The effectiveness of online metacognitive versus face-to-face counseling on anxiety and metaworry in women with a history of spontaneous miscarriage: A Randomized clinical trial
Abstract BackgroundOnline and face-to-face counseling interventions can be performed on women with a history of miscarriage, which causes their anxiety and metaworry.The aim of this study was to compare effectiveness of metacognitive counseling methods, online and face-to-face, on anxiety and metaworry of women with miscarriage.MethodsIn this parallel randomized clinical trial, 40 women with a history of miscarriage, anxiety and metaworry were randomly assigned to two groups (n = 20/each): group I receiving metacognitive counseling via online network and software, and group II (control) receiving face-to-face metacognitive counseling with same content and time, 90-minute sessions. Data were collected demographic form, Beck Anxiety Inventory, Wellz metaworry questionnaire and satisfaction scale. Primary outcomes included changes in the scores of anxiety, metaworry were measured in both groups in three times including at the base line, and at the end of week eight and twelve of the intervention initiation. Satisfaction with counseling method was assessed as secondary outcome at the end of week eight and twelve of the intervention beginning in both groups.ResultsIn both groups, mean score of anxiety in 12th week was significantly different from before the intervention; difference was more significant in online group (p = 0.04). In both groups, the mean score of metaworry in 12th week had a statistically significant difference compared to the beginning of the study, and the decrease was again more significant in the online group (p = 0.03). Satisfaction with the counseling method had statistically significant difference between the two groups in week eight and twelve (respectively p ≈ 0.00).ConclusionsMetacognitive counseling both online and face-to-face improves anxiety and metaworry in women with miscarriage. Online counseling was more effective, satisfying, and longer compared with face-to-face counseling method, especially in corona virus19 outbreak.Trial registration: ISRCTN, IRCT20181120041707N1, Prospectively registered, Registered 23 May 2019, https://en.irct.ir/trial/35643/ IRCT20181120041707N1