Studies of Seismic Velocities in Subduction Zones from Continuous Ocean Bottom Seismometer Data

<p><b>This thesis uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by Ocean Bottom Seismometers (OBSs) to study seismic velocities in the upper crust of the overriding plate. The first and second projects (Chapters 3 and 4) focus on temporal seismic velocity variations in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone offshore the North Island, New Zealand, while the third project (Chapter 5) focuses on shear wave velocities in the southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. In the first project (Chapters 3), we investigate a region of frequent slow slip events (SSEs) offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. From September to October 2014, an SSE occurred with a slip over 250 mm and was recorded successfully by the Hikurangi Ocean Bottom Investigation of Tremor and Slow Slip deployment II (HOBITSS II). We apply coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by nine OBSs deployed by the HOBITSS II to study the seismic velocity variations related to the SSE. The average velocity variations display a decrease on the order of 0.05% during the SSE, followed by an increase of similar magnitude afterwards. Two hypotheses are proposed to explain our observation. The first hypothesis, which has been suggested by previous studies, considers that the velocity decrease during the SSE is caused by more fluids migrating into the upper plate as the SSE breaks a low-permeability seal on the plate boundary. After the SSE, the fluids in the upper plate diffuse gradually and the velocity increases; The second hypothesis is that before the SSE, elastic strain accumulates causing contraction and reduction of porosity and therefore increase of velocity (the velocity increase between SSEs). During the SSE, the velocity decrease is caused by increased porosity as the SSE relieves the accumulated elastic strain on the plate interface, which results in dilation. After the SSE, stress and strain accumulate again, causing a porosity decrease and a velocity increase back to the original value. This study demonstrates that the velocity variations related to SSEs are observable and provides evidence for slow slip mechanism hypotheses.</b></p> <p>The second project (Chapter 4) focuses on the temporal seismic velocity variations associated with an SSE in 2019 offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. This is a later SSE in the same area as the first project (Chapters 3). Based on the success of the HOBITSS II, more ocean bottom instruments were deployed in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone from 2018 to 2019 (HOBITSS V). An SSE lasting approximately one month from the end of March to the beginning of May 2019 occurred during the deployment and was recorded by the network. The main slip was south of the deployment and the slip beneath the deployment was up to 150 mm. This study applies coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by five OBSs and computes seismic velocity variations to investigate their relation to the SSE. A velocity decrease on the order of 0.015% during the SSE and an increase back to the original velocity value are observed at 1–2.5 s. This supports the two hypotheses proposed in Chapters 3: fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. In addition, velocity variations computed from individual stations show velocity increases before the SSE, which are destructively interfered in their average. Such a situation could occur if the SSE migrated across the network. If the velocity increases before the SSE from individual stations are real, they can be only explained by the hypothesis of crustal strain changes (the second hypothesis in project 1). However, fluid migration (the first hypothesis in project 1) may still happen concomitantly.</p> <p>The third project focuses on the tectonics in southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. The southwestern Okinawa Trough is an active back-arc basin, extending and rifting within the continental lithosphere. The tectonic development of the back-arc basin is still not well-understood. This study uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by 34 OBSs deployed by Academia Sinica at various periods from 2010 to 2018. Cross-correlations on vertical seismic components and pressure gauges are computed to construct Rayleigh/Scholte waves to study the shear wave velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough. Phase velocities are measured from the Rayleigh/Scholte waves. Shear velocities are inverted from the phase velocities. Results show the velocity in the south of the back-arc rifting axis near the axis is slower than the velocity in the north of the rifting axis, suggesting the velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis. Previous studies have shown high heat flows (about 110mW/m 2 on average) in the south of the rifting axis. The low velocity in the south could be caused by the high heat flow that may be related to asymmetric back-arc extension and/or rifting. This study presents the shear wave velocity structure in the southwest Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis, which implies the back-arc extending/rifting is asymmetric in the study region. This study also suggests effective techniques for OBS noise corrections and unwrapping the cycle skipping of phase velocity measurements.</p> <p>In summary, this thesis represents three projects focusing on seismic velocities in two subduction zones using ambient noise data collected by OBSs. The first and second projects study the temporal velocity variations and the relation to SSEs. Both studies observe velocity decreases during the SSEs and increases after the SSEs, supporting two hypotheses of fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. The third project finds the shear velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting center, which may imply the back-arc extension is asymmetric.</p>

How distinctive are flood-triggered turbidity currents?

ABSTRACT Turbidity currents triggered at river mouths form an important highway for sediment, organic carbon, and nutrients to the deep sea. Consequently, it has been proposed that the deposits of these flood-triggered turbidity currents provide important long-term records of past river floods, continental erosion, and climate. Various depositional models have been suggested to identify river-flood-triggered turbidite deposits, which are largely based on the assumption that a characteristic velocity structure of the flood-triggered turbidity current is preserved as a recognizable vertical grain size trend in their deposits. Four criteria have been proposed for the velocity structure of flood-triggered turbidity currents: prolonged flow duration; a gradual increase in velocity; cyclicity of velocity magnitude; and a low peak velocity. However, very few direct observations of flood-triggered turbidity currents exist to test these proposed velocity structures. Here we present direct measurements from the Var Canyon, offshore Nice in the Mediterranean Sea. An acoustic Doppler current profiler was located 6 km offshore from the river mouth, and provided detailed velocity measurements that can be directly linked to the state of the river. Another mooring, positioned 16 km offshore, showed how this velocity structure evolved down-canyon. Three turbidity currents were measured at these moorings, two of which are associated with river floods. The third event was not linked to a river flood and was most likely triggered by a seabed slope failure. The multi-pulsed and prolonged velocity structure of all three (flood- and landslide-triggered) events is similar at the first mooring, suggesting that it may not be diagnostic of flood triggering. Indeed, the event that was most likely triggered by a slope failure matched the four flood-triggered criteria best, as it had prolonged duration, cyclicity, low velocity, and a gradual onset. Hence, previously assumed velocity-structure criteria used to identify flood-triggered turbidity currents may be produced by other triggers. Next, this study shows how the proximal multi-pulsed velocity structure reorganizes down-canyon to produce a single velocity pulse. Such rapid-onset, single-pulse velocity structure has previously been linked to landslide-triggered events. Flows recorded in this study show amalgamation of multiple velocity pulses leading to shredding of the flood signal, so that the original initiation mechanism is no longer discernible at just 16 km from the river mouth. Recognizing flood-triggered turbidity currents and their deposits may thus be challenging, as similar velocity structures can be formed by different triggers, and this proximal velocity structure can rapidly be lost due to self-organization of the turbidity current.

Studies of Seismic Velocities in Subduction Zones from Continuous Ocean Bottom Seismometer Data

<p><b>This thesis uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by Ocean Bottom Seismometers (OBSs) to study seismic velocities in the upper crust of the overriding plate. The first and second projects (Chapters 3 and 4) focus on temporal seismic velocity variations in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone offshore the North Island, New Zealand, while the third project (Chapter 5) focuses on shear wave velocities in the southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. In the first project (Chapters 3), we investigate a region of frequent slow slip events (SSEs) offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. From September to October 2014, an SSE occurred with a slip over 250 mm and was recorded successfully by the Hikurangi Ocean Bottom Investigation of Tremor and Slow Slip deployment II (HOBITSS II). We apply coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by nine OBSs deployed by the HOBITSS II to study the seismic velocity variations related to the SSE. The average velocity variations display a decrease on the order of 0.05% during the SSE, followed by an increase of similar magnitude afterwards. Two hypotheses are proposed to explain our observation. The first hypothesis, which has been suggested by previous studies, considers that the velocity decrease during the SSE is caused by more fluids migrating into the upper plate as the SSE breaks a low-permeability seal on the plate boundary. After the SSE, the fluids in the upper plate diffuse gradually and the velocity increases; The second hypothesis is that before the SSE, elastic strain accumulates causing contraction and reduction of porosity and therefore increase of velocity (the velocity increase between SSEs). During the SSE, the velocity decrease is caused by increased porosity as the SSE relieves the accumulated elastic strain on the plate interface, which results in dilation. After the SSE, stress and strain accumulate again, causing a porosity decrease and a velocity increase back to the original value. This study demonstrates that the velocity variations related to SSEs are observable and provides evidence for slow slip mechanism hypotheses.</b></p> <p>The second project (Chapter 4) focuses on the temporal seismic velocity variations associated with an SSE in 2019 offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. This is a later SSE in the same area as the first project (Chapters 3). Based on the success of the HOBITSS II, more ocean bottom instruments were deployed in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone from 2018 to 2019 (HOBITSS V). An SSE lasting approximately one month from the end of March to the beginning of May 2019 occurred during the deployment and was recorded by the network. The main slip was south of the deployment and the slip beneath the deployment was up to 150 mm. This study applies coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by five OBSs and computes seismic velocity variations to investigate their relation to the SSE. A velocity decrease on the order of 0.015% during the SSE and an increase back to the original velocity value are observed at 1–2.5 s. This supports the two hypotheses proposed in Chapters 3: fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. In addition, velocity variations computed from individual stations show velocity increases before the SSE, which are destructively interfered in their average. Such a situation could occur if the SSE migrated across the network. If the velocity increases before the SSE from individual stations are real, they can be only explained by the hypothesis of crustal strain changes (the second hypothesis in project 1). However, fluid migration (the first hypothesis in project 1) may still happen concomitantly.</p> <p>The third project focuses on the tectonics in southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. The southwestern Okinawa Trough is an active back-arc basin, extending and rifting within the continental lithosphere. The tectonic development of the back-arc basin is still not well-understood. This study uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by 34 OBSs deployed by Academia Sinica at various periods from 2010 to 2018. Cross-correlations on vertical seismic components and pressure gauges are computed to construct Rayleigh/Scholte waves to study the shear wave velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough. Phase velocities are measured from the Rayleigh/Scholte waves. Shear velocities are inverted from the phase velocities. Results show the velocity in the south of the back-arc rifting axis near the axis is slower than the velocity in the north of the rifting axis, suggesting the velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis. Previous studies have shown high heat flows (about 110mW/m 2 on average) in the south of the rifting axis. The low velocity in the south could be caused by the high heat flow that may be related to asymmetric back-arc extension and/or rifting. This study presents the shear wave velocity structure in the southwest Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis, which implies the back-arc extending/rifting is asymmetric in the study region. This study also suggests effective techniques for OBS noise corrections and unwrapping the cycle skipping of phase velocity measurements.</p> <p>In summary, this thesis represents three projects focusing on seismic velocities in two subduction zones using ambient noise data collected by OBSs. The first and second projects study the temporal velocity variations and the relation to SSEs. Both studies observe velocity decreases during the SSEs and increases after the SSEs, supporting two hypotheses of fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. The third project finds the shear velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting center, which may imply the back-arc extension is asymmetric.</p>

Studies of Seismic Velocities in Subduction Zones from Continuous Ocean Bottom Seismometer Data

<p><b>This thesis uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by Ocean Bottom Seismometers (OBSs) to study seismic velocities in the upper crust of the overriding plate. The first and second projects (Chapters 3 and 4) focus on temporal seismic velocity variations in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone offshore the North Island, New Zealand, while the third project (Chapter 5) focuses on shear wave velocities in the southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. In the first project (Chapters 3), we investigate a region of frequent slow slip events (SSEs) offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. From September to October 2014, an SSE occurred with a slip over 250 mm and was recorded successfully by the Hikurangi Ocean Bottom Investigation of Tremor and Slow Slip deployment II (HOBITSS II). We apply coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by nine OBSs deployed by the HOBITSS II to study the seismic velocity variations related to the SSE. The average velocity variations display a decrease on the order of 0.05% during the SSE, followed by an increase of similar magnitude afterwards. Two hypotheses are proposed to explain our observation. The first hypothesis, which has been suggested by previous studies, considers that the velocity decrease during the SSE is caused by more fluids migrating into the upper plate as the SSE breaks a low-permeability seal on the plate boundary. After the SSE, the fluids in the upper plate diffuse gradually and the velocity increases; The second hypothesis is that before the SSE, elastic strain accumulates causing contraction and reduction of porosity and therefore increase of velocity (the velocity increase between SSEs). During the SSE, the velocity decrease is caused by increased porosity as the SSE relieves the accumulated elastic strain on the plate interface, which results in dilation. After the SSE, stress and strain accumulate again, causing a porosity decrease and a velocity increase back to the original value. This study demonstrates that the velocity variations related to SSEs are observable and provides evidence for slow slip mechanism hypotheses.</b></p> <p>The second project (Chapter 4) focuses on the temporal seismic velocity variations associated with an SSE in 2019 offshore Gisborne, North Island, New Zealand. This is a later SSE in the same area as the first project (Chapters 3). Based on the success of the HOBITSS II, more ocean bottom instruments were deployed in the northern Hikurangi subduction zone from 2018 to 2019 (HOBITSS V). An SSE lasting approximately one month from the end of March to the beginning of May 2019 occurred during the deployment and was recorded by the network. The main slip was south of the deployment and the slip beneath the deployment was up to 150 mm. This study applies coda wave interferometry on the ambient noise data acquired by five OBSs and computes seismic velocity variations to investigate their relation to the SSE. A velocity decrease on the order of 0.015% during the SSE and an increase back to the original velocity value are observed at 1–2.5 s. This supports the two hypotheses proposed in Chapters 3: fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. In addition, velocity variations computed from individual stations show velocity increases before the SSE, which are destructively interfered in their average. Such a situation could occur if the SSE migrated across the network. If the velocity increases before the SSE from individual stations are real, they can be only explained by the hypothesis of crustal strain changes (the second hypothesis in project 1). However, fluid migration (the first hypothesis in project 1) may still happen concomitantly.</p> <p>The third project focuses on the tectonics in southwestern Okinawa Trough offshore northeastern Taiwan. The southwestern Okinawa Trough is an active back-arc basin, extending and rifting within the continental lithosphere. The tectonic development of the back-arc basin is still not well-understood. This study uses continuous ambient noise data recorded by 34 OBSs deployed by Academia Sinica at various periods from 2010 to 2018. Cross-correlations on vertical seismic components and pressure gauges are computed to construct Rayleigh/Scholte waves to study the shear wave velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough. Phase velocities are measured from the Rayleigh/Scholte waves. Shear velocities are inverted from the phase velocities. Results show the velocity in the south of the back-arc rifting axis near the axis is slower than the velocity in the north of the rifting axis, suggesting the velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis. Previous studies have shown high heat flows (about 110mW/m 2 on average) in the south of the rifting axis. The low velocity in the south could be caused by the high heat flow that may be related to asymmetric back-arc extension and/or rifting. This study presents the shear wave velocity structure in the southwest Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting axis, which implies the back-arc extending/rifting is asymmetric in the study region. This study also suggests effective techniques for OBS noise corrections and unwrapping the cycle skipping of phase velocity measurements.</p> <p>In summary, this thesis represents three projects focusing on seismic velocities in two subduction zones using ambient noise data collected by OBSs. The first and second projects study the temporal velocity variations and the relation to SSEs. Both studies observe velocity decreases during the SSEs and increases after the SSEs, supporting two hypotheses of fluid migration and/or stain changes through the SSE cycle. The third project finds the shear velocity structure in the southwestern Okinawa Trough is asymmetric along the rifting center, which may imply the back-arc extension is asymmetric.</p>

Why Differential Data Work

ABSTRACT This article explains the features of differential data that make them attractive, their shortcomings, and the situations for which they are best suited. The use of differential data is ubiquitous in the seismological community, in which they are used to determine earthquake locations via the double-difference method and the Earth’s velocity structure via geotomography; furthermore, they have important applications in other areas of geophysics, as well. A common assumption is that differential data are uncorrelated and have uniform variance. We show that this assumption is well justified when the original, undifferenced data covary with each other according to a two-sided exponential function. It is not well justified when they covary according to a Gaussian function. Differences of exponentially correlated data are approximately uncorrelated with uniform variance when they are regularly spaced in distance. However, when they are irregularly spaced, they are uncorrelated with a nonuniform variance that scales with the spacing of the data. When differential data are computed by taking differences of the original, undifferenced data, model parameters estimated using ordinary least squares applied to the differential data are almost exactly equal to those estimated using weighed least squares applied to the original, undifferenced data (with the weights given by the inverse covariance matrix). A better solution only results when the differential data are directly estimated and their variance is smaller than is implied by differencing the original data. Differential data may be appropriate for global seismic travel-time data because the covariance of errors in predicted travel times may have a covariance close to a two-sided exponential, on account of the upper mantle being close to a Von Karman medium with exponent κ≪12.

On the Potential of 3D Transdimensional Surface Wave Tomography for Geothermal Prospecting of the Reykjanes Peninsula

Seismic travel time tomography using surface waves is an effective tool for three-dimensional crustal imaging. Historically, these surface waves are the result of active seismic sources or earthquakes. More recently, however, surface waves retrieved through the application of seismic interferometry have also been exploited. Conventionally, two-step inversion algorithms are employed to solve the tomographic inverse problem. That is, a first inversion results in frequency-dependent, two-dimensional maps of phase velocity, which then serve as input for a series of independent, one-dimensional frequency-to-depth inversions. As such, a set of localized depth-dependent velocity profiles are obtained at the surface points. Stitching these separate profiles together subsequently yields a three-dimensional velocity model. Relatively recently, a one-step three-dimensional non-linear tomographic algorithm has been proposed. The algorithm is rooted in a Bayesian framework using Markov chains with reversible jumps, and is referred to as transdimensional tomography. Specifically, the three-dimensional velocity field is parameterized by means of a polyhedral Voronoi tessellation. In this study, we investigate the potential of this algorithm for the purpose of recovering the three-dimensional surface-wave-velocity structure from ambient noise recorded on and around the Reykjanes Peninsula, southwest Iceland. To that end, we design a number of synthetic tests that take into account the station configuration of the Reykjanes seismic network. We find that the algorithm is able to recover the 3D velocity structure at various scales in areas where station density is high. In addition, we find that the standard deviation of the recovered velocities is low in those regions. At the same time, the velocity structure is less well recovered in parts of the peninsula sampled by fewer stations. This implies that the algorithm successfully adapts model resolution to the density of rays. It also adapts model resolution to the amount of noise in the travel times. Because the algorithm is computationally demanding, we modify the algorithm such that computational costs are reduced while sufficiently preserving non-linearity. We conclude that the algorithm can now be applied adequately to travel times extracted from station–station cross correlations by the Reykjanes seismic network.