Abstract
Study question
What role does the X chromosome play in early embryo metabolism? Does X chromosome copy number contribute to sex differences in early embryonic metabolism?
Summary answer
Chromosome X contains several metabolism-related genes that are expressed prior to X-inactivation, suggesting that their dosage plays a role in sex-biased regulation of embryo metabolism.
What is known already
Published reports indicate that sex differences in preimplantation embryo metabolism exist across mammalian species, including humans. Two observations supporting this are that male embryos reach blastocyst stage earlier than their female counterparts, and that glucose uptake and processing is thought to be higher in female compared to male embryos. It has been hypothesized that these differences reflect the location of the metabolism gene G6PD, the rate limiting enzyme in the Pentose Phosphate Pathway, on Chromosome X.
Study design, size, duration
This study is a reanalysis of publicly available RNA-seq data, including 1176 single cells from 59 blastocysts (24 E5, 18 E6, 17 E7) published in one study (Petropoulos et al 2016).
Participants/materials, setting, methods
Cells were subjected to a digital karyotype inference algorithm and aneuploid samples were removed from the dataset. Sex differential gene expression analyses (DE) were then performed in euploid trophectoderm cells (TE; 233 XY from 16 embryos and 180 XX cells from 12 embryos). Cell numbers from ICM were too sparse to compare.
Main results and the role of chance
Analysis of XX and XY TE revealed 618 significantly differentially expressed genes (DEGs; 507 upregulated in XX cells, and 111 upregulated in XY cells). These genes are spread across autosomes and sex chromosomes. Interestingly, G6PD is not significantly more highly expressed in XX cells.
Gene Ontology (GO) analysis of the XX-biased DEGs revealed a transcriptional sex bias in metabolism-related GO categories, including “mitochondrial ATP synthesis coupled electron transport”, and “respiratory chain complex I”.
Gene-level assessment revealed that the drivers of these enrichments are spread across the genome, but 28/64 reside on Chromosome X (hypergeometric p-value = 5.984473e–27), including NDUFA1, NDUFB11, and COX7B (components of the electron transport chain), and SLC25A5 (an ATP/ADP transporter involved in maintaining mitochondrial membrane potential). This indicates a direct role for multiple X-linked genes in sex-biased regulation of embryo metabolism.
Metabolic genes that are not sex-biased are distributed across the genome, with no significant enrichment on Chromosome X (76/266, hypergeometric p-value=0.607). Together, these data indicate that GO metabolic term X enrichment is a feature of sex-biased expression and not due to an accumulation of metabolism-related genes on the X.
Limitations, reasons for caution
This analysis draws on publicly available data, and thus we are unable to perform orthogonal validation of karyotype calls. Additionally, while the initial dataset is large, the quality-filtered dataset (euploid XX and XY TE) is small, and single cell data is infamously variable. Further data collection is required.
Wider implications of the findings: Our analysis of sex-biased gene expression in early human embryos suggests a more important role for the X chromosome in modulating sex biases in early embryo metabolism than previously recognized. This study provides insight into the mechanisms underlying the development of metabolic sex differences throughout the lifespan.
Trial registration number
NA
The importance of having two X chromosomes