Developmental influence on evolutionary rates and the origin of placental mammal tooth complexity

Development has often been viewed as a constraining force on morphological adaptation, but its precise influence, especially on evolutionary rates, is poorly understood. Placental mammals provide a classic example of adaptive radiation, but the debate around rate and drivers of early placental evolution remains contentious. A hallmark of early dental evolution in many placental lineages was a transition from a triangular upper molar to a more complex upper molar with a rectangular cusp pattern better specialized for crushing. To examine how development influenced this transition, we simulated dental evolution on “landscapes” built from different parameters of a computational model of tooth morphogenesis. Among the parameters examined, we find that increases in the number of enamel knots, the developmental precursors of the tooth cusps, were primarily influenced by increased self-regulation of the molecular activator (activation), whereas the pattern of knots resulted from changes in both activation and biases in tooth bud growth. In simulations, increased activation facilitated accelerated evolutionary increases in knot number, creating a lateral knot arrangement that evolved at least ten times on placental upper molars. Relatively small increases in activation, superimposed on an ancestral tritubercular molar growth pattern, could recreate key changes leading to a rectangular upper molar cusp pattern. Tinkering with tooth bud geometry varied the way cusps initiated along the posterolingual molar margin, suggesting that small spatial variations in ancestral molar growth may have influenced how placental lineages acquired a hypocone cusp. We suggest that development could have enabled relatively fast higher-level divergence of the placental molar dentition.

The initiation knot is a signaling center required for molar tooth development

ABSTRACT Signaling centers, or organizers, regulate many aspects of embryonic morphogenesis. In the mammalian molar tooth, reiterative signaling in specialized centers called enamel knots (EKs) determines tooth patterning. Preceding the primary EK, transient epithelial thickening appears, the significance of which remains debated. Using tissue confocal fluorescence imaging with laser ablation experiments, we show that this transient thickening is an earlier signaling center, the molar initiation knot (IK), that is required for the progression of tooth development. IK cell dynamics demonstrate the hallmarks of a signaling center: cell cycle exit, condensation and eventual silencing through apoptosis. IK initiation and maturation are defined by the juxtaposition of cells with high Wnt activity to Shh-expressing non-proliferating cells, the combination of which drives the growth of the tooth bud, leading to the formation of the primary EK as an independent cell cluster. Overall, the whole development of the tooth, from initiation to patterning, is driven by the iterative use of signaling centers.

Does endometrial morular metaplasia represent odontogenic differentiation?

The nature of endometrial morular metaplasia (MorM) is still unknown. The nuclear β-catenin accumulation and the not rare ghost cell keratinization suggest a similarity with hard keratin-producing odontogenic and hair matrix tumors rather than with squamous differentiation. We aimed to compare MorM to hard keratin-producing tumors. Forty-one hard keratin-producing tumors, including 26 hair matrix tumors (20 pilomatrixomas and 6 pilomatrix carcinomas) and 15 odontogenic tumors (adamantinomatous craniopharyngiomas), were compared to 15 endometrioid carcinomas with MorM with or without squamous/keratinizing features. Immunohistochemistry for β-catenin, CD10, CDX2, ki67, p63, CK5/6, CK7, CK8/18, CK19, and pan-hard keratin was performed; 10 cases of endometrioid carcinomas with conventional squamous differentiation were used as controls. In adamantinomatous craniopharyngiomas, the β-catenin-accumulating cell clusters (whorl-like structures) were morphologically similar to MorM (round syncytial aggregates of bland cells with round-to-spindled nuclei and profuse cytoplasm), with overlapping squamous/keratinizing features (clear cells with prominent membrane, rounded squamous formations, ghost cells). Both MorM and whorl-like structures consistently showed positivity for CD10 and CDX2, with low ki67; cytokeratins pattern was also overlapping, although more variable. Hard keratin was focally/multifocally positive in 8 MorM cases and focally in one conventional squamous differentiation case. Hair matrix tumors showed no morphological or immunophenotypical overlap with MorM. MorM shows wide morphological and immunophenotypical overlap with the whorl-like structures of adamantinomatous craniopharyngiomas, which are analogous to enamel knots of tooth development. This suggests that MorM might be an aberrant mimic of odontogenic differentiation.

The Initiation Knot is a Signaling Center Required for Molar Tooth Development

SummarySignaling centers, or organizers, regulate many aspects of embryonic morphogenesis. In the mammalian molar tooth, reiterative signaling in specialized centers called enamel knots (EKs) determine tooth patterning. Preceding the first, primary EK, a transient epithelial thickening appears whose significance remains debated. Here, using tissue confocal fluorescence imaging with laser ablation experiments, we show that this transient thickening is an earlier signaling center, the molar initiation knot (IK) that is required for the progression of tooth development. IK cell dynamics manifest the hallmarks of a signaling center; cell cycle exit, condensation, and eventual silencing through apoptosis. IK initiation and maturation are defined by the juxtaposition of high Wnt activity cells to Shh-expressing non-proliferating cells, the combination of which drives the growth of the tooth bud, leading to the formation of the primary EK as an independent cell cluster. Overall, the whole development of the tooth, from initiation to patterning, is driven by the iterative use of signaling centers.

Predicting Evolutionary Transitions in Tooth Complexity With a Morphogenetic Model

The extent to which evolutionary transitions are shaped by developmental bias remains poorly understood. Classically, morphological variation is assumed to be abundant and continuous, but if morphogenesis biases how traits vary than evolutionary transitions might follow somewhat predictable steps. Compared to other anatomical structures, teeth have an exceptional fossil record which documents striking evolutionary trajectories toward complexity. Using computer simulations of tooth morphogenesis, we examined how varying developmental parameters influenced transitions from morphologically simple to complex teeth. We find that as tooth complexity increases, development tends to generate progressively more discontinuous variation which could make the fine-tuning of dietary adaptation difficult. Transitions from simple to complex teeth required an early shift from mesiodistal to lateral cusp patterning which is congruent with patterns of dental complexification in early mammals. We infer that the contributions of primary enamel knot cells to secondary enamel knots which are responsible for patterning lateral cusps may have been an important developmental innovation in tribosphenic mammals. Our results provide evidence that development can bias evolutionary transitions and highlights how morphogenetic modelling can play an important role in building more realistic models of morphological character evolution.

An Explanation for How FGFs Predict Species-Specific Tooth Cusp Patterns

Species-specific cusp patterns result from the iterative formation of enamel knots, the epithelial signaling centers, at the future cusp positions. The expressions of fibroblast growth factors (FGFs), especially Fgf4, in the secondary enamel knots in the areas of the future cusp tips are generally used to manifest the appearance of species-specific tooth shapes. However, the mechanism underlying the predictive role of FGFs in species-specific cusp patterns remains obscure. Here, we demonstrated that gerbils, which have a lophodont pattern, exhibit a striped expression pattern of Fgf4, whereas mice, which have a bunodont pattern, have a spotted expression pattern, and these observations verify the predictive role of Fgf4 in species-specific cusp patterns. By manipulating FGFs’ signaling in the inner dental epithelium of gerbils, we provide evidence for the intracellular participation of FGF signaling, specifically FGF4 and FGF20, in Rac1- and RhoA-regulated cellular geometry remolding during the determination of different cusp patterns. Our study presents a novel explanation of how different FGF expression patterns produce different cusp patterns and implies that a conserved intracellular FGF-GTPase signaling module might represent an underlying developmental basis for evolutionary changes in cusp patterns.

Post-natal Effect of Overexpressed DKK1 on Mandibular Molar Formation

Dickkopf-related protein 1 (DKK1) is a potent inhibitor of Wnt/β-catenin signaling. Dkk1-null mutant embryos display severe defects in head induction. Conversely, targeted expression of Dkk1 in dental epithelial cells leads to the formation of dysfunctional enamel knots and subsequent tooth defects during embryonic development. However, its role in post-natal dentinogenesis is largely unknown. To address this issue, we studied the role of DKK1 in post-natal dentin development using 2.3-kb Col1a1- Dkk1 transgenic mice, with the following key findings: (1) The Dkk1 transgene was highly expressed in pulp and odontoblast cells during post-natal developmental stages; (2) the 1st molar displayed short roots, an enlarged pulp/root canal region, and a decrease in the dentin formation rate; (3) a small malformed second molar and an absent third molar; (4) an increase of immature odontoblasts, few mature odontoblasts, and sharply reduced dentinal tubules; and (5) a dramatic change in Osx and nestin expression. We propose that DKK1 controls post-natal mandibular molar dentin formation either directly or indirectly via the inhibition of Wnt signaling at the following aspects: (i) post-natal dentin formation, (ii) formation and/or maintenance of the dentin tubular system, (iii) mineralization of the dentin, and (iv) regulation of molecules such as Osx and nestin.

Molar Intercuspal Dimensions: Genetic Input to Phenotypic Variation

Molecular studies indicate that epigenetic events are important in determining how the internal enamel epithelium folds during odontogenesis. Since this process of folding leads to the subsequent arrangement of cusps on molar teeth, we hypothesized that intercuspal distances of human molar teeth would display greater phenotypic variation but lower heritabilities than overall crown diameters. Intercuspal distances and maximum crown diameters were recorded from digitized images of dental casts in 100 monozygotic and 74 dizygotic twin pairs. Intercuspal distances displayed less sexual dimorphism in mean values but greater relative variability and fluctuating asymmetry than overall crown measures. Correlations between intercuspal distances and overall crown measures were low. Models incorporating only environmental effects accounted for observed variation in several intercuspal measures. For those intercuspal variables displaying significant additive genetic variance, estimates of heritability ranged from 43 to 79%, whereas those for overall crown size were higher generally, ranging from 60 to 82%. Our finding of high phenotypic variation in intercuspal distances with only moderate genetic contribution is consistent with substantial epigenetic influence on the progressive folding of the internal enamel epithelium, following formation of the primary and secondary enamel knots.