scholarly journals Discussion on ‘Borehole temperature log from the Glasgow Geothermal Energy Research Field Site: a record of past changes to ground surface temperature caused by urban development’ : Scottish Journal of Geology, 56, 134-152, https://doi.org/10.1144/sjg2019-033

2020 ◽  
pp. sjg2020-014
Author(s):  
Alison A. Monaghan ◽  
David A.C. Manning ◽  
Zoe K. Shipton

In their analysis of temperature data, Watson and Westaway (2020) make substantial use of initial open information provided by the UK Geoenergy Observatory: Glasgow Geothermal Energy Research Field Site. They also offer criticisms on site location, heat resource size, design and costs, however these criticisms appear to be based on a misunderstanding of the purpose of the Glasgow Observatory. In order to mitigate misapprehensions for future Observatory users, we write in reply. The Glasgow Observatory has been developed as a multidisciplinary research facility; it is not a demonstrator of maximum mine water heat resource, which is by implication what Watson and Westaway (2020) would deem a success.

2021 ◽  
pp. sjg2020-031
Author(s):  
Rob Westaway

Watson and Westaway (2020) (WW) quantified subsurface temperature variations caused by anthropogenic climate change and urban/industrial development in Glasgow, using temperature data from the Glasgow Geothermal Energy Research Field Site (GGERFS) well GGC-01 (at site G-10; Fig. 1), noting implications for the thermal physics of this site. Monaghan, Manning and Shipton (2021) (MMS) have queried points, noted in passing by WW, on other aspects: the GGERFS purpose, location, design, heat resource, and cost.


2020 ◽  
Vol 60 (2) ◽  
pp. 732
Author(s):  
Karsten Michael ◽  
Ludovic Ricard ◽  
Linda Stalker ◽  
Allison Hortle ◽  
Arsham Avijegon

The oil and gas industry in Western Australia will need to address their carbon emissions in response to the state government’s aspiration of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050. The geological storage of carbon dioxide is a proven technology and an option for reducing emissions. Storage operations would need to provide adequate monitoring systems in compliance with yet to be defined regulations and to assure the public that potential leakage could be confidently detected, managed and remediated. The In-Situ Laboratory in the south-west of Western Australia was established as a research field site to support low emissions technology development and provides a unique field site for controlled CO2 release experiments in a fault zone and testing of monitoring technologies between 400 m depth and the ground surface. A first test injection of 38 tonnes of food-grade gaseous CO2 in 2019 demonstrated the ability to detect less than 10 tonnes of CO2 with fibre optic sensing and borehole seismic testing. Results from the previous test and future experiments will help to improve the sensitivity of monitoring technologies and could contribute to defining adequate monitoring requirements for carbon storage regulations.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mike Chandler ◽  
Julian Mecklneburgh ◽  
Ernest Rutter

<p>The UKGEOS Glasgow research field site comprises a network of 12 boreholes into flooded coal mines, and is designed to observe how warm water moves around the abandoned mine workings over time <em>(Monaghan et al., 2018)</em>. Minewater geothermal projects involve the redevelopment of abandoned mining areas into large volume, low temperature resources and use heat pumps to drive heating for homes, industry or agriculture. This technique has proven potential as a renewable, decarbonised heat source providing reliable heating, cooling and heat storage with stable pricing to former mining areas.</p><p>Flow through minewater systems is partitioned between flow through the mine voids, through fractured media, and through porous media. This heterogeneity in flow is crucial to the development of models to predict the efficacy of minewater geothermal systems, as water flowing through the fractured material should absorb more heat than that flowing directly through the mine voids. This heat exchange then goes on to control the rate at which heat can be sustainably extracted from the minewater system.</p><p>The majority of fluid flow has generally been assumed to be through the mine voids. However, the proportion of fluid flow through the porous wallrocks is very sensitive to the fracture populations that they contain, due to the shallow nature of these mine workings leaving them under low stress.  Geothermal tests at the Gaspé mines in Québec demonstrate this clearly, with high wallrock conductivities (10<sup>-6</sup>-10<sup>-4</sup> m.s<sup>-1</sup>) attributed to mine-blasting <em>(Raymond & Therrien, 2008)</em>. Coal mining in the Glasgow area was predominantly carried out using the Pillar & Stoop or Longwall methods, which lead to very different damage states in the wallrocks, and so the effect of these fracture populations is expected to have a large effect on flow partitioning.</p><p>Here, relationships between in-situ stress, fracture population and permeability were determined from well-core samples of the Glasgow Main Coal and underlying mudstone and sandstone strata, in order to characterise how flow may be partitioned within different regions of these mine-workings.</p><p>Stress-dependent permeability and storativity were measured using the osciallting pore-pressure method, and elastic tensors were determined using an array of ultrasonic transducers. Axial fractures were then generated within these samples under low triaxial stress states, and the change in permeability with induced fractures then measured at a single stress state, with the newly developed fracture population characterised through the changes in the elastic tensor.</p><p><em>Monaghan, A. A., Starcher, V., Dochartaigh, B. É. Ó., Shorter, K., & Burkin, J. (2018)</em>. <strong>UK Geoenergy Observatories : Glasgow Geothermal Energy Research Field Site - Science infrastructure.</strong> http://nora.nerc.ac.uk/id/eprint/521444/%0A</p><p><em>Raymond, J., & Therrien, R. (2008)</em>. L<strong>ow-temperature geothermal potential of the flooded Gaspé Mines, Québec, Canada.</strong> Geothermics. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geothermics.2007.10.001</p>


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alison Monaghan ◽  
Vanessa Starcher ◽  
Hugh Barron ◽  
Corinna Abesser ◽  
Brighid O Dochartaigh ◽  
...  

<p>Mine water geothermal heat production and storage can provide a decarbonised source of energy for space heating and cooling, however the large resource potential has yet to be exploited widely. Besides economic, regulatory and licensing barriers, the geoscientific uncertainties remain significant. A lack of detailed understanding of thermal and hydrogeological subsurface conditions and processes, resource sustainability, and the potential impacts on the subsurface-to-surface environmental impacts have so far hampered a more widespread development of this resource.</p><p>The British Geological Survey (BGS) is in the final stages of constructing the Glasgow Geothermal Energy Research Field Site on behalf of the Natural Environment Research Council with UK Government funding. As one of the two new UK Geoenergy Observatories, the Glasgow site will facilitate collaborative research to improve our understanding of subsurface processes and change. It will provide scientific infrastructure for investigating the shallow, low-temperature coal mine water geothermal energy resources available in abandoned and flooded mine workings at depths of around 50-90 m below the eastern parts of the city.</p><p>The Glasgow site was chosen due to its commonalities with other parts of the UK and beyond in terms of its coal mining history, geology and legacy of industrial land use. Mine water geothermal resources in these settings could provide sufficient heat for community-scale district heating networks.</p><p>The research infrastructure comprises arrays of mine water and environmental baseline boreholes for characterisation and monitoring, and the boreholes are instrumented with permanent geophysical sensors. Here we report on interim results from drilling the environmental baseline and mine water boreholes, and opportunities for research and innovation.</p><p>Continuous monitoring and regular sampling data will be provided for the science community to examine a dynamic subsurface geo-, hydro- and bio-sphere. The facility will also provide opportunities for researchers to undertake their own experiments, with the aim of producing high-quality scientific evidence to reduce uncertainty on mine heat energy systems and understand their environmental impacts, for schemes across the UK and beyond.</p>


2010 ◽  
Author(s):  
B. Mack Kennedy ◽  
Karsten Pruess ◽  
Marcelo J. Lippmann ◽  
Ernest L. Majer ◽  
Peter E. Rose ◽  
...  

2012 ◽  
Vol 8 (3) ◽  
pp. 1059-1066 ◽  
Author(s):  
V. Rath ◽  
J. F. González Rouco ◽  
H. Goosse

Abstract. The investigation of observed borehole temperatures has proved to be a valuable tool for the reconstruction of ground surface temperature histories. However, there are still many open questions concerning the significance and accuracy of the reconstructions from these data. In particular, the temperature signal of the warming after the Last Glacial Maximum is still present in borehole temperature profiles. It is shown here that this signal also influences the relatively shallow boreholes used in current paleoclimate inversions to estimate temperature changes in the last centuries by producing errors in the determination of the steady state geothermal gradient. However, the impact on estimates of past temperature changes is weaker. For deeper boreholes, the curvature of the long-term signal is significant. A correction based on simple assumptions about glacial–interglacial temperature changes shows promising results, improving the extraction of millennial scale signals. The same procedure may help when comparing observed borehole temperature profiles with the results from numerical climate models.


2017 ◽  
Vol 139 ◽  
pp. 103-115 ◽  
Author(s):  
Duncan R.J. Sutherland ◽  
Donald R. Noble ◽  
Jeffrey Steynor ◽  
Thomas Davey ◽  
Tom Bruce

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document