believed that the new-designed concept can be investigated and explored further for wind turbine.


Author(s):  
D. De Tavernier ◽  
C. Ferreira ◽  
A. Viré ◽  
B. LeBlanc ◽  
S. Bernardy

2018 ◽  
Vol 8 (7) ◽  
pp. 1111 ◽  
Author(s):  
Shuang Li ◽  
Lei Zhang ◽  
Ke Yang ◽  
Jin Xu ◽  
Xue Li

Energies ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 13 (10) ◽  
pp. 2535
Author(s):  
Chengyong Zhu ◽  
Tongguang Wang ◽  
Jie Chen ◽  
Wei Zhong

Passive vortex generators (VGs) have been widely applied on wind turbines to boost the aerodynamic performance. Although VGs can delay the onset of static stall, the effect of VGs on dynamic stall is still incompletely understood. Therefore, this paper aims at investigating the deep dynamic stall of NREL S809 airfoil controlled by single-row and double-row VGs. The URANS method with VGs fully resolved is used to simulate the unsteady airfoil flow. Firstly, both single-row and double-row VGs effectively suppress the flow separation and reduce the fluctuations in aerodynamic forces when the airfoil pitches up. The maximum lift coefficient is therefore increased beyond 40%, and the onset of deep dynamic stall is also delayed. This suggests that deep dynamic-stall behaviors can be properly controlled by VGs. Secondly, there is a great difference in aerodynamic performance between single-row and double-row VGs when the airfoil pitches down. Single-row VGs severely reduce the aerodynamic pitch damping by 64%, thereby undermining the torsional aeroelastic stability of airfoil. Double-row VGs quickly restore the decreased aerodynamic efficiency near the maximum angle of attack, and also significantly accelerate the flow reattachment. The second-row VGs can help the near-wall flow to withstand the adverse pressure gradient and then suppress the trailing-edge flow separation, particularly during the downstroke process. Generally, double-row VGs are better than single-row VGs concerning controlling deep dynamic stall. This work also gives a performance assessment of VGs in controlling the highly unsteady aerodynamic forces of a wind turbine airfoil.


Author(s):  
Peter J. Attar ◽  
Raymond E. Gordnier ◽  
Jordan W. Johnston ◽  
William A. Romberg ◽  
Ramkumar N. Parthasarathy

The fluid and structural response of two different membrane wing Micro Air Vehicles is studied through computation and experiment. A (three) batten-reinforced fixed wing membrane micro air vehicle is used to determine the effect of membrane prestrain and fixed angle of attack on flutter and limit cycle behavior of fixed wing membrane Micro Air Vehicles. For each configuration tested, flutter and subsequent limit cycle oscillations are measured in wind tunnel tests and predicted using an aeroelastic computational model consisting of a nonlinear finite element model coupled to a vortex lattice solution of the Laplace equation and boundary conditions. Correlation between the predicted and measured onset of limit cycle oscillation is good as is the prediction of the amplitude of the limit cycle at the trailing edge of the lower membrane. A direct correlation between levels of strain and the phase of the membranes during the limit cycle is found in the computation and thought to also occur in the experiment. The second membrane wing micro air vehicle configuration is that of a plunging membrane airfoil model. This model is studied computationally using a sixth-order finite difference solution of the Navier-Stokes equations coupled to a nonlinear string finite element model. The effect, on the structural and fluid response, of plunging Strouhal number, reduced frequency and static angle of attack is examined. At two degree angle of attack, and Strouhal number of 0.2, the effect of increasing the plunging reduced frequency is to decrease the sectional lift coefficient and increase the sectional drag coefficient. At this angle of attack, minimal change in the sectional lift coefficient is found when increasing from a Strouhal number of 0.2 to 0.5 at reduced frequencies of 0.5 and 5.903, the lowest and highest values of this parameter which are studied in this work. For this angle of attack the maximum change which occurs when increasing the Strouhal number from 0.2 to 0.5 is at a reduced frequency of 1.5. When the effect of angle of attack is studied, it is found that at a Strouhal number of 0.5 and reduced frequency of 1.5 the plunging flexible model demonstrates improved lift characteristics over the fixed flexible airfoil case. The greatest improvement occurs at an angle of attack of 2 degrees followed by 10 degrees and then 6 degrees. Finally the effect on the flow characteristics of airfoil flexibility is investigated by increasing the membrane pre-strain from a nominal value of 5 percent to that of 20 percent. This increase in pre-strain results in a reduced value of sectional lift coefficient as compared the 5 percent pre-strain case at the same fixed angle of attack, Strouhal number and reduced frequency.


2017 ◽  
Vol 140 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Ravon Venters ◽  
Brian T. Helenbrook ◽  
Kenneth D. Visser

This study presents a numerical optimization of a ducted wind turbine (DWT) to maximize power output. The cross section of the duct was an Eppler 423 airfoil, which is a cambered airfoil with a high lift coefficient (CL). The rotor was modeled as an actuator disk, and the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) k–ε model was used to simulate the flow. The optimization determined the optimal placement and angle for the duct relative to the rotor disk, as well as the optimal coefficient of thrust for the rotor. It was determined that the optimal coefficient of thrust is similar to an open rotor in spite of the fact that the local flow velocity is modified by the duct. The optimal angle of attack of the duct was much larger than the separation angle of attack of the airfoil in a freestream. Large angles of attack did not induce separation on the duct because the expansion caused by the rotor disk helped keep the flow attached. For the same rotor area, the power output of the largest DWT was 66% greater than an open rotor. For the same total cross-sectional area of the entire device, the DWT also outperformed an open rotor, exceeding Betz's limit by a small margin.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document