Pitfalls in Sample Preparation of Metalloproteins for Low-Temperature EPR: The Example of Alkaline Myoglobin

Due to fast relaxation processes of transition metal ions, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy of metalloproteins needs to be performed at cryogenic temperatures. To avoid damaging the biological system upon freezing, a cryoprotectant is generally added to the sample as a glassing agent. Even though cryoprotectants are expected to be inert substances, evidences in literature show their non-innocent role in altering the shape of EPR spectra of proteins and biological objects in general. In this work we conduct a systematic study on the impact of several experimental factors—such as buffer composition, choice of cryoprotectant, pH and temperature—on the EPR spectrum of myoglobin, taken as a reference system for being a well-characterized heme-containing protein. We focus on high-pH buffers to induce and investigate the alkaline transition of ferric myoglobin (pKa ~ 8.9). A combined approach of continuous-wave EPR and UV–visible absorption spectroscopy shows that using particular pairs of buffers and cryoprotectants determines a considerable pH variation in the sample and that this effect is enhanced at cryogenic temperature. In addition, phase memory times were measured to evaluate the efficiency of different cryoprotectants and compared with spectral linewidths in continuous-wave EPR. Our findings suggest that among the selected cryoprotectants ethylene glycol is rather effective, even more than the widely used glycerol, without having unwanted effects.

In Vitro Heme Coordination of a Dye-Decolorizing Peroxidase—The Interplay of Key Amino Acids, pH, Buffer and Glycerol

Dye-decolorizing peroxidases (DyPs) have gained interest for their ability to oxidize anthraquinone-derived dyes and lignin model compounds. Spectroscopic techniques, such as electron paramagnetic resonance and optical absorption spectroscopy, provide main tools to study how the enzymatic function is linked to the heme-pocket architecture, provided the experimental conditions are carefully chosen. Here, these techniques are used to investigate the effect of active site perturbations on the structure of ferric P-class DyP from Klebsiella pneumoniae (KpDyP) and three variants of the main distal residues (D143A, R232A and D143A/R232A). Arg-232 is found to be important for maintaining the heme distal architecture and essential to facilitate an alkaline transition. The latter is promoted in absence of Asp-143. Furthermore, the non-innocent effect of the buffer choice and addition of the cryoprotectant glycerol is shown. However, while unavoidable or indiscriminate experimental conditions are pitfalls, careful comparison of the effects of different exogenous molecules on the electronic structure and spin state of the heme iron contains information about the inherent flexibility of the heme pocket. The interplay between structural flexibility, key amino acids, pH, temperature, buffer and glycerol during in vitro spectroscopic studies is discussed with respect to the poor peroxidase activity of bacterial P-class DyPs.

Influence of the heme distal pocket on nitrite binding orientation and reactivity in Sperm Whale myoglobin

Nitrite binding to recombinant wild-type Sperm Whale myoglobin (SWMb) was studied using a combination of spectroscopic methods including room-temperature magnetic circular dichroism. These revealed that the reactive species is free nitrous acid and the product of the reaction contains a nitrite ion bound to the ferric heme iron in the nitrito- (O-bound) orientation. This exists in a thermal equilibrium with a low-spin ground state and a high-spin excited state and is spectroscopically distinct from the purely low-spin nitro- (N-bound) species observed in the H64V SWMb variant. Substitution of the proximal heme ligand, histidine-93, with lysine yields a novel form of myoglobin (H93K) with enhanced reactivity towards nitrite. The nitrito-mode of binding to the ferric heme iron is retained in the H93K variant again as a thermal equilibrium of spin-states. This proximal substitution influences the heme distal pocket causing the pKa of the alkaline transition to be lowered relative to wild-type SWMb. This change in the environment of the distal pocket coupled with nitrito-binding is the most likely explanation for the 8-fold increase in the rate of nitrite reduction by H93K relative to WT SWMb.

Altered structure and dynamics of pathogenic cytochrome c variants correlate with increased apoptotic activity

Mutation of cytochrome c in humans causes mild autosomal dominant thrombocytopenia. The role of cytochrome c in platelet formation, and the molecular mechanism underlying the association of cytochrome c mutations with thrombocytopenia remains unknown, although a gain-of-function is most likely. Cytochrome c contributes to several cellular processes, with an exchange between conformational states proposed to regulate changes in function. Here, we use experimental and computational approaches to determine whether pathogenic variants share changes in structure and function, and to understand how these changes might occur. Three pathogenic variants (G41S, Y48H, A51V) cause an increase in apoptosome activation and peroxidase activity. Molecular dynamics simulations of these variants, and two non-naturally occurring variants (G41A, G41T), indicate that increased apoptosome activation correlates with the increased overall flexibility of cytochrome c, particularly movement of the Ω loops. Crystal structures of Y48H and G41T complement these studies which overall suggest that the binding of cytochrome c to apoptotic protease activating factor-1 (Apaf-1) may involve an ‘induced fit’ mechanism which is enhanced in the more conformationally mobile variants. In contrast, peroxidase activity did not significantly correlate with protein dynamics. Thus, the mechanism by which the variants increase peroxidase activity is not related to the conformational dynamics of the native hexacoordinate state of cytochrome c. Recent molecular dynamics data proposing conformational mobility of specific cytochrome c regions underpins changes in reduction potential and alkaline transition pK was not fully supported. These data highlight that conformational dynamics of cytochrome c drive some but not all of its properties and activities.

Altered structure and dynamics of pathogenic cytochrome c variants correlate with increased apoptotic activity

Mutation of cytochrome c in humans causes mild autosomal dominant thrombocytopenia. The role of cytochrome c in platelet formation, and molecular mechanism underlying the association of cytochrome c mutations with thrombocytopenia remains unknown, although a gain-of-function is most likely. Cytochrome c contributes to several cellular processes, with exchange between conformational states proposed to regulate changes in function. Here we use experimental and computational approaches to determine whether pathogenic variants share changes in structure and function, and to understand how these changes might occur. We find that three pathogenic variants (G41S, Y48H, A51V) cause an increase in apoptosome activation and peroxidase activity. Molecular dynamics simulations of these variants, and two non-naturally occurring variants (G41A, G41T), indicate that increased apoptosome activation correlates with increased overall flexibility of cytochrome c, particularly movement of the Ω loops. This suggests that the binding of cytochrome c to apoptotic protease activating factor-1 (Apaf-1) may involve an “induced fit” mechanism which is enhanced in the more conformationally mobile variants. In contrast, peroxidase activity did not significantly correlate with protein dynamics suggesting that the mechanism by which the variants alter peroxidase activity is not related to the conformation dynamics of the hexacoordinate heme Fe state of cytochrome c analyzed in the simulations. Recent suggestions that conformational mobility of specific regions of cytochrome c underpins changes in reduction potential and the alkaline transition pK were not supported. These data highlight that conformational dynamics of cytochrome c drives some but not all of its properties and activities.

Monitoring alkaline transitions of yeast iso-1 cytochrome c at natural isotopic abundance using trimethyllysine as a native NMR probe

A solution 1H–14N HSQC experiment has been employed to monitor the alkaline transition of yeast iso-1 cytochrome c.

Effects of heme modification on oxygen affinity and cooperativity of human adult hemoglobin

We substituted strongly electron-withdrawing trifluoromethyl ( CF 3) group(s) as heme side chain(s) of human adult hemoglobin (Hb) to achieve large alterations of the heme electronic structure, in order to elucidate the relationship between the oxygen ( O 2) binding properties of Hb and the electronic properties of heme peripheral side chains. The obtained results were compared with those of similar studies performed on myoglobin (Mb), e.g. (Nishimura R, Matsumoto D, Shibata T, Yanagisawa S, Ogura T, Tai H, Matsuo T, Hirota S, Neya S, Suzuki A, and Yamamoto Y. Inorg. Chem. 2014; 53: 9156–9165). These two proteins shared the common feature of a decrease in O 2 affinity upon the CF 3 substitution(s). Using the P50 value, which is the partial pressure of O 2 required for 50% oxygenation of a protein, and the equilibrium constant ( p K a ) of the "acid-alkaline transition" in the met form of a protein as measures of the O 2 affinity and the electron density of heme Fe atom of the protein, respectively, a linear p K a - log (1/P50) relationship was demonstrated for the Hb and Mb systems. The native Hb, however, deviated from the p K a - log (1/P50) relationship, while the native Mb followed it. These results highlighted the significance of the vinyl side chains of the heme cofactor in the functional control of Hb through tertiary and quaternary structural changes upon the oxygenation of the protein.