香港、长沙中学生偶像与榜样选择比较分析 SELECTION OF FAVORITE IDOLS AND MODELS AMONG CHINESE HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS: A COMPARATIVE STUDY IN HONG KONG AND CHANGSHA
本研究结果表明,香港与长沙的青少年在对钦佩人物的选择上存在着明显的差异。概括起来,香港的青少年更喜欢理想-浪漫-绝对型名人,这些人突出表现为歌星、影星和体育明星;而长沙的青少年更喜欢现实-理性-相对型名人,这些人突出表现为著名政治家和文学家。在怎样看待所提名钦佩人物时,两地的青少年多将演艺界、体育界和政治界的名人当偶像看,而将自己的家人和朋友师长当榜样看。此外,港的青少年选择亲朋好友作为自己最钦佩人物的倾向要高於长沙的青少年,长沙的青少年则选择政治名人作为自己最钦佩人物。此次研究再次证明,偶像和榜样是两个不同的概念。根据上述结果,本文提出,当今青少年崇拜的主流是对歌星、影星和体育明星的“三星崇拜”,这与当今社会的商业化炒作有密切关系。本文还提出,在看待青少年偶像崇拜行为时,应区分遥亲感和即亲感两个概念。其中对遥亲感的满足可谓青少年偶像崇拜的主要目标和精神需求之所在。 The present study asked 258 high school students in Hong Kong and Changsha to nominate three most admired people in their lives and rate them on degrees to which they could become their idols and models. Hong Kong students mostly nominated celebrities in entertainment and sports industries while Changsha students mostly nominated celebrities in politics. Hong Kong students were more inclined than Changsha students to nominate family members, friends and teachers to be their most admired people. A clear distinction was also noted between idols and models. Based on the above results, the authors argued that "tri-star idol worship" constituted the mainstream of idol worship for young people nowadays and that a distinction could be made between remote intimacy and immediate intimacy in understanding adolescent idol worship.