The American Actress’s Starring Playbook, 1831–1857
This chapter examines the professional strategies of three American actresses of the 1830s through the 1850s: Josephine Clifton, Charlotte Cushman, and Matilda Heron, who competed with English stars in the context of intensifying respectability politics around theater. They appealed to nationalism, pursued original repertoire, and tried to align themselves with genteel white womanhood. As women with no family alliances in the industry, they faced the pitfalls of negotiating an industry largely controlled by male power brokers and in which appeals to respectability remained tenuous. The comparison between them demonstrates that the starring system made it possible for some women to pursue unconventional independent lives for the time even as they strained to appear to conform to narrow constructions of genteel white womanhood.