This chapter charts sentimentalism as it opposed and forwarded the displacement of the Five Tribes from lands east of the Mississippi River known as the Trail of Tears. The chapter analyzes an archive of U.S. relocation officers’ journals, Cherokee publications and oral histories, GIS images of the trail, and the living metaphor of the Cherokee rose. As affect permeated new publics and print cultures, court justices, storytellers, legislators, and survivors increasingly turned to the land to evoke, express, and mediate affects in response to genocide. This chapter maps which forms of (tribal, local, federal) belonging emerged, which were foreclosed, and on what and whose grounds. In light of the Trail, still incised on the continent, as well as Cherokee rhetorics that treats the earth as an agent, the chapter excavates the ground as an active participant in, as well as a literal and figurative landscape for, contestations over stewardship, sovereignty, and territory.