Judging by Refraining from Judgment

2019 ◽  
pp. 95-114
Author(s):  
Gerhard Richter

This chapter focuses on Adorno’s understanding of the category of judgment. Proceeding from Adorno’s apodictic interpretation of a poem by the German Biedermeier writer Eduard Mörike, it reconstructs what it might mean for Adorno to argue for the critical practice of judging by refraining from judgment. Mörike’s children’s poem “Mousetrap Rhyme” is the only poem that Adorno chooses to quote in its entirety in his Aesthetic Theory. His surprising choice reveals how the uncoercive gaze can never be reduced to a set of ideological operations or a priori correspondences but rather must confront, in the space of the work of art, the question of its judgment—and the typically unspoken premises and presuppositions of any judgment—always one more time. Here, the uncoercive gaze fastens upon the artwork in a way that allows art to become world without reducing the art to the condition of being merely that which already is the case or that which already claims to be world. The artwork keeps alive the singular form of judgment as judgment without judging, in which the ultimate arrest of judgment remains deferred in virtue of another judgment, based on a future critical engagement, that is always still to come.

Author(s):  
Dominic McIver Lopes

There is currently a great deal of fundamental disagreement in research into aesthetic response. The remedy is ideally integration, wherein researchers in the different aesthetic sciences and humanistic studies converge on a common conception of what they are trying to explain, even if they continue to disagree about how to explain it. If it is to be successful, this convergence will require that researchers in both the scientific and humanistic disciplines be sensitive to the limitations that are inherent in each of these two different approaches. On the one hand, we should not expect a conception of aesthetic response that is productive for research across disciplines to be given a precise a priori definition. On the other hand, aesthetic science must acknowledge that aesthetic response is embedded in critical practice, about which the humanities have a lot to say.


2019 ◽  
Vol 53 ◽  
pp. 295-307
Author(s):  
Will McNeill ◽  

Heidegger’s 1936 essay “The Origin of the Work of Art” is notoriously dense and difficult. In part this is because it appears to come almost from nowhere, given that Heidegger has relatively little to say about art in his earlier work. Yet the essay can only be adequately understood, I would argue, in concert with Heidegger’s essay on Hölderlin from the same year, “Hölderlin and the Essence of Poetizing.” Without the Hölderlin essay, for instance, the central claim of “The Origin of the Work of Art” to the effect that all art is in essence poetizing, Dichtung, can hardly be appreciated in its philosophical significance without the discussions of both essence and poetizing that appear in the Hölderlin essay. This is true of other concepts also. The central concept of the rift (Riß)—the fissure or tear—that appears in “The Origin of the Work of Art” might readily be assumed to be adopted from Albrecht Dürer, whose use of the term Heidegger cites at a key point in the 1936 essay. Here, however, I argue that the real source of the concept for Heidegger is Hölderlin, and that the Riß is, moreover—quite literally—an inscription of originary, ekstatic temporality; that is, of temporality as the “origin” of Being and as the poetic or poetizing essence of art. I do so, first, by briefly considering Heidegger’s references to Dürer in “The Origin of the Work of Art” and other texts from the period, as well as his understanding of the Riß and of the tearing of the Riß in that essay and in its two earlier versions. I then turn to Heidegger’s 1936 Rome lecture “Hölderlin and the Essence of Poetizing,” in order to show the Hölderlinian origins of this concept for Heidegger.


In recent communications to the Society, I have confined myself largely to the Theory of Fourier Series, partly because much seemed to me still to require doing in this subject, partly because I believed its thorough investigation to be the natural preparation for the study of other series of normal functions. It has, indeed, been known for some time that the behaviour of, for instance, series of Sturm-Liouville functions exactly corresponds to that of Fourier series. The introduction that I have recently made into Analysis of what I have called restricted Fourier series enables us to notably extend the range of such analogies. I propose in the present communication to illustrate this remark with reference to series of Legendre coefficients. Whereas Fourier series may be said to be “naturally unrestricted,” in virtue of the fact that the convergence of the integrated series to an integral necessarily involves the tendency towards zero of its own general term, so that the consideration of the more general type of series does not at once suggest itself, Legendre series may be said to come into being “restricted,” even when the coefficients are expressible in what may be called the Fourier form by means of integrals involving Legendre’s coefficients. In other words, such series correspond precisely to restricted Fourier series, instead of to ordinary Fourier series like the analogous series of Sturm-Liouville functions.


Author(s):  
Walter Brueggemann

This chapter, in a personal way, considers some methodological moves in this discipline beyond historical criticism, for example, post-critical reading, post-colonial interpretation, and reception history. The interest of the chapter, however, is the interpretive theological outcomes of such methods, and why the text continues to matter theologically in a culture of denial and despair. Clearly these newer methods allow for significant interpretive outcomes in a way that older historical critical practice could not. The author anticipates that in time to come, more courageous interpretation of prophetic texts will more readily make that move toward contemporaneity that the text seems always to anticipate.


2019 ◽  
pp. 131-143
Author(s):  
Gerhard Richter

Chapter 6 marks a transition from the uncoercive gaze as it finds expression in other aspects of Adorno’s work to the problem of orientation, understood both as an intellectual phenomenon and as a problem to be considered in relation to the work of art. This chapter adds another case study to the examination of Adorno’s critical practice of the uncoercive gaze by complicating the concept of orientation and supposed “cognitive maps” provided by the artwork and by theoretical discourse. Tracing Adorno’s abiding engagement with the problem of orientation back to Kant’s essay on what it might mean to orient oneself in thinking, the chapter interrogates how Adorno’s engagement with the problem of orientation and the attendant specter of disorientation inflects a broader set of concerns that traverse his writing throughout its various periods.


2020 ◽  
Vol 21 (3) ◽  
pp. 237-244
Author(s):  
Alexander Mayer ◽  
Stefan Napel

Abstract Executive Directors of the International Monetary Fund elect the Fund’s Managing Director from a shortlist of three candidates; financial quotas of IMF members define the respective numbers of votes. The implied a priori distribution of success (preference satisfaction) is compared across different electoral procedures. The USA’s Executive Director can expect to come closer to its top preference under plurality rule than for pairwise majority comparisons or plurality with a runoff; opposite applies to everybody else. Differences of US success between voting rules dominate the within-rule differences between most other Directors, and much of the latest reform of quotas.


2014 ◽  
Vol 40 (128) ◽  
pp. 457
Author(s):  
José Henrique Santos

Este ensaio trata do duplo sentido subjacente à doutrina da encarnação. A natureza humano/divina do Cristo indica o percurso da “ascensão especulativa” que precisa ir para chegar a vir: só podeis (v)ir ao Pai por meio de mim. A teologia produz um discurso antecipado que só começa a gerar sentido (para nós) “de baixo para cima”, mas que pressupõe, ao mesmo tempo, a graça do Deus Criador vindo ao encontro do homem. Tento expor, na medida do possível, a severa lógica do discurso dogmático e sua intrínseca racionalidade. A tese implícita no texto supõe sintética a priori a identidade do Pai e do Filho, e não analítica. (Ver referência a Hipólito de Roma).Abstract: This essay focuses on the double meaning underlying the doctrine of incarnation. The human/divine nature of Christ puts us on the path of the “speculative ascent” that needs to come in order do come back: you can only get to the Father through me. Theology produces an anticipated discourse which only starts making sense (for us) “from bottom to top” but that, at the same time, presupposes the grace of the Lord, Lord the Creator who came forth to meet mankind. The attempt here will be to determine, as far as possible, the strict logic of the dogmatic discourse along with its intrinsic rationality. The implicit thesis of the text supposes that the identity of the Father and of the Son is a priori synthetic and not analytic (see the reference to Hippolytus of Rome)


1994 ◽  
Vol 36 ◽  
pp. 31-43
Author(s):  
Robert Elliot

Some people think that nature has intrinsic value, that it has value in itself quite apart from its present and future economic, intellectual, recreational and aesthetic uses. Some people think that nature's intrinsic value grounds an obligation to preserve it and to minimise human interference with it. I agree. It is important, however, to try to say exactly why nature has intrinsic value, to go beyond merely stating some idiosyncratic attitude and to provide some justification of that attitude with which others might engage. Presumably there are properties that wild nature exemplifies in virtue of which it is intrinsically valued. Only when these are indicated is rational debate as to whether wild nature has intrinsic value possible. Only when these are indicated is it possible to begin to persuade dissenters to change their views. Indeed, unless one can at least begin to say what these properties are it is not clear that the attitude could have any meaningful content. While it is perhaps possible to value something without immediately understanding what it is about the thing that makes it valuable, the failure to come up with any candidate value-adding property after some reflection suggests that the initial value-judgment is vacuous.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
◽  
Jafar Mirzaee Porkoli

<p><b>The core argument of this thesis is on the aporetic moment/space of decision and the poetics of the to-come in John Milton's works, with the fundamental importance of the individual. For Milton, this moment/space is radically critical and free, and individually problematic, which goes beyond the usual private/public space even though the public aspects and responsibilities of the person's decision demonstrate exceptional significance in the form of public enactment. In Milton's terms, the experience of such an aporetic moment/space of decision is indispensible for those who want to become a "fit reader" and develop the essential qualities and attributes. I will argue that Milton has always written with the desire to highlight and exemplify the absolute singularity of such a moment and experience throughout his life and works, both prose and poetry.</b></p> <p>The thesis will represent its arguments in two sections. The first section, through a consideration of Derrida's arguments in his works (in particular: "The Laws of Reflection: Nelson Mandela, in Admiration," "The Future of the Profession or the Unconditional University," "Force of Law: 'The Mystical Foundation of Authority,'" and "This Strange Institution Called Literature") together with a selection of Milton's writings, mainly prose (including: Areopagitica, Eikonoklastes, The Tenure of Kings and Magistrates, and Paradise Lost), will examine and identify possible continuities and convergences between the two writers. Such an intimate juxtaposition and close reading of their works has promisingly offered recognition of continuities, convergences, and affinities in their thought in terms of the qualities and attributes of the "fit reader" and the "democratic intellect." In the opening five chapters, the interactive reading highlights fundamental questions and notions for both writers, including the question of exemplarity or singularity, the notion of public space without conditions, the question of justice beyond the law, the critique of violence, and the question of literature as a lawless institution, providing me with the essential terminology to formulate new interpretations of Milton's works, in particular, Paradise Regained and Samson Agonistes.</p> <p>The second part of the thesis uses the conceptions and terms developed in the opening chapters to read the two late poems, Paradise Regained and Samson Agonistes, as singular examples of Milton's fit reader, the aporetic moment/space of decision, and the poetics of the to-come by setting out the general comparative points between them. The focus of my arguments in these chapters will be on the hypothesis that Paradise Regained and Samson Agonistes are both demonstrating the aporetic moment/space of decision - confusingly replete with uncertainties, complexities, and indeterminacies - and the dominant poetics of the to-come as well as arguing for the singularity of the moment, decision, and enactment of the decision in each poem. I will argue that Paradise Regained and Samson Agonistes provide outstanding exemplifications of Milton's notion of the "fit reader" developing similar qualities and attributes in common with Derrida's "democratic intellect."Milton's works represent the aporetic moment/space of decision as an ongoing process; it is a singular moment in which uncertainties and indeterminacies produce unresolvable choices, but where a decision must nonetheless be made; it is a moment of "trial" the result of which cannot be known to the individual "fit reader" in advance. Milton's late poems, Paradise Regained and Samson Agonistes, explore the critical significance of this moment and demonstrate that no certain, fixed, pre-programmed, or predetermined model or frame can be applied to the resolution of aporetic moments of decision in different times, places, and contexts. The "fit reader" is one who radically and critically reads and re-reads aporetic situations, full of inescapable indeterminacies and unresolved choices, and expresses his individual judgement in the singular form of a true decision (not calculation) to advance the possibilities of truth, justice, and humanity.</p>


CORAK ◽  
2017 ◽  
Vol 6 (2) ◽  
Author(s):  
Dyah Retno Fitriani

Passion, love, and interest can be an inspiration to an artist. That thing can be a stimulation in creating a work of art. Some scene of film Life of Pi shows an ocean view which glows at night became such an admiration to the writer. The astonishment then stimulated curiousities of the writer about that phenomenon. Finally, there came out the word Radiolaria. Radiolaria are tiny sized planktons which have holes and spikes in their bodies. The shape and texture of Radiolaria became an inspiration that later will be deformed and shaped into a ceramic instalation. Innovation and creation that arise in this work were also displayed using phospor as a medium to show the phenomenon of Bioluminesensi. The intention to introduce the shape and function of Radiolaria gives an enormous stimulation to the writer, so that this artwork was made to give an education through this work of art. The creation of this artwork began with making skecth planning, material choosing, up to the stage of creating which was done by some techniques, which are a cire perdue, pinch, slab, and decorating stage with the technique of piercing and twisting. After that, there was a drying stage, biscuit burning, glacing, glacing burning, phospor finishing, and displaying. Furthermore, the artwork was strenghten by some supporting theories, such as: ceramic theory, deformation, instalation, semiotic, and aesthetic theory. This work is a ceramic applied art which was displayed in the varied colors and shapes instalation. Semiotic contains were slipped in this artwork and were hoped to create a good communication with the society and art lovers. This Radiolaria themed work of art was made to introduce Radiolaria to people in general with applying the touch of personal expression touch so that originality of this work would remains the same without fading the impression of the real Radiolaria. Key Words: Deformation, Radiolaria, Ceramic Instalation.   Kesukaan, kecintaan, ketertaikan akan suatu hal dapat menjadi sebuah inspirasi bagi seorang seniman, tentunya hal tersebut dapat menjadi sebuah rangsangan dalam menciptakan sebuah karya seni. Film Life of Pi yang dibeberapa scene nya memperlihatkan pemandangan laut yang dapat berpijar dimalam hari memberikan rasa takjub sehingga merangsang rasa ingin tahu tentang apa yang menyebabkan adanya fenomena tersebut, yang kemudian didapatlah kata Radiolaria. Radiolaria merupakan plankton yang berukuran sangat kecil dengan ciri khas memiliki lubang-lubang dan duri-duri pada tubuhnya. Bentuk dan tekstur Radiolaria ini dijadikan sumber ide yang kemudian akan dideformasi dan dijadikan keramik instalasi. Inovasi dan kreasi yang muncul dalam karya ini juga ditampilkan dengan menggunakan fosfor sebagai media untuk menunjukkan peristiwa Bioluminesensi. Rasa ingin memperkenalkan akan bentuk dan manfaatRadiolaria memberikan dorongan yang begitu besar, sehingga diciptakanlah karya ini agar dapat memberikan edukasi baru melalui karya keramik instalasi.Penciptaan karya ini diawali dengan membuat sketsa perancangan, pemilihan bahan, hingga tahap perwujudan yang dilakukan dengan beberapa teknik yaitu cetak tuang, pinch, dan slab dan tahap pendekorasian dengan teknik krawang, dan pilin. Kemudian tahapan pengeringan, pembakaran biskuit, pengglasiran, pembakaran glasir, finishing dengan fosfor, dan pendisplayan. Lalu diperkuat dengan beberapa teori pendukung seperti : teori keramik, deformasi, instalasi, semiotika, dan estetika.Hasil karya ini merupakan seni kriya keramik yang didisplay secara instalasi yang memiliki variasi bentuk dan warna, dan kandungan semiotika yang disisipkan pada setiap karyanya sehingga diharapkan karya ini dapat berkomunikasi dengan masyarakat, dan penikmat seni dengan baik. Karya keramik dengan tema Radiolaria ini dimakudkan untuk memperkenalkan Radiolaria dikalangan awam dengan menerapkan sentuhan ekspresi pribadi sehingga orisinalitas karya tetap terjaga tanpa mengurangi kesan dari Radiolaria yang aslinya. Kata Kunci : Deformasi, Radiolaria, Keramik Instalasi.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document