In this study, a series of 3D FE simulations of a geosynthetic-reinforced pile-supported embankment (GRPE) design were conducted. The effect of the subsoil stiffness, friction and dilation angles of the fill, the fill height, the pile spacing, the surcharge load on the embankment, and the anisotropic tensile stiffness of the GR, the ground reaction curve (GRC), and the interfacial responses between the fill material and geosynthetic reinforcement (GR) were scrutinized. The numerical results showed how transfer of the vertical load towards the piles (load part A) and the related soil arches change with the subsoil stiffness, geometric parameters, and the vertical pressure on the embankment. Furthermore, the vertical load transferred through the GR (load part B) is reduced significantly with increasing subsoil stiffness, while the load part carried by the subsoil increases (load part C). The numerical results showed that the vertical stress distribution on the GR changes from an inverse-triangular shape for low subsoil stiffness to a uniform shape for high subsoil stiffness. This matches perfectly with the Concentric Arches model. For low subsoil stiffness, the tensile strains of the GR are concentrated at the corner of a square pile cap.