NEXRAD Quantitative Precipitation Estimations for Hydrologic Simulation Using a Hybrid Hydrologic Model
Abstract A hybrid hydrologic model (lumped conceptual and distributed feature model), Distributed-Clark, is introduced to perform hydrologic simulations using spatially distributed NEXRAD quantitative precipitation estimations (QPEs). In Distributed-Clark, spatially distributed excess rainfall estimated with the Soil Conservation Service (SCS) curve number method and a GIS-based set of separated unit hydrographs are utilized to calculate a direct runoff flow hydrograph. This simple approach using few modeling parameters reduces calibration complexity relative to physically based distributed (PBD) models by only focusing on integrated flow estimation at watershed outlets. Case studies assessed the quality of NEXRAD stage IV QPEs for hydrologic simulation compared to gauge-only analyses. NEXRAD data validation against rain gauge observations and performance evaluation with model simulation result comparisons for inputs of spatially distributed stage IV and spatially averaged gauged data for four study watersheds were conducted. Results show significant differences in NEXRAD QPEs and gauged rainfall amounts, with NEXRAD data overestimated by 7.5% and 9.1% and underestimated by 15.0% and 11.4% accompanied by spatial variability. These differences affect model performance in hydrologic applications. Rainfall–runoff flow simulations using spatially distributed NEXRAD stage IV QPEs demonstrate relatively good fit [direct runoff: Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency ENS = 0.85, coefficient of determination R2 = 0.89, and percent bias (PBIAS) = 3.92%; streamflow: ENS = 0.91, R2 = 0.93, and PBIAS = 1.87%] against observed flow as well as better fit (ENS of 3.7% and R2 of 6.0% increase in direct runoff) than spatially averaged gauged rainfall for the same model calibration approach, enabling improved estimates of flow volumes and peak rates that can be underestimated in hydrologic simulations for spatially averaged rainfall.