The taxonomy and systematics of the door snail genus Siciliaria was revised based on an integrative approach including a comprehensive genital anatomical investigation, which was combined with shell morphology and DNA sequence data (mitochondrial COI, nuclear ITS2 sequences). The genital morphology of 118 specimens of 21 taxa from 43 populations was investigated and a new general description of the genital morphology of the genus is provided. Additionally, 26 specimens of 14 taxa of additional 5 genera (sensu Bank & Neubert, 2019) of Alopiinae (Mauritanica, Charpentieria, Stigmatica, Gibbularia, Papillifera, and the here reintroduced genus Tirolica) were included in the genetic analyses.
In the phylogenetic tree based on COI sequences, the species of the genus Siciliaria s.l. from northwestern Sicily were found within two separate highly supported main clades. In the tree based on the nuclear ITS2 marker sequence, resolution was considerably lower, albeit, the tree partially confirmed the mitochondrial tree. We re-introduced Sicania Tomlin, 1929 (corresponding to main clade II in the tree). Siciliaria scarificata did not appear in one of the two main clades but was the sister group of Mauretanica perinni polygyra. Concerning monophyly of species, only the widely distributed S. calcarae was paraphyletic in the COI tree, a finding that has to be investigated further with multiple marker sequences.
For the other genera (Charpentieria, Stigmatica, Gibbularia, Papillifera and Tirolica) we provide here also detailed descriptions of the genital anatomy of 51 taxa for a total amount of 191 dissected specimens. Several of these taxa could be included in the phylogenetic analysis and were found in several quite distinct lineages. Although the taxon sampling of these taxa was far from being complete, the comprehensive data provided here (concerning morphology, genetics and distribution) provide first insights into this diverse group of clausiliid taxa.