Contrasting shared- and specific-mechanism accounts of developmental prosopagnosia: A new approach
The understanding of developmental prosopagnosia (DP) is dominated by two opposing views: (i) that DP reflects malfunction of a mechanism shared by face and object recognition, but which is more critical for face than for object recognition, or (ii) that DP is due to malfunction of a mechanism specific to faces, but where object recognition deficits may co-occur due to collateral damage. Here we address some of the limitations in DP studies on this point by examining face and car recognition in a large cohort of healthy subjects selected in an unbiased manner. At the group level we find evidence of a general association between face and car recognition performance but at the individual level we also find occasional dissociations. We discuss the methodological implications of these findings for cognitive neuropsychology in general (association vs. dissociation) but also the theoretical implications for the current understanding of DP more specifically.