Assessing Variability of Wind Speed: Comparison and Validation of 27 Methodologies
Abstract. Because wind resources vary from year to year, the inter-monthly and inter-annual variability (IAV) of wind speed is a key component of the overall uncertainty in the wind resource assessment process thereby causing challenges to wind-farm operators and owners. We present a critical assessment of several common approaches for calculating variability by applying each of the methods to the same 37-year monthly wind-speed and energy-production time series to highlight the differences between these methods. We then assess the accuracy of the variability calculations by correlating the wind-speed variability estimates to the variabilities of actual wind-farm energy production. We recommend the Robust Coefficient of Variation (RCoV) for systematically estimating variability, and we underscore its advantages as well as the importance of using a statistically robust and resistant method. Using normalized spread metrics, including RCoV, high variability of monthly mean wind speeds at a location effectively denotes strong fluctuations of monthly total energy generations, and vice versa. Meanwhile, the wind-speed IAVs computed with annual-mean data fail to adequately represent energy-production IAVs of wind farms. Finally, we find that estimates of energy-generation variability require 10 ± 3 years of monthly mean wind-speed records to achieve 90 % statistical confidence. This paper also provides guidance on the spatial distribution of wind-speed RCoV.