Ladies of Bygone Times
Chapter III examines the treatises on marriage and women’s duties that pose as the work of Pythagoras’ direct disciples, but which were composed between the 1st centuries BCE and CE. The treatises appear to formulate a rather conservative program in dialogue, not only with Plato but also with the Stoics Antipater, Musonius Rufus, and Hierocles. Close readings of three treatises attributed to male Pythagoreans (Ocellus, Callicratidas, and Bryson) and two attributed to female Pythagoreans (Perictione and Phintys) reveal a striking consistency of expectations: the spouses must live in harmony, but the husband must always be in charge, and the wife must gladly embrace her inferior position and in fact welcome abuse (Bryson and Perictione). Nonetheless, the Pythagorean author-figure’s capacity for philosophical inquiry is demonstrated in these treatises on women virtues. The position of the female intellectual capable to comment on a variety of topics is further affirmed in treatises on knowledge (Perictione), music (Ptolemais), and human nature (Aesara). The figures of Pythagorean women are thus used both to assert the need for women to accept their traditional subordinate role—in contrast to some Stoic writings—and to acknowledge their intellectual potential.