The role of estrone in feminizing hormone treatment
Abstract Context In trans women, hormone treatment induces feminization, however the degree of feminization varies from person to person. A possible contributing factor could be estrone, a weak estrogen that interferes with the estrogen receptor. Objective To assess whether estrone is involved in feminization induced by hormone treatment. Design Prospective cohort study, with one year follow-up. Setting Gender identity clinic. Participants 212 adult trans women, starting hormone treatment between July 2017 and December 2019, median age 25 years. Intervention Gender affirming hormone treatment. Main outcome measures Change in fat percentage and breast development. Results After 12 months of hormone treatment, estrone concentration was 187pmol/L (95%CI 153 – 220) in transdermal and 1516pmol/L (95%CI 1284 – 1748) in oral estradiol users. Fat percentage increased by 1.2% (IQR 0.3 – 4.8) in transdermal and 4.6% (IQR 2.5 – 5.9) in oral estradiol users. This was not associated with estrone concentrations in transdermal(+4.4% (95%CI -4.0 – 13) per 100pmol/L increase in estrone concentration) nor in oral estradiol users (-0.7% (95%CI -1.7 – 0.3)). Breast volume increased by 69ml (IQR 58 – 134) in transdermal and 62ml (IQR 32 – 95) in oral estradiol users. This was not associated with estrone concentrations in transdermal (+ 14% (95%CI -49 – 156) per 100pmol/L increase in estrone concentration) nor oral estradiol users (+ 11% (95%CI -14 – 43)). Conclusions Change in fat percentage and breast development in trans women were not associated with estrone concentrations nor with administration route. Therefore measurement of estrone concentrations does not have a place in the monitoring of feminization in trans women.