Abstract Numeric Relations and the Visual Structure of Algebra
We propose that construction processes involve an alignment of notational structures across representation systems, biasing reasoners toward the selection of formal notations that maintain the visuo-spatial structure of source representations. For example, in the statement “There are five elephants for every three rhinoceroses,” the spatial proximity of “five” and “elephants; and “three” and “rhinoceroses” will bias reasoners to write the incorrect expression 5E = 3R because that expression maintains the spatial relationships encoded in the source representation. In three experiments, participants construct equations with given structure, based on story problems with a variety of phrasings. We demonstrate how the notational alignment approach accounts naturally for a variety of previously reported phenomena in equation construction, and successfully predicts error patterns that are not accounted for by prior explanations such as the “left to right transcription heuristic.”