The effect of sample grinding on extractable iron and aluminum in soils
Pyrophosphate-, dithionite- and acid ammonium oxalate-extractable Fe and Al are often measured on a finely ground aliquot of soil. Grinding provides a homogeneous sample from which a representative subsample can be obtained at sampling aliquots of less than 1 g. When a significant portion of the unground soil is greater than the sieve mesh size used when grinding, abrasion of primary minerals may cause increased levels of extractable Fe and Al. This study examined the distribution of extractable Fe and Al in some sandy soils and compared their levels in samples ground to < 500 μm and < 150 μm with those in unground < 2-mm soil. Samples ground to < 150 μm yielded the highest amounts of extractable Fe and Al. This effect was most prevalent when a motorized mortar and pestle was used. Samples ground to < 500 μm, which were frequently re-sieved to avoid over-grinding, contained similar amounts of extractable Fe and Al as the unground < 2-mm sample. If less than 1 g of soil is used for analysis, a sample manually ground to < 500 μm (35 mesh) is advisable and a protocol for sample grinding is recommended. Key words: Iron, aluminum, pyrophosphate, dithionite, oxalate, grinding