Surgical Treatment of Tympanic Membrane Retractions
Objective To report a modified technique of cartilage reinforcement tympanoplasty. To assess the safety and efficacy of this technique for symptomatic tympanic membrane retractions. Methods Retrospective analysis of patients with Pars Tensa retractions treated surgically between 2001 and 2007. The indications were discharge and hearing loss. Surgery involved excision of retracted segment, exposure of facial recess, removal of keratin and reinforcement with thinned tragal cartilage graft (cartilage thinned by cartilage cutter) and temporalis fascia. Paired T test was used to compare the mean ABG before and after surgery. Results 34 ears were operated on in 33 patients with an age range of 8 to 66 (mean 38). Full extent of the retraction was visible (Moderate) in 12 ears and not visible in 22 ears (Severe). Cholesteatoma was found in 10 ears (all in Severe group) and ossicular erosion was noticed in 29 ears. Follow-up ranged from 12 to 66 months (mean of 36 months). The success rate was 97% with recurrence of retraction in 1 ear. Air-bone gap improved in 31 ears, remained the same in 1 ear, and worsened in 2 ears. The pre- and postoperative mean ABG values were 24.3 (SD 9.5) and 17 (8.7). The difference was 7.3 p<0.0001(95% CI=4.8,9.9). Cholesteatoma recurred in 1 patient. Cholesteatoma presence and severity of retraction did not have any influence on the recurrence rate (Fisher's Exact Test). Conclusions High incidence of per-operative discovery of cholesteatoma (30%) in our series supports early, aggressive management of symptomatic retractions. Thinned cartilage is more effective with less chances of migration.