Experimental Investigation Into Thermal Behavior of Steam Turbine Components—Temperature Measurements With Optical Probes and Natural Cooling Analysis

Author(s):  
Gabriel Marinescu ◽  
Wolfgang F. Mohr ◽  
Andreas Ehrsam ◽  
Paolo Ruffino ◽  
Michael Sell

The steam turbine cooldown has a significant impact on the cyclic fatigue life. A lower initial metal temperature after standstill results in a higher temperature difference to be overcome during the next start-up. Generally, lower initial metal temperatures result in higher start-up stress. In order to optimize steam turbines for cyclic operation, it is essential to fully understand natural cooling, which is especially challenging for rotors. This paper presents a first-in-time application of a 2D numerical procedure for the assessment of the thermal regime during natural cooling, including the rotors, casings, valves, and main pipes. The concept of the cooling calculation is to replace the fluid gross buoyancy during natural cooling by an equivalent fluid conductivity that gives the same thermal effect on the metal parts. The fluid equivalent conductivity is calculated based on experimental data. The turbine temperature was measured with pyrometric probes on the rotor and with standard thermocouples on inner and outer casings. The pyrometric probes were calibrated with standard temperature measurements on a thermo well, where the steam transmittance and the rotor metal transmissivity were measured.

Author(s):  
Gabriel Marinescu ◽  
Andreas Ehrsam

Steam turbine cool-down has a significant impact on the cyclic fatigue life. A lower initial metal temperature after standstill results in a higher temperature difference to be overcome during the next start-up. Generally, lower initial metal temperatures result in higher start-up stress. In order to optimize steam turbines for cyclic operation, it is essential to fully understand natural cooling, which is especially challenging for rotors. A two-dimensional numerical procedure is described for the assessment of the thermal regime during natural cooling including the rotors, casings, valves and main pipes. The concept of the cooling calculation is to replace the steam gross buoyancy during the gland steam ingestion phase by an equivalent fluid conductivity, that gives the same thermal effect on the metal parts. The fluid equivalent conductivity is calculated based on measurements. The approach is calibrated with experimental data. Finally, the highly sensitive nature of the cyclic lifetime to the predicted cooling evolution is demonstrated. This paper is complementary with the paper [1].


Author(s):  
Gabriel Marinescu ◽  
Michael Sell ◽  
Andreas Ehrsam ◽  
Philipp B. Brunner

Steam turbine start-up has a significant impact on the cyclic fatigue life. Modern steam turbines are operated at high temperatures for optimal efficiency, which results in high temperature differences relative to the condition before start-up. To achieve the fastest possible start-up time without reducing the lifetime of the turbine components due to excessive thermal stress, the start-up procedure of cyclic turbines is optimized to follow the specific material low cycle fatigue limit. For such optimization and to ensure reliable operation, it is essential to fully understand the thermal behavior of the components during start-up. This is especially challenging in low flow conditions, i.e. during pre-warming and early loading phase. A two-dimensional numerical procedure is described for the assessment of the thermal regime during start-up. The calculation procedure includes the rotor, casings, valves and main pipes. The concept of the start-up calculation is to replace the convective effect of the steam in the turbine cavity by an equivalent fluid over-conductivity that gives the same thermal effect on metallic parts. This approach allows simulating accurately the effect of steam ingestion during pre-warming phase. The fluid equivalent over-conductivity is calibrated with experimental data. At the end of the paper the impact of ingested steam temperature and mass-flow on the rotor cyclic lifetime is demonstrated. This paper is a continuation of papers [1] and [2].


Author(s):  
Gabriel Marinescu ◽  
Peter Stein ◽  
Michael Sell

Steam turbine transient maneuvers have a significant impact on the cyclic fatigue life. Modern steam turbines are operated at high temperatures for optimal efficiency, which results in high time and space temperature gradients. A low initial metal temperature after standstill results in a high temperature difference to be overcome during the next startup and consequently a low lifetime at critical locations. To achieve the fastest possible start-up time without reducing the lifetime of the turbine components, the natural cooling must be captured accurately in calculation and the start-up procedure optimized. At the past two ASME conferences we presented three papers [1], [2], [3], about a 2D numerical procedure for the thermal regime calculation during natural cooling and startup. The analysis included the rotor, casings, valves and pipes. The main concept was to replace the thermal effect of the fluid convectivity by a fluid function K(T) called “over-conductivity”, which is calibrated vs. experimental data. The paper below shows: (a) the theoretical background of the over-conductivity function K(T) and (b) the equation of the correlation function f(T,p) between the fluid velocity and fluid temperature gradient. Both K(T) and f(T,p) are applicable for the flow within the large turbine cavities with negligible pressure gradient. The robustness of the K(T) function is verified on three different turbine configurations. For each machine a separate transient thermal model was built and the calculated temperatures were compared with the corresponding measured temperatures. At the end of the paper conclusions about the natural cooling features are presented.


Author(s):  
Peng Wang ◽  
Gang Chen ◽  
WenFu Li

In the latest several years, concentrated solar plants (CSP) have been rapidly developed. Steam turbines employed in these plants are subjected to daily start up and continuous load variations. There is a general increase in demand for operation flexibility and rapid start up capability for solar steam turbines. Accordingly, how to decrease the low cyclic fatigue life consumption during the daily start up process is a hot researched topic at present, and this greatly depends on the transient thermal stress. A number of studies show that the startup schemes and the unit’s structural form decide the LCF life consumption directly. In this paper, a 50MW double cylinder (HP and ILP Section) reheat solar steam turbine is studied, and it is operated continuously with inlet steam conditions of 540[°C], 140[bar], reheat steam conditions of 540[°C], 24[bar] and exhaust conditions of 41.5[°C], 0.08[bar]. A number of comparisons are made with the FEM numerical simulation, and some optimal designs which are applied to improve the rapid start up performance and decrease the LCF life consumption during the startup are presented.


Author(s):  
Yasuhiro Yoshida ◽  
Kazunori Yamanaka ◽  
Atsushi Yamashita ◽  
Norihiro Iyanaga ◽  
Takuya Yoshida

In the fast start-up for combined cycle power plants (CCPP), the thermal stresses of the steam turbine rotor are generally controlled by the steam temperatures or flow rates by using gas turbines (GTs), steam turbines, and desuperheaters to avoid exceeding the thermal stress limits. However, this thermal stress sensitivity to steam temperatures and flow rates depends on the start-up sequence due to the relatively large time constants of the heat transfer response in the plant components. In this paper, a coordinated control method of gas turbines and steam turbine is proposed for thermal stress control, which takes into account the large time constants of the heat transfer response. The start-up processes are simulated in order to assess the effect of the coordinated control method. The simulation results of the plant start-ups after several different cool-down times show that the thermal stresses are stably controlled without exceeding the limits. In addition, the steam turbine start-up times are reduced by 22–28% compared with those of the cases where only steam turbine control is applied.


Author(s):  
Wolfgang Beer ◽  
Lukas Propp ◽  
Lutz Voelker

New flexible operational regimes with fast start-ups and fast-changing load cycles for steam turbines require calculation procedures for determining optimal start-up times in order not to exceed the limits of thermal stress for the steam turbine parts. This work presents a start-up time calculation for various kinds of industrial steam turbines. An analytical approach for estimating the optimal thermal load of a turbine from quasi-steady or steady condition is developed. The geometry of the respective turbine components, the changing of the steam parameters and heat transfer effects during the start-up procedure are taken into account while observing the respective material properties and stress limits. The temperature distributions of the respective turbine parts are calculated with a one-dimensional numerical algorithm of Fourier’s heat conduction equation. Three-dimensional influences of the geometry and of the the heat flux are considered analytically by adjusting the numerical solutions of elementary bodies (e.g. one-dimensional plate). The start-up time calculation is performed in small time steps to guarantee the stability of the numerical solution. The unsteady stress analysis for the start-up procedure does not uniquely identify one critical component. The calculation must be repeated for each time step to identify the component which limits the start-up gradient. Other boundary conditions, such as restricted speed ranges of the rotor with minimum transients and time for synchronization with the electrical grid, are considered by the model too and can further limit the start-up gradient and lead to slower start-up procedures. The one-dimensional calculation models were verified with a three-dimensional FEA of the casing and a two axis symmetrical FEA of the rotor. The results for the temperature distribution are presented and compared to the one-dimensional results. The final result of the analytical approach for an optimized start-up time calculation is verified with two typical start-up calculations, one for a generator drive steam turbine and one for a mechanical-drive steam turbine.


Author(s):  
Y. Kostenko ◽  
D. Veltmann ◽  
S. Hecker

Abstract Growing renewable energy generation share causes more irregular and more flexible operational regimes of conventional power plants than in the past. It leads to long periods without dispatch for several days or even weeks. As a consequence, the required pre-heating of the steam turbine leads to an extended power plant start-up time [1]. The current steam turbine Hot Standby Mode (HSM) contributes to a more flexible steam turbine operation and is a part of the Flex-Power Services™ portfolio [2]. HSM prevents the turbine components from cooling via heat supply using an electrical Trace Heating System (THS) after shutdowns [3]. The aim of the HSM is to enable faster start-up time after moderate standstills. HSM functionality can be extended to include the pre-heating option after longer standstills. This paper investigates pre-heating of the steam turbine with an electrical THS. At the beginning, it covers general aspects of flexible fossil power plant operation and point out the advantages of HSM. Afterwards the technology of the trace heating system and its application on steam turbines will be explained. In the next step the transient pre-heating process is analyzed and optimized using FEA, CFD and analytic calculations including validation considerations. Therefor a heat transfer correlation for flexible transient operation of the HSM was developed. A typical large steam turbine with an output of up to 300MW was investigated. Finally the results are summarized and an outlook is given. The results of heat transfer and conduction between and within turbine components are used to enable fast start-ups after long standstills or even outages with the benefit of minimal energy consumption. The solution is available for new apparatus as well as for the modernization of existing installations.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Roland Grein ◽  
Ulrich Ehehalt ◽  
Christian Siewert ◽  
Norbert Kill

Abstract In the future energy landscape, combined cycle power plants will increasingly take the role of providing balancing power for fluctuating renewable energy sources due to their high availability and fast start-up times. This implies more frequent cycling, a larger number of speed cycles and thus new challenges for plant design and operation. One of these challenges is a potential increase of cyclic fatigue incurred by last-stage blades during start-up and coast-down. Blade vibrations might be induced by synchronous shaft vibrations when the blade resonance is excited by lateral shaft vibrations. In this paper, we report measurement results of shaft and blade vibrations observed at some Siemens Energy steam turbines. Apart from the expected increase of blade vibrations when the double rotating speed crosses the blade resonance, a distinctive dip of shaft vibrations at the low-pressure turbine bearings is observed. We argue that this phenomenon is likely related to the aforementioned interaction between blade and shaft vibrations and present a theoretical framework to describe this interaction and the observed effect.


Author(s):  
James Spelling ◽  
Markus Jo¨cker ◽  
Andrew Martin

Steam turbines in solar thermal power plants experience a much greater number of starts than those operating in base-load plants. In order to preserve the lifetime of the turbine whilst still allowing fast starts, it is of great interest to find ways to maintain the turbine temperature during idle periods. A dynamic model of a solar steam turbine has been elaborated, simulating both the heat conduction within the body and the heat exchange with the gland steam, main steam and the environment, allowing prediction of the temperatures within the turbine during off-design operation and standby. The model has been validated against 96h of measured data from the Andasol 1 power plant, giving an average error of 1.2% for key temperature measurements. The validated model was then used to evaluate a number of modifications that can be made to maintain the turbine temperature during idle periods. Heat blankets were shown to be the most effective measure for keeping the turbine casing warm, whereas increasing the gland steam temperature was most effective in maintaining the temperature of the rotor. By applying a combination of these measures the dispatchability of the turbine can be improved significantly: electrical output can be increased by up to 9.5% after a long cool-down and up to 9.8% after a short cool-down.


Author(s):  
W. F. Mohr ◽  
P. Ruffino

The first-in-time application of intensity pyrometry to measure in-situ the hot rotor surface temperature of a standard, combined cycle, intermediate pressure steam turbine is presented. The data cover a cold-start and cooling from base load. The pyrometric temperatures are compared to standard temperature measurements on static turbine parts and an upstream steam temperature measured on a thermo well. It is reported, how the applicability of pyrometry in steam turbines was assessed. Details are given about a newly developed USC autoclave, which was used to measure steam transmittance, and about the measurement of the emissivity of the rotor metal. Further the steps taken towards a steam-pyrometer are shown; how it was developed, validated in terms of its precision and lifetime in hot steam environment, and how its integration to a standard turbine was prepared.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document