The Case for a Progressive Benefits Tax
Opponents of redistributive taxation have long supported a “benefits” tax, which would tax individuals in accordance with the market value of the benefits they receive from the government. The question is, what market? A perfectly competitive market in which goods and services are priced at their marginal cost of production? A quasi-monopolistic market in which the supplier (here, the state) can price-discriminate among customers based on their willingness to pay? Some third alternative? Depending upon the answer, a benefits tax could yield radically different distributions of the tax burden, from a regressive to a steeply progressive rate structure. Benefits tax proponents have opted for a perfectly competitive market, but their own laissez-faire precommitments support a different answer, with radically different implications for the “right” rate structure.