Transcription modulates chromatin dynamics and locus configuration sampling

In living cells the 3D structure of gene loci is dynamic, but this is not revealed by 3C and FISH experiments in fixed samples, leaving a significant gap in our understanding. To overcome these limitations we applied the "highly predictive heteromorphic polymer" (HiP-HoP) model, validated by experiments, to determine chromatin fibre mobility at the Pax6 locus in three mouse cell lines with different transcription states. While transcriptional activity minimally affects the movement of 40 kbp regions, we observed that the motion of smaller 1 kbp regions depends strongly on local disruption to chromatin fibre structure marked by H3K27 acetylation. This also significantly influenced locus configuration dynamics by modulating promoter-enhancer loops associated with protein bridging. Importantly these simulations indicate that chromatin dynamics are sufficiently fast to sample all possible conformations of loci within minutes, generating wide dynamic variability of gene loci structure within single cells. Experiments inhibiting transcription change chromatin fibre structure subtly, yet we predict they should substantially affect mobility. This combination of simulation and experimental validation provide a novel insight and mechanistic model to explain how transcriptional activity influences chromatin structure and gene dynamics.

Electrostatics and Solvation: Essential Determinants of Chromatin Compaction

ABSTRACTChromatin compaction is a process of fundamental importance in Biology, as it greatly influences cellular function and gene expression. The dynamics of compaction is determined by the interactions between DNA and histones, which are mainly mechanical and electrostatic. The high charge of DNA makes electrostatics extremely important for chromatin topology and dynamics. Besides their mechanical and steric role in the chromatin fibre, linker DNA length and linker histone presence and binding position also bear great electrostatic consequences. Electrostatics in chromatin is also indirectly linked to the DNA sequence: the presence of high-curvature AT-rich segments in DNA can cause conformational variations with electrostatic repercussions, attesting to the fact that the role of DNA is both structural and electrostatic. Electrostatics in this system has been analysed by extensively examining at the computational level the repercussions of varying ionic concentration, using all-atom, coarse-grained, and continuum models. There have been some tentative attempts to describe the force fields governing chromatin conformational changes and the energy landscapes of these transitions, but the intricacy of the system has hampered reaching a consensus. Chromatin compaction is a very complex issue, depending on many factors and spanning orders of magnitude in space and time in its dynamics. Therefore, comparison and complementation of theoretical models with experimental results is fundamental. Here, we present existing approaches to analyse electrostatics in chromatin and the different points of view from which this issue is treated. We pay particular attention to solvation, often overlooked in chromatin studies. We also present some numerical results on the solvation of nucleosome core particles. We discuss experimental techniques that have been combined with computational approaches and present some related experimental data such as the Z-potential of nucleosomes at varying ionic concentrations. Finally, we discuss how these observations support the importance of electrostatics and solvation in chromatin models.SIGNIFICANCEThis work explores the determinants of chromatin compaction, focusing on the importance of electrostatic interactions and solvation. Chromatin compaction is an intrinsically multiscale issue, since processes concerning chromatin occur on a wide range of spatial and temporal scales. Since DNA is a highly charged macromolecule, electrostatic interactions are extremely significant for chromatin compaction, an effect examined in this work from many angles, such as the importance of ionic concentration and different ionic types, DNA-protein interactions, and solvation. Solvation is often overlooked in chromatin studies, especially in coarse-grained models, where the nucleosome core, the building block of the chromatin fibre, is represented as a rigid body, even though it has been observed that solvation influences chromatin even at the base-pair level.

Polymer Simulations of Heteromorphic Chromatin Predict the 3-D Folding of Complex Genomic Loci

Chromatin folded into 3-D macromolecular structures is often analysed by 3C and FISH techniques, but frequently provide contradictory results. Instead, chromatin can be modelled as a simple polymer comprised of a connected chain of units. By embedding data for epigenetic marks (H3K27ac), genomic disruptions (ATAC-seq) and structural anchors (CTCF) we developed a highly predictive heteromorphic polymer (HiP-HoP) model, where the chromatin fibre varied along its length; combined with diffusing protein bridges and loop extrusion this model predicted the 3-D organisation of genomic loci at a population and single cell level. The model was validated at several gene loci, including the complex Pax6 gene, and was able to determine locus conformations across cell types with varying levels of transcriptional activity and explain different mechanisms of enhancer use. Minimal a priori knowledge of epigenetic marks is sufficient to recapitulate complex genomic loci in 3-D and enable predictions of chromatin folding paths.

Effect of chromatin flexibility on diffusive loop extrusion via molecular slip-links

We use Brownian dynamics simulations to study the formation of chromatin loops through diffusive sliding of molecular slip links, mimicking the behaviour of cohesin-like molecules. We recently proposed that diffusive sliding is sufficient to explain the extrusion of chromatin loops of hundreds of kilo-base-pairs (kbp), which may then be stabilised by interactions between cohesin and CTCF proteins. Here we show that the elasticity of the chromatin fibre strongly affects this dynamical process, and find that diffusive loop extrusion is more efficient on stiffer chromatin regions. Efficiency is also enhanced if cohesin loading sites are close to regions where CTCF is bound. In light of the heterogeneous physical properties of eukaryotic chromatin, we suggest that our results should be relevant to the looping and organisation of interphase chromosomes in vivo.

Epigenetic Transitions and Knotted Solitons in Stretched Chromatin

The spreading and regulation of epigenetic marks on chromosomes is crucial to establish and maintain cellular identity. Nonetheless, the dynamical mechanism leading to the establishment and maintenance of a given, cell-line specific, epigenetic pattern is still poorly understood. In this work we propose, and investigate in silico, a possible experimental strategy to illuminate the interplay between 3D chromatin structure and epigenetic dynamics. We consider a set-up where a reconstituted chromatin fibre is stretched at its two ends (e.g., by laser tweezers), while epigenetic enzymes (writers) and chromatin-binding proteins (readers) are flooded into the system. We show that, by tuning the stretching force and the binding affinity of the readers for chromatin, the fibre undergoes a sharp transition between a stretched, epigenetically disordered, state and a crumpled, epigenetically coherent, one. We further investigate the case in which a knot is tied along the chromatin fibre, and find that the knotted segment enhances local epigenetic order, giving rise to “epigenetic solitons” which travel and diffuse along chromatin. Our results point to an intriguing coupling between 3D chromatin topology and epigenetic dynamics, which may be investigated via single molecule experiments.

The role of the nucleosome acidic patch in modulating higher order chromatin structure

Higher order folding of chromatin fibre is mediated by interactions of the histone H4 N-terminal tail domains with neighbouring nucleosomes. Mechanistically, the H4 tails of one nucleosome bind to the acidic patch region on the surface of adjacent nucleosomes, causing fibre compaction. The functionality of the chromatin fibre can be modified by proteins that interact with the nucleosome. The co-structures of five different proteins with the nucleosome (LANA, IL-33, RCC1, Sir3 and HMGN2) recently have been examined by experimental and computational studies. Interestingly, each of these proteins displays steric, ionic and hydrogen bond complementarity with the acidic patch, and therefore will compete with each other for binding to the nucleosome. We first review the molecular details of each interface, focusing on the key non-covalent interactions that stabilize the protein–acidic patch interactions. We then propose a model in which binding of proteins to the nucleosome disrupts interaction of the H4 tail domains with the acidic patch, preventing the intrinsic chromatin folding pathway and leading to assembly of alternative higher order chromatin structures with unique biological functions.

Insights into chromatin fibre structure by in vitro and in silico single-molecule stretching experiments

The detailed structure and dynamics of the chromatin fibre and their relation to gene regulation represent important open biological questions. Recent advances in single-molecule force spectroscopy experiments have addressed these questions by directly measuring the forces that stabilize and alter the folded states of chromatin, and by investigating the mechanisms of fibre unfolding. We present examples that demonstrate how complementary modelling approaches have helped not only to interpret the experimental findings, but also to advance our knowledge of force-induced events such as unfolding of chromatin with dynamically bound linker histones and nucleosome unwrapping.

Monte Carlo simulation of chromatin fibre confined in a nanochannel

We study 30-nm chromatin fibre restricted in a nanofluidic channel with square cross-section using Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. The chromatin fibre is modelled as cylinders-on-a-string with six alterable angles. The effects of the channel width and Emax on the configuration of the chromatin fibre are investigated in detail. Our results show that the channel width has a considerable influence on conformational characteristics of the chain. It is found that at large Emax, the chromatin fibre undergoes a conformational transition from stretched state to coiled state with increasing the channel width. Additionally, the influence of the channel width is lowered with enhancing Emax. At small values of the channel width, the chains for different Emax exhibit a similar structure, namely, a stretched conformation