scholarly journals The charges on positive and negative ions in gases

In a paper on the Diffusion of Ions in Gases, I described a method of comparing the charges on the ions generated in gases with the charge on an ion in a liquid electrolyte. If N be the number of molecules in a cubic centimetre of a gas at standard pressure and temperature, and e the charge on an ion, then N . e = 3∙10 8 . U / K, where U is the velocity of an ion in a field of unit electric force and K the coefficient of diffusion. Thus from separate determinations of the quantities U and K, the product N . e can be obtained. If E is the charge on a monovalent ion in a liquid electrolyte, N . E = 1∙23 x 10 10 , so that a comparison of the various charges may be made, and the calculations have shown that the charge on a positive or negative ion in a gas is nearly equal to the charge E. There were, however, considerable discrepancies, particularly with positive ions, which gave values of N . e as great as 1∙66 x 10 10 in some cases.

1. In a paper published in the ‘Proceedings of the Royal Society,’ vol. 80, p. 207, January, 1908, a method was given for comparing the charges on ions in liquids and gases. The first set of experiments gave results in accordance with the theory, and it was found that the charge on a positive ion in a gas was double that of a negative ion, the latter being equal to the charge on a monovalent ion in a liquid electrolyte. The ratio of the charges obtained was 2.4 / 1.23. The ions were produced by secondary Röntgen rays emitted by a brass surface, and further experiments have shown that positive ions with double or single atomic charges may be produced, the number of either kind depending on the nature of the secondary rays, which is determined by the state of the metallic surface from which they originate.


In a paper on “The Charges on Positive and Negative Ions in Gases,” Prof. Townsend has described a method for the direct determination of the quantity N e , where N is the number of molecules in a cubic centimetre of a gas at standard pressure and temperature and e the charge on an ion. His experiments were carried out on ions produced by the action of secondary Rontgen rays, and he showed that for negative ions the method led with great accuracy to the value 1.23 x 10 10 for N e , the same as that for NE, where E is the charge on a monovalent ion in a liquid electrolyte. For positive ions the value obtained in the first set of experiments was 2.4 x 10 10 , but subsequently with less penetrating secondary rays it was found to be as low as 1.26 x 10 10 . It would therefore appear that the positive ions have in some cases a single and in others a double atomic charge, whereas the charge on the negative ions is always the same. With a view of testing the theory for ions produced by radium, experiments have been made with an apparatus precisely similar to that used by Prof. Townsend, and the results obtained confirm the reliability of the method. After making due allowance for experimental and other known sources of error the positive ion appears to behave at all pressures and under all forces in accordance with the theory, but in the case of the negative ion some considerable deviations were observed, if the gas is very dry, but these disappear as soon as some water vapour is added.


1. In two previous papers published in the ‘Proceedings of the Royal Society,' a method was described of finding directly the charges on positive and negative ions produced by secondary Röntgen rays in gases, in terms of the charge on a monovalent ion in a liquid electrolyte; and the results of some experiments made with air were given. A number of investigations have since been made with oxygen, hydrogen, and carbonic acid, which have taken a considerable time to complete, for although a determination of the charge can be made very accurately from a few simple observations, it requires a long time to investigate the effect produced by complete drying on the motion of the negative ions. This effect can be observed by means of the same kind of experiments as are necessary for determining the charges on the ions, and it is of considerable interest to find at what forces and pressures the negative ions in dry gases assume the corpuscular state and move under an electric force according to laws that are quite different from those which govern the motions of the positive ions.


1936 ◽  
Vol 32 (3) ◽  
pp. 482-485 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. A. Smith

When an electron makes a transition from a continuous state to a bound state, for example in the case of neutralization of a positive ion or formation of a negative ion, its excess energy must be disposed of in some way. It is usually given off as radiation. In the case of neutralization of positive ions the radiation forms the well-known continuous spectrum. No such spectrum due to the direct formation of negative ions has, however, been observed. This process has been fully discussed in a recent paper by Massey and Smith. It is shown that in this case the spectrum would be difficult to observe.


2020 ◽  
Vol 86 (6) ◽  
Author(s):  
Samiran Ghosh ◽  
Biplab Maity ◽  
Swarup Poria

The dynamical behaviour of weakly nonlinear, low-frequency sound waves are investigated in a plasma composed of only positive and negative ions incorporating the effects of a weak external uniform magnetic field. In the plasma model the mass (temperature) of the positive ions is smaller (larger) than that of the negative ions. The dynamics of the nonlinear wave is shown to be governed by a novel nonlinear equation. The stationary plane wave (analytical and numerical) nonlinear analysis on the basis of experimental parameters reveals that the nonlinear wave does have quasi-periodic and chaotic solutions. The Poincarè return map analysis confirms these observed complex structures.


2000 ◽  
Vol 64 (2) ◽  
pp. 131-153 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. N. FRANKLIN ◽  
J. SNELL

This paper reports the results of computations to obtain the spatial distributions of the charged particles in a bounded active plasma dominated by negative ions. Using the fluid model with a constant collision frequency for electrons, positive ions and negative ions the cases of both detachment-dominated gases (such as oxygen) and recombination-dominated gases (such as chlorine) are examined. It is concluded that it is valid to use a Boltzmann relation ne = ne0exp(eV/kT) for the electrons of density ne, where the temperature T is approximately the electron temperature Te, and that the density nn of the negative ions at low pressures obeys nn = nn0exp(eV/kTn), where Tn is the negative-ion temperature. However, at high pressure in detachment-dominated gases where the ratio of negative-ion density to electron density is constant and greater than unity, and when the attachment rate is larger than the ionization rate, the negative ions are distributed with the same effective temperature as the electrons. In all other cases there is no simple relationship. Thus to put nn/ne = const, nn = ne0exp(eV/kTe) and nn = nn0exp(eV/kTn) simultaneously is mathematically inconsistent and physically unsound. Accordingly, expressions deduced for ambipolar diffusion coefficients based on these assumptions have no validity. The correct expressions for the situation where nn/ne = const are obtained without invoking a Boltzmann relation for the negative ions.


The ionized regions of the upper atmosphere include, not only neutral atoms and molecules, electrons and positive ions, but also negative ions. Of these, electrons are alone effective in producing reflexion of wireless waves; so that an electron attached to a neutral molecule to form a negative ion is as effectively removed from active participation in these phenomena as one recombined with a positive ion to form a neutral molecule. The decay of electron density at night has been attributed by some authors to recombination with positive.ions and by others to attachment by neutral molecules. The first process is in agreement with the observed law of decay and has the additional advantage of making it easily possible to understand the formation of layers of concentrated ionization; on the other hand, the chance of attachment to a molecule per impact would have to be extremely small for the attachment rate to be negligible, since the number of collisions per second with neutral atoms is very much greater than with positive ions.


The three previous papers of this series (Arnot and Milligan 1936 b ; Arnot 1937 a, b ) contain an account of experimental work which led the senior author to propose a new process of negative-ion formation. This process is the formation of negative ions at metal surfaces by bombardment of the surface with positive ions, the negative ion being formed by the positive ion capturing two electron from the surface. Further work carried out during the past year, which is described in this paper, has revealed a new variation of the above process. In this latter process the impinging positive ion causes an adsorbed atom on the surface to come off as a negative ion. It is believed that this newer process is essentially similar to the process previously reported, the difference being due merely to the transference of excitation energy from the incident positive ion, after its capture of an electron, to the atom adsorbed on the surface. The discovery of this second effect was made independently by Sloane and Press (1938), although they attribute it to a different process.


2013 ◽  
Vol 79 (6) ◽  
pp. 1113-1116 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. ROSENBERG

AbstractThe excitation of drift waves by an electron current parallel to the magnetic field is investigated in a nonuniform plasma composed of electrons, positive ions, negative ions, and massive, negatively charged dust. Electrostatic drift waves with frequencies smaller than the ion gyrofrequencies and wavelengths larger than the ion gyroradii are considered. Linear kinetic theory is used, and collisions of charged particles with neutrals are taken into account. The present results may be relevant to laboratory collisional magnetoplasmas containing negative ions and dust.


The quantal theory of negative ions has now been developed considerably (Massey and Smith 1936; Massey 1938), but on account of difficulties of computing it is usually necessary to assume rather than to prove that a given ion exists, and then to discuss the probability of its formation by different processes. The work described here is a contribution to the experimental side of this subject. It had its origin in a projected attempt to measure the capture cross-section of mercury atoms for electrons, as a verification of Massey and Smith's (1936) then unpublished theory of this process. In considering this it became clear that the experiment would be one of unusual difficulty. Before proceeding with it, therefore, it was decided to verify the existence of Hg - as a stable entity, which is assumed in the quantal theory. this was in doubt since Stille (1933), in some careful experiments, had recently failed to obtain it from the plasma of various forms of discharge through mercury vapour, although it is known that negative ions tend to accumulate in such regions (Emeleus and Sayers 1938). Whilst one of us was repeating his experiments, with modifications which led to essentially the same results and will be describes elsewhere, Arnot and Milligan (1936 b ) reported that they had obtained Hg - by bombardment of metal surfaces with Hg + . A comparison of their work with our own showed only one essential point of difference, namely that the construction of their apparatus did not permit of degassing in situ , a condition satisfied with our tubes. Both for this reason and because of the intrinsic importance of their discovery it was thought desirable to repeat part of their work, with apparatus geometrically similar in electrode construction, but capable of being degassed in a furnace under vacuum. We were again unable to obtain Hg - after the apparatus had been degassed and in operation for a short of that of Hg - was obtained. There were, however, always present several light negative ions, which had the excess energies found by Arnot and Milligan (1936 b ) with Hg - . The conditions under which these were formed led us to suppose that they were produced by bombardment of the metal surfaces by mercury positive ions (Press 1937; Sloane 1937) and not capture of electrons by positive ions of the same species, the process suggested by Arnot and Milligan (1936 b ). The existence of a process of this type, which may be conveniently termed "sputtering" (Sloane and Press 1938), is also implied by some earlier work by J. S. Thompson (1931) which has, so far as we know, never been published in detail. It is, however, impossible to decide definitely ion (e. g. CO - ) when it hits the surface, so long as one is producing the negative ions on a metal surface in a plasma or ionization chamber. One cannot overlook the possibility of the negative ion being formed from its own positive ion, since the latter may be present in the plasma or ionization chamber, and CO + , for example, was in fact shown in our work to be there from the positive-ion mass spectra, although in quantity only a fraction of 1% of Hg + . An unambiguous decision on this point can only be reached by first isolating a particular positive ion by a mass spectrograph, then bombarding a surface by this in a high vacuum , and finally making a mass spectrographic and energy distribution analysis of the resultant negative ions. We have built a double mass spectrograph for this purpose and find that negative ions of one kind possessing energies in excess of that imparted to them by the accelerating fields can be produced by bombardment with positive ions of another kind (Sloane and Press 1938). An account of the experiments with the single mass spectrograph is given in 1. the experiments with the double mass spectrograph are described in 2.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document