HR Diagrams of Galaxies: Ages and Stages of Evolution
Baade (1944) based his concept of stellar populations in galaxies on the HR diagrams that he inferred from the magnitude at which their brightest stars could be resolved. His type I population had bright blue supergiants like those in the disk of the Milky Way, while the brightest stars in type II were the red giants found in globular clusters. He postulated that the Hubble sequence of galaxy types from irregulars to ellipticals contained increasing proportions of Population II relative to Population I, and that similar differences characterized nuclear bulges of spirals relative to their disks. A very important revision of this picture came with the discovery by Morgan and Mayall (1957; Morgan, 1956, 1959) that the integrated blue light of the nuclear bulges of M31 and the Galaxy is dominated by strong-lined CN giants, not by the weak-lined type found in globular clusters. On the basis of integrated spectra of galaxies, Morgan developed a revised population scheme, in which the extreme types are a young-star rich population, like Baade's extreme Population I, and a young-star deficient population, analogous to Population II but generally metal-rich. Different proportions of these two types are still thought to represent the main differences among stellar populations in different regions of galaxies.