Reappraisal of gap analysis for effusive crises at Piton de la Fournaise

Effective and rapid effusive crisis response is necessary to mitigate the risks associated with lava flows that could threaten or inundate inhabited or visited areas. At Piton de la Fournaise (La Réunion, France), well-established protocols between Observatoire Volcanologique du Piton de la Fournaise – Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris (OVPF-IPGP) and civil protection, and between scientists of a multinational array of institutes, allow effective tracking of eruptive crises and hazard management embracing all stakeholders. To assess the outstanding needs for such responses Tsang and Lindsay (J Appl Volcanol 9:9, 2020) applied a gap analysis to assess research gaps in terms of preparedness, response and recovery at 11 effusive centers, including Piton de la Fournaise. For Piton de la Fournaise, their gap analysis implied widespread gaps in the state of knowledge. However, their work relied on incomplete and erroneous data and methods, resulting in a gap analysis that significantly underrepresented this state of knowledge. We thus here re-build a correct database for Piton de la Fournaise, properly define the scope of an appropriate gap analysis, and provide a robust gap analysis, finding that there are, actually, very few gaps for Piton de la Fournaise. This is a result of the existence of a great quantity of published work in the peer-reviewed literature, as well as frequent reports documenting event impact in the local press and observatory reports. At Piton de la Fournaise, this latter (observatory-based) resource is largely due to the efforts of OVPF-IPGP who have a wealth of experience having responded to 81 eruptions since its creation in 1979 through the end of September 2021.Although welcome and necessary, especially if it is made by a group of scientists outside the local management of the volcanic risk (i.e., a neutral group), such gap analysis need to be sure to fully consider all available peer-reviewed literature, as well as newspaper reports, observatory releases and non-peer-reviewed eruption reports, so as to be complete and correct. Fundamentally, such an analysis needs to consider the information collected and produced by the volcano observatory charged with handling surveillance operations and reporting duties to civil protection for the volcano under analysis. As a very minimum, to ensure that a necessarily comprehensive and complete treatment of the scientific literature has been completed, we recommend that a third party expert, who is a recognized specialist in terms of research at the site considered, reviews and checks the material used for the gap analysis before final release of recommendations.

Lava flow hazard map of Piton de la Fournaise volcano

Piton de la Fournaise, situated on La Réunion island (France), is one of the most active hot spot basaltic shield volcanoes worldwide, experiencing at least two eruptions per year since the establishment of the volcanological observatory in 1979. Eruptions are typically fissure-fed and form extensive lava flow fields. About 95 % of some ∼ 250 historical events (since the first confidently dated eruption in 1708) have occurred inside an uninhabited horseshoe-shaped caldera (hereafter referred to as the Enclos), which is open to the ocean on its eastern side. Rarely (12 times since the 18th century), fissures have opened outside of the Enclos, where housing units, population centers, and infrastructure are at risk. In such a situation, lava flow hazard maps are a useful way of visualizing lava flow inundation probabilities over large areas. Here, we present the up-to-date lava flow hazard map for Piton de la Fournaise based on (i) vent distribution, (ii) lava flow recurrence times, (iii) statistics of lava flow lengths, and (iv) simulations of lava flow paths using the DOWNFLOW stochastic numerical model. The map of the entire volcano highlights the spatial distribution probability of future lava flow invasion for the medium to long term (years to decades). It shows that the most probable location for future lava flow is within the Enclos (where there are areas with up to 12 % probability), a location visited by more than 100 000 visitors every year. Outside of the Enclos, probabilities reach 0.5 % along the active rift zones. Although lava flow hazard occurrence in inhabited areas is deemed to be very low (< 0.1 %), it may be underestimated as our study is only based on post-18th century records and neglects older events. We also provide a series of lava flow hazard maps inside the Enclos, computed on a multi-temporal (i.e., regularly updated) topography. Although hazard distribution remains broadly the same over time, some changes are noticed throughout the analyzed periods due to improved digital elevation model (DEM) resolution, the high frequency of eruptions that constantly modifies the topography, and the lava flow dimensional characteristics and paths. The lava flow hazard map for Piton de la Fournaise presented here is reliable and trustworthy for long-term hazard assessment and land use planning and management. Specific hazard maps for short-term hazard assessment (e.g., for responding to volcanic crises) or considering the cycles of activity at the volcano and different event scenarios (i.e., events fed by different combinations of temporally evolving superficial and deep sources) are required for further assessment of affected areas in the future – especially by atypical but potentially extremely hazardous large-volume eruptions. At such an active site, our method supports the need for regular updates of DEMs and associated lava flow hazard maps if we are to be effective in keeping up to date with mitigation of the associated risks.

Multiscale Modeling of Convection and Pollutant Transport Associated with Volcanic Eruption and Lava Flow: Application to the April 2007 Eruption of the Piton de la Fournaise (Reunion Island)

Volcanic eruptions can cause damage to land and people living nearby, generate high concentrations of toxic gases, and also create large plumes that limit observations and the performance of forecasting models that rely on these observations. This study investigates the use of micro- to meso-scale simulation to represent and predict the convection, transport, and deposit of volcanic pollutants. The case under study is the 2007 eruption of the Piton de la Fournaise, simulated using a high-resolution, coupled lava/atmospheric approach (derived from wildfire/atmosphere coupled code) to account for the strong, localized heat and gaseous fluxes occurring near the vent, over the lava flow, and at the lava–sea interface. Higher resolution requires fluxes over the lava flow to be explicitly simulated to account for the induced convection over the flow, local mixing, and dilution. Comparisons with air quality values at local stations show that the simulation is in good agreement with observations in terms of sulfur concentration and dynamics, and performs better than lower resolution simulation with parameterized surface fluxes. In particular, the explicit representation of the thermal flows associated with lava allows the associated thermal breezes to be represented. This local modification of the wind flow strongly impacts the organization of the volcanic convection (injection height) and the regional transport of the sulfur dioxide emitted at the vent. These results show that explicitly solving volcanic activity/atmosphere complex interactions provides realistic forecasts of induced pollution.

Lava flow hazard map of Piton de la Fournaise volcano

&lt;p&gt;Piton de la Fournaise, situated on La Re&amp;#769;union Island (France), is one of the most active hot spot basaltic shield volcanoes worldwide, experiencing at least two eruptions per year since the establishment of the observatory in 1979. Eruptions are typically fissure-fed and form extensive lava flow fields. About 95 % of some ~250 historical events (since the first confidently dated eruption in 1708) have occurred inside an uninhabited horse-shoe shaped caldera (hereafter referred to as the Enclos) which is open to the ocean on its eastern side. Rarely (12 times since the 18th century), fissures have opened outside of the Enclos where housing units, population centers and infrastructure are at risk. In such a situation, lava flow hazard maps are a useful way of visualizing lava flow inundation probabilities over large areas. Here, we present a lava flow hazard map for Piton de la Fournaise volcano based on: i) vent distribution, ii) statistics of lava flow lengths, iii) lava flow recurrence times, and iv) simulations of lava flow paths across multi-temporal (i.e., regularly updated) topography using the DOWNFLOW stochastic numerical model. A map of the entire volcano highlights that the most probable (up to 12 %) location for future lava flow inundation is within the Enclos, where about 100,000 visitors are present each year. Hazard distribution changes throughout the analysis period due to the high frequency of eruptions that constantly modifies the vent opening distribution as well as the topography and the lava flow dimensional characteristics. Outside of the Enclos, probabilities reach 0.5 % along the well-defined rift zones and, although hazard occurrence in inhabited areas is deemed to be very low (&lt;0.1 %), it may be underestimated here, as our study is only based on post-18th century records and neglects cycles of activity at the volcano. Specific hazard maps considering different event scenarios (i.e., events fed by different combinations of temporally evolving superficial and deep sources) are required to better assess affected areas in the future &amp;#8211; especially by atypical, but potentially extremely hazardous, large volume eruptions. At such an active site, our method supports the need for regular updates of DEMs and associated lava flow hazard maps if we are to be effective in mitigating the associated risks.&lt;/p&gt;

Gas and heat fluxes during multiple effusive eruptions of Piton de la Fournaise (Réunion) and their implications for magmatic processes

&lt;p&gt;Piton de la Fournaise (La R&amp;#233;union, France) is one of the most active volcanoes in the world, producing frequent effusive basaltic eruptions of varying duration. These eruptions are accompanied by strong thermal infrared (TIR) signals and significant sulfur dioxide (SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt;) emissions detected by satellite instruments. The high frequency of eruptions provides an extensive dataset, which allows us to explore the relationships between eruptive heat, mass and gas fluxes. Five eruptions with different temporal trends of erupted mass flux have been selected for this study: April 2007, May 2015, August-October 2015, February 2019 and April 2020. For each of them, we estimated SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; emission from three ultraviolet satellite instruments (the Ozone Monitoring Instrument OMI, the Ozone Mapping and Profiler Suite OMPS and the Tropospheric Monitoring Instrument TROPOMI). The total SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; emission for each eruption has been estimated for an extensive range of sulfur (S) content within melt inclusions and the matrix using a petrological approach and the erupted magma masses obtained from MODIS TIR satellite data. Preliminary results show that, assuming the estimated SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; emission falls within the 30% error of the SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; mass detected by each satellite instrument, the implied magmatic sulfur contents are in good agreement with expected values for basaltic eruptions. Given pre-eruptive S contents between 200 and 750 ppm, estimated SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; emissions for the May 2015 eruption are consistent with an eruption largely fed by degassed magma. However, for the February 2019 eruption, there is a discrepancy between the three satellite sensors. Whereas the TROPOMI and the OMI instruments provide almost the same range of magmatic sulfur content (300-1100 ppm), the OMPS gives a higher range (700 to 1900 ppm) suggesting that fresh, undegassed magma was also involved in this eruption. Petrologic analysis of the pre-eruptive sulfur content will allow us to validate the satellite data and, in turn, to validate the ground-based SO&lt;sub&gt;2&lt;/sub&gt; data from the NOVAC network operated by the&amp;#160;Observatoire Volcanologique du Piton de la Fournaise&amp;#160;(OVPF). Our approach yields insights into the characteristics of the magma reservoir supplying effusive events (e.g., eruptive degassing processes and the ratio of intrusive to extrusive magma) from space-based sensors.&lt;/p&gt;