Eligibility of judges
Art 19 UPCA provides for a training framework which was included in the Agreement to help to improve the competence of judges and to ensure that knowledge of patent law and the UPC system is widely spread amongst the Member States of the UPC. The training framework will also be used to prepare applicants for their position as judges of the UPC as only nationals of a signatory state to the UPCA can be appointed as a judge of the Court. As noble as these goals may be, they must not fuel the possible misunderstanding that it would be sufficient to prove practical experience merely by participation in lectures, seminars, conferences, or mock trials. Such training elements are, of course, useful but can never compensate for lack of practical experience in handling patent cases.