Identification and Correction of Rotor Instability in an Oil-Free Gas Turbine

Author(s):  
Daniel R. Lubell ◽  
Jonathan L. Wade ◽  
Navjot S. Chauhan ◽  
John G. Nourse

The direction of advanced gas turbines and other turbomachinery has been towards oil-free designs, enabled by the significant improvements of high temperature foil bearings. The advantages of oil-free gas turbines have been studied and shown to be realistic. However, the oil-free technology is still at an early stage in its development relative to conventional oil lubricated turbomachinery systems which have been studied and manufactured for about 100 years, and the bearings even longer. Oil-free gas turbines are most successful as a system design initiated with oil-free bearings. Making these successful designs requires knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of integrating oil-free bearings. A common example is foil bearings, the type typically considered for oil-free gas turbines. These bearings are lower in damping than their oil lubricated counterparts. Therefore special considerations are made by the experienced oil-free gas turbine designer early in the design process. Knowledge of the opportunities for instability that are not as common in conventional turbomachinery provides value to the final design. This paper presents the identification and correction of rotor instability in an oil-free microturbine of a 65 kW system. The manufacturer put significant effort into identifying the root cause of the seemingly random occurrences of rotor instability, in order to improve yield for acceptance tests. Through the application of conventional rotordynamics theory and techniques, combined with 3-D imaging of complex cast parts, the root cause was identified as an Alford’s-type force at the turbine driven by critical machined and cast features of the turbine wheel that would not have been important in a conventional oil lubricated turbomachine. A successful corrective process has been put in place, providing final confirmation of the root cause.

Author(s):  
Daniel Lubell ◽  
Christopher DellaCorte ◽  
Malcolm Stanford

During the start-up and shut-down of a turbomachine supported on compliant foil bearings, before the bearings have full development of the hydrodynamic gas film, sliding occurs between the rotor and the bearing foils. Traditional solid lubricants (e.g., graphite, Teflon®) readily solve this problem at low temperature. High temperature operation, however, has been a key obstacle. Without a suitable high temperature coating, foil air bearing use is limited to about 300°C (570°F). In oil-free gas turbines, a hot section bearing presents a very aggressive environment for these coatings. A NASA developed coating, PS304, represents one tribological approach to this challenge. In this paper, the use of PS304 as a rotor coating operating against a hot foil gas bearing is reviewed and discussed. During the course of several long term, high cycle, engine tests, which included two coating related failures, the PS304 technology evolved and improved. For instance, a post deposition thermal treatment to improve dimensional stability, and improvements to the deposition process to enhance strength resulted from the engine evaluations. Largely because of this work, the bearing/coating combination has been successfully demonstrated at over 500°C (930°F) in an oil-free gas turbine for over 2500 hours and 2900 start-stop cycles without damage or loss of performance when properly applied. Ongoing testing at Glenn Research Center as part of a long term program is over 3500 hours and 150 cycles.


1980 ◽  
Vol 102 (3) ◽  
pp. 518-523
Author(s):  
S. J. Valentino

The increased demand for fuel conservation has provided the impetus for higher efficiency in the design of gas turbines and their operation. To conserve more fuel, regenerators must operate at higher temperatures and pressures, and must experience frequent on-off cycles. The design concept, methodology, and full-scale testing leading to the final design of the regenerator will be presented. Particular emphasis will be given to the importance of meaningful testing of both the regenerator and materials used. The necessity of having materials data, in the as-processed condition versus catalog data, for reliable design, is also presented.


Author(s):  
Stephen Garner ◽  
Zuhair Ibrahim

Gas turbines are a type of internal combustion engine and are used in a wide range of services powering aircraft of all types, as well as driving mechanical equipment such as pumps, compressors in the petrochemical industry, and generators in the electric utility industry. Similar to the reciprocating internal combustion engine in an automobile, energy (mechanical or electrical) is generated by the burning of a hydrocarbon fuel (i.e., jet fuel, diesel or natural gas). The core of a gas turbine engine is comprised of three main sections: the compressor section, the combustor section, and the turbine section. To ensure that a gas turbine operates safely, reliably, and with optimum performance, all gas turbines are provided with a control system designed either by the OEM or according to the OEM’s specification. The OEM-provided control systems will typically include complex and integrated subsystems such as (but not limited to): a graphic user interface, an engine management system (EMS or ECS), a safety related system (SRS), and a package control system (PCS) that may interface with a facilities’ existing computerized control systems. Any failure of the mechanical systems, electro-mechanical systems, or logic based control systems of a gas turbine can result in forced outage. A forced outage of a gas turbine, whether in a mechanical service, such as pipelines, or in either a simple cycle or combined cycle power generation installation results in a reduction of system availability and therefore a loss in revenue. The significant capital investment in a gas turbine system necessitates a high degree of reliability and system availability while reducing forced outages. A power plant can minimize occurrences of forced outages and optimize recovery of capacity by effectively combining proactive and reactive solutions. This paper will discuss both proactive and reactive programs as well as their implementation in order to answer the key questions that often surround an outage: How is outage time minimized while increasing reliability and system availability? What went wrong and who or what is responsible? How soon can the unit or the plant get back online? And what operational or maintenance considerations are needed to prevent a similar recurrence. Proactive approaches to be discussed include process hazard analyses (PHA) such as hazard and operability studies (HAZOP), hazard identification (HAZID), layer-of-protection analyses (LOPA), what-if analyses, and quantitative risk assessments (QRA) in addition to failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA); and failure mode, effects and criticality analysis (FMECA). Reactive approaches to be discussed include various root cause analysis (RCA) and failure analysis (FA) techniques and methodologies such as fault-tree analysis. Case studies and some lessons learned will also be presented to illustrate the methods.


Author(s):  
Robert Lundberg ◽  
Rolf Gabrielsson

The European EUREKA project EU 209 or AGATA - Advanced Gas Turbine for Automobiles is a program dedicated to the development of three critical ceramic components; i. catalytic combustor, ii. radial turbine wheel, iii. static heat exchanger, designed for a 60 kW turbogenerator hybrid electric vehicle. The objective is to develop and test the three components as a full scale feasibility study with an industrial perspective. The AGATA partners represent car manufacturers as well as companies and research institutes in the turbine, catalyst and ceramic material fields in France and Sweden. The program has been running since early 1993 with good progress in all three sub-projects. The turbine wheel design is now completed. FEM calculations indicate that the maximum stress occur during cold start and is below 300 MPa. Extensive mechanical testing of the Si3N4 materials from AC Cerama and C&C has been performed. The catalytic combustor operates uncooled at 1350°C. This means a severe environment for both the active catalyst and the ceramic honeycomb substrates. Catalysts with high activity even after aging at 1350°C have been developed. Ceramic honeycomb substrates that survive this temperature have also been defined. The catalytic combustor final design is ready and the configurations which will be full scale tested have been selected. The heat exchanger will be a ceramic recuperator with 90 % efficiency. Both a tube concept and a plate concept have been studied. The plate concept has been chosen for further work. Sub-scale plate recuperators made of either cordierite or SiC have been manufactured by C&C and tested.


Author(s):  
Paolo Di Sisto ◽  
Massimiliano Grosso

Gas turbine rotors must be reliable, stable and durable because they operate in a demanding centrifugal and thermal environment without being maintained and replaced for many years. The design of a rotor is one of the most challenging tasks that gas turbine design team should face because its basic architecture has to be decided in the early design stage together with the gas turbine flow path and combustion architecture. A wrong initial decision may require a substantial modification of the gas turbine cross section and consequently have a dramatic impact on the project schedule. This paper introduces readers to the main aspects of the gas turbine rotor design, including the multidiscipline design tools that allow a quick rotor components shaping nowadays. Thanks to the use of some of the most popular gas turbines in the O&G application, this paper will explain how the rotor design has developed over the last decades. An example of how today a new rotor is designed will be provided, by describing some of the main topics analyzed during the conceptual design phase of a General Electric (GE) engine that will be on the market since the 2016. The paper also describes some of the biggest challenges that rotor design teams will have to face in the next future.


Author(s):  
Riccardo Da Soghe ◽  
Cosimo Bianchini ◽  
Mirko Micio ◽  
Jacopo D’Errico ◽  
Francesco Bavassano

The desired reduction of secondary air consumption of gas turbines is especially challenging when the sealing of stator-rotor cavities is concerned, where it is necessary to guarantee integrity against hot gas ingestion. Sealing and thermal performance of gas turbine stator-rotor cavities are directly dependent on the rim configuration. This paper provides a CFD-based characterization of heavy-duty gas turbine wheel-spaces when dealing with real engine operating conditions and geometries. Focusing on the rim seal configuration, the geometrical arrangement of the ingestion-cavity, the buffer-cavity and the inner cavities were investigated to improve the ingress flow-discouraging behaviour. The study reveals that the most important geometrical parameters affecting the rim sealing effectiveness are those related to the ingestion-cavity. Moreover, an empirical model to predict the stator-rotor cavity sealing performance in off-design conditions was proposed. The model, that consists in an extension of a well-known literature approach, performed well at the analysed operating conditions, confirming to be an excellent tool for the early design phases. Finally, an investigation on the unsteady behaviour of the seal highlights a coupling with an acoustic mode of the cavity, suggesting possible reasons to justify the presence of rotating structures embedded into the cavity flow.


Author(s):  
Gerrit Kool ◽  
Jacques van den Elshout ◽  
Eric Vogelaar ◽  
Ron van Gestel ◽  
Andre´ Mom

Maintenance costs of gas turbines are mainly driven by replacement costs of expensive parts. Reconditioning of these parts is considered to decrease the costs significantly, but it is the impression that re-used parts tend to be more involved in part failures. This is sometimes related to microstructural changes in the substrate materials owing to part repair. One hundred and nine (109) unscheduled gas turbine component failure cases have been collected and analyzed to identify causes of failure and contributing factors, and also to provide guidance on corrective measures such as design changes, new repair methods, missing information links and future R&D efforts. It was found that the most frequently reported failure mechanisms are mechanical and thermal fatigue and changes in the microstructure. Fifty percent (50%) of the reported failure cases have a root cause in the original component design and repair design, and consequently permanent solutions can be achieved by design modifications only. The paper concludes with the identification of knowledge gaps.


Author(s):  
Kenji Fujiwara ◽  
Narihito Nakagawa ◽  
Kenji Kobayashi ◽  
Shinya Yokoi ◽  
Tsutomu Kihara ◽  
...  

An unique ceramic material produced through unidirectional solidification with eutectic composition of two-phase oxides was introduced recently. This composite material has the microstructure of coupled networks of two single crystals interpenetrate each other without grain boundaries. Depending on this microstructure this material, called Melt Growth Composite (MGC), can sustain its room temperature strength up to 1,700 (near its melting point) and offer strong oxidization-resistant ability, making its characteristics quite ideal for the gas turbine application. Our research project on MGC started in 2001 with the objective of establishing component technologies for MGC application to the high temperature components of the gas turbine engine. This paper outlines the results of our research so far at the early stage of the project.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Noor Azman Mohamat Nor ◽  
Andrew Findlay

Abstract The focus of this case study is the analysis of offshore Oil & Gas facilities recorded downtime data which are classified into gas turbine downtime categories and causes. Each event is then correlated with the maintenance repair records to determine the respective root cause. The key objective of this study is to establish the Critical Success Factors (CSF) for unit health after a gas turbine has been in operation for more than 10 years. The outcome is used to enhance the unit performance, efficiency, maintainability, and operability. As a first step, Content Analysis technique was employed to systematically decipher and organize the downtime causes from collected data. Over 500 data samples collected over a period of 3 years were sorted into relevant categories and causes: comprising a total downtime of 11,410 hours. The downtime data, which is interval scale in nature that is in ‘hours’, is meticulously tabulated against respective downtime categories and causes location by location for the 11 gas turbines sites and correlating this to the repair work. Within scope is downtime related to: Forced Outage Automatic Trip; Failure to Start; Forced Outage Manual Shutdown; and Maintenance Unscheduled while those out of scope are Non-Curtailing and Reserve Shutdown as these are external to gas turbine operational influence. In the second step, descriptive statistics analysis was carried out to understand the key downtime drivers by categories. Pattern recognition is used to identify whether the cause is a “One Time Event”, “Random Event” or “Recurring Event” to confirm data integrity and establish the problem statement. This approach assists in the discovery of erroneous data that could mislead the outcome of statistical analysis. Pattern recognition through data stratification and clustering classifies issue impact as reliability or availability. Simplistic analyses can miss major customer impact issues such as: frequent small shutdowns that do not accumulate a lot of hours per event but cause operational disruption; or infrequent time consuming events resulting from a lack of trained personnel, spares shortages, and difficulty in troubleshooting. In the third step, statistical correlation analysis was applied to establish the relationship between gas turbine downtime and repair works in determining the root causes. Benchmarking these analyses outcome with the actual equipment landscape provides for high probability root cause, thus facilitating solutions for improved site reliability and availability. The study identified CSF in the following areas: personnel training and competency; correct maintenance philosophy and its execution in practice; and life cycle management including obsolescence and spares management. Near term recommendations on changes to site operations or equipment based on OEM guidelines and current available best practices are summarized for each site analyzed.


Author(s):  
Paolo Del Turco ◽  
Michele D’Ercole ◽  
Ahmed Ossama Fouad ◽  
Riccardo Carta ◽  
Alessandro Russo ◽  
...  

Given the constant increase in world energy demand, gas turbine operators are continuously looking for turbo-machinery improvements, both in terms of increased power and extended maintenance intervals, limiting, as much as possible, the downtime for upgrading. In 2006, GE Oil & Gas engineers launched the Power Crystal™ development program to enhance the output power or extend the maintenance interval of the MS5002C and D heavy duty gas turbines. This effort resulted in an upgrade kit potentially to be installed during a standard major inspection, which include a single crystal material 1st stage high pressure turbine blade and additional improvements, such as new coatings for combustor hardware and improved cooling of the 1st stage high pressure turbine nozzle and 1st stage high pressure turbine wheel. The upgrade kit was validated through an extensive test campaign, which included test-rig component tests in advance of the First Engine to Test (FETT). All critical-to-quality parameters of the gas turbine were investigated, such as turbine gas path component temperatures and stresses, performance and operability. This paper describes the background for the upgrade, discusses the new kit features, how the test program was built and conducted, and reports the experience accumulated on the gas turbine during the initial field operation.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document