Investor sentiment and the risk-return tradeoff

2020 ◽  
Vol 07 (04) ◽  
pp. 2050043
Author(s):  
Mohamed Marouen Amiri ◽  
Kamel Naoui ◽  
Abdelkader Derbali ◽  
Mounir Ben Sassi

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the risk-return tradeoff allowing for the presence of noise traders, i.e., a subset of investors who either base their trading strategies on sentiment or hold unjustified optimistic/pessimistic views regarding market prospects. We measure noise traders’ sentiment relying on two sets of indices, namely the Baker and Wurgler sentiment index and the Michigan Consumer Confidence Index, in the US stock market. Under the assumption of the presence of noise traders’ sentiment, the risk-return tradeoff is tested through two sets of models: Merton’s Intertemporal CAPM and the GARCH-in-mean model. First, we find that the relationship between risk and return allowing for the presence of noise trader risk as measured by the Baker and Wurgler sentiment index is positive and statistically significant when tested through Merton’s Intertemporal CAPM. Second, the risk-return tradeoff tested through GARCH-in-mean models augmented by noise traders’ risk as measured through survey-based measures of sentiment establishes no clear evidence for a significant mean–variance relationship. Overall, we confirm Merton’s (1973) hypothesis that the more risk an investor bears, the greater his expected returns. This paper contributes to the asset pricing literature by trying to shed some light on the risk-return tradeoff from the standpoint of behavioral finance.

2012 ◽  
Vol 29 (1) ◽  
pp. 51 ◽  
Author(s):  
Francisca Beer ◽  
Mohamed Zouaoui

Recently, investor sentiment measures have become one of the more widely examined areas in behavioral finance. A number of measures have been developed in the literature without having been fully validated, and therefore leaving in question which measure should be used for empirical exploration. The purpose of this study is to examine the relative performance of a number of popular measures in predicting stock returns and to test the relative efficacy of a hybrid approach. Using a panel of investor sentiment measures, we develop a new measure of sentiment which combines direct and indirect sentiment measures. Our results show that our composite sentiment index affects the returns of stocks hard to value and difficult to arbitrage consistent with the predictions of noise traders models. Finally, we find that our composite index has a better predictive ability than the alternative sentiment measures largely used in the literature.


2021 ◽  
Vol 2021 ◽  
pp. 1-14
Author(s):  
Xiaohong Shen ◽  
Gaoshan Wang ◽  
Yue Wang

This paper investigates whether and how the research reports issued by securities companies affect stock returns from the perspective of investor sentiment in China. By collecting research reports and investor comments from a popular Chinese investor community, i.e., East Money, we derive two indices that represent the information contained in research reports: one is the attention of research reports and the other is the average stock rating given by research reports; then we develop an investor sentiment indicator using the machine learning method. Based on behavioral finance theory, we hypothesize that research reports have a significant effect on stock returns and investor sentiment plays a mediating role in it. The empirical analysis results confirm the above hypotheses. Specifically, the average stock rating given by research reports can better predict future stock returns, and investor sentiment plays a partial mediating role in the relationship between stock rating and stock returns.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
YI-MING DU ◽  
RUI DING ◽  
YI-LIN ZHANG ◽  
TING ZHANG ◽  
TAO ZHOU

As one of the main contents of behavioral finance, investor sentiment has become a research hotspot in recent years. This paper takes the CSI300 index of China as the observation object, selects five emotional monthly time series data including lag one period from 2016 to 2020. The method of principal component analysis will be used to reduce the dimension of 10 groups of data. After eliminating the macroeconomic factors, the dimension reduction results are analyzed by the second principal component analysis to obtain the comprehensive index of emotion. Furthermore, a Vector Auto Regressive model (VAR) is established to investigate the relationship between ISIO and CSI300 of the stock market. The results show that investor sentiment and stock price interact with each other, but only in the short term. With more and more sufficient market information known, the effect is becoming insignificant.


2009 ◽  
Author(s):  
Παναγιώτης Σχίζας

My doctoral thesis provides evidence of two different types of trading strategies. The first type is based οη market neutral trading strategies under the methodology of pair trading strategies. The second part is on rotation strategies according to sign forecasting specifications and explores the probability of profitable market and volatility timing. The thesis is comprised by three chapters. The first chapter is dedicated to Exchange Traded Funds, ETFs. Ι am presenting an extended literature review on the topic. The review tries to capture every aspect of ETFs that is of concern for the academic community. Moreover, Ι am presenting the mechanism of ETFs and the pros and cons that are inherent in an ETF structure. Ιη addition, Ι am discussing active ETFs. Οη the 4th of March 2008, the Securities and Exchange Commission approved the listing and trading of Active Exchange Traded Funds in the US market. This decision opens up a new era on asset management. Ι am trying to identify the most appealing issues from this new decision. Ι am analysing the similarities and the differences with passive ETFs and conventional mutual funds and the obstacles that arise from the inception of active ETFs. The second chapter is dedicated to pair trading strategies. Gatev, Goetzmann and Rouwenhourt (2006) applied a trading algorithm based οη the concept of mean reverting returns. Prices of two assets that move together in the long run and diverge in the short term will revert to their equilibrium. An alternative definition for the pair trading strategies is that of a relative value statistical arbitrage methodology. Engleberg, Gao and Jagannathan (2009) examined pair trading methodology and tried to explain the factors behind the profitability. The contribution of my work is the implementation of a modification of pair trading investment strategy and the examination of the profitability and the motives that create the profitability in the contest of ETFs. Ι implement different estimations for each separate step of the formulation of the strategies in order to examine and find an “optimal” algorithm. Ι then conduct different tests to check the robustness of my methodology. Ιη the next step, Ι check the pattern of profitability based on several tests based on the segmentations according to market capitalization, emerging and developed markets. The second part involves the empirical evidence of pair trading portfolios according to risk profile. Ι incorporated Fama and French risk factors to explain for potential patterns behind the profits. The estimations included national and international risk factors on profitability. The most important part is the decomposition of the traded pairs and the examination one by one according to its own risk characteristics. My dataset is constructed by international ETFs which is the tradable version of country indices. In that concept, Ι research in each separate pair its own variables and Ι test the factors that affect profitability. Among the extended research all over pair trading strategies, this research provides the following contributions. 1. It is the first time that ETFs are used in pairs trading. 2. International evidence on pair trading with easily accessible instruments. 3. Pair trading profitability outperforms S&P500. 4. The US and international Fama and French risk factors are insufficient to explain pair trading international profitability. The third chapter is dedicated to volatility and market timing strategies. Ι examined a new methodology that assesses the economic and statistical significance of market and volatility timing according to a novel forecasting specification. My methodology combines the dynamics of time-varying expected returns and volatility timing and several thresholds derived by expected returns and variability. The specification is incorporating forecasting sign ability. The forecast estimations are incorporated to create trading rules and the formation of portfolios. The trading rules, then, are incorporated to the allocation decision. In every decision, we allocate the total wealth to one asset. In every transaction, we rotate between the two assets. The methodology is based on a pairwise asset evaluation. I test for the patterns behind volatility timing, and for the day of the week effect. The results indicate that under specific assumptions market and volatility timing can lead to profitable trading strategies. The selection of the specification appear to be sensitive between past returns and volatility which confirms the initial conception of the cross interaction between time varying expected returns and variation. Comparing the performance of the rotation portfolios based on forecasts using different model selection criteria, the rotation trading is performing the highest final wealth, when there is not a clear domination between expected return and variation. Applying the methodology under different days of the week, I can differentiate from the literature in means of the performance with rotation trading to exhibits the most statically and economic significant excess returns οη Monday. The next test examines if different levels of volatility generate correct sign predictions. The empirical analysis shows that there is not clear dependence between returns and level of volatility. Empirical evidence appear to be sensitive about the selection of trading specification which confirms the motivation of the research of cross interactions between time varying expected returns and variation. Rotation trading outperformed the market in means of final performance and risk levels as represented by the maximum drawdown indicator. My thesis makes a distinct contribution in the area of active asset management and asset allocation methods. It explores in depth two different trading strategies in the context of a relatively new financial tool, the Exchange Traded Fund (ETF), and is to the best of my knowledge one of the few existing works that address the issue of ETF profitability in a relatively thorough manner, always in the context of active trading.


2015 ◽  
Vol 5 (4) ◽  
pp. 114-122
Author(s):  
Simon Man Shing So ◽  
Violet U. T. Lei

As noise traders affect stock market by trading, sentiment, as a signal of noise, may have relationships with trading volume. This paper explores the effect of sentiment on the stock market’s trading volume. Increase in Volatility Index (VIX) can explain the percentage increase in trading volume, but only in high VIX period. Besides, higher level of VIX is likely to be associated with greater variability of trading volume. The noise traders add liquidity to the market and provide more chances for investors to time their trade as the volatility of liquidity increases. These two kinds of impact lower rational investors’ required return. The noise traders not only drive the price deviating from fundamental value, but also influence the liquidity dimensions


Entropy ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 20 (9) ◽  
pp. 677 ◽  
Author(s):  
Salim Lahmiri ◽  
Stelios Bekiros

The risk‒return trade-off is a fundamental relationship that has received a large amount of attention in financial and economic analysis. Indeed, it has important implications for understanding linear dynamics in price returns and active quantitative portfolio optimization. The main contributions of this work include, firstly, examining such a relationship in five major fertilizer markets through different time periods: a period of low variability in returns and a period of high variability such as that during which the recent global financial crisis occurred. Secondly, we explore how entropy in those markets varies during the investigated time periods. This requires us to assess their inherent informational dynamics. The empirical results show that higher volatility is associated with a larger return in diammonium phosphate, potassium chloride, triple super phosphate, and urea market, but not rock phosphate. In addition, the magnitude of this relationship is low during a period of high variability. It is concluded that key statistical patterns of return and the relationship between return and volatility are affected during high variability periods. Our findings indicate that entropy in return and volatility series of each fertilizer market increase significantly during time periods of high variability.


Author(s):  
Steven Hurst

The United States, Iran and the Bomb provides the first comprehensive analysis of the US-Iranian nuclear relationship from its origins through to the signing of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) in 2015. Starting with the Nixon administration in the 1970s, it analyses the policies of successive US administrations toward the Iranian nuclear programme. Emphasizing the centrality of domestic politics to decision-making on both sides, it offers both an explanation of the evolution of the relationship and a critique of successive US administrations' efforts to halt the Iranian nuclear programme, with neither coercive measures nor inducements effectively applied. The book further argues that factional politics inside Iran played a crucial role in Iranian nuclear decision-making and that American policy tended to reinforce the position of Iranian hardliners and undermine that of those who were prepared to compromise on the nuclear issue. In the final chapter it demonstrates how President Obama's alterations to American strategy, accompanied by shifts in Iranian domestic politics, finally brought about the signing of the JCPOA in 2015.


2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
Yohanes Indrayono

<p>This study contributes to the on-going studies on behavioral finance by providing a case study on underreaction and overreaction of firm stocks to firm valuation. We use the Model of Investor Sentiment (Barberis et al., 2005) to evaluate underreaction and overreaction behavior and reflect on specific findings in the Indonesian market. The result of the study is most of the stocks in the Indonesian Stock Exchange are more overreaction to the news of firm financial statements. Firms on the industry with more intangible assets measure more overreaction than firms on industries with more tangible assets. For stocks with overreaction, the stock firm value is positively affected by a change in the total assets and profitability, but not by change of book value. The result concretized no evidence that firm stocks overreacted to the news more than underreacting. In stock industrial sectors, the financial institutions and wholesale industry stocks demonstrated remarkable overreactions. Nonetheless, automotive, building construction, food and beverage as well as cement evidenced more underreaction. For better return in financial markets, investors may buy stocks of the firm on industry with more tangible assets when there is no good news about the increasing firm profitability and sales; nonetheless, they should buy stocks of the firm on industry with more intangible assets when there is no lousy news about the increasing firm profitability and sales. </p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document