Conventional wisdom indicates that as attrition in a field sample occurs, the remaining sample becomes more similar, e.g., homogeneous. This narrowing of the differences in the sample will cause a decrease in reliability as measured by Cronbach alpha. The current research is a 5-yr. longitudinal study that involved a group of auditors from five Big Six firms. The initial sample (Bernardi, 1994a) of 494 auditors was followed for a period of five years to assess the effect of attrition on Cronbach alpha for the Defining Issues Test (Rest, 1979a). At the beginning of the research, alpha was .348; however, by the end of Year five, alpha had decreased to .309. When the sample was stratified by sex and geographic location, the data indicate that, while alpha increased for the majority of the sample, it dramatically decreased for women in the New York City Metropolitan area. This study should assist other researchers who are examining data on a longitudinal basis when the sample is presumed to become more similar over time.